加拿大到底发生了什么……

 
 
@Cosmicbrownies42
I can't understand a single word the staff at Tim's are saying, they're ignorant asf, talk faster than an auctioneer, and my order is always a suprise.
 
蒂姆霍顿店里员工说的话我一个字都听不明白，那些人也太不懂礼貌了，说话比拍卖师报价还快，每次点单都像在开盲盒。
 
@MrFinch-m5c
What a lovely country that forces their own people to move out so that they can use cheap developing-country labors, and giving those people PR and citizenship. Soon this country will full of people who speak English and French with Indian accent or Chinese accent, but still call themselves Canadians.
 
好一个“美好”的国度啊！硬是逼着自己本国的老百姓搬出去，就为了能用上发展中国家来的廉价劳动力，还给人发永久居留权和公民身份。要不了多久，这国家就会到处充斥着带印度口音或中国口音的英语和法语使用者，可他们居然还自称为加拿大人！
 
@xXGR4NTXx474
I live in America, southwest. I live in a diverse state, only 34% white (nevermind it being 90% white when my grandpa was growing up). I’ve been told “go back to Europe” for being a white guy, despite my family being in California for 5 generations, and in America since the New English settlers. I finally took a family trip to Europe last month, and the situation is… insane. Only went to Paris and Amsterdam. Never seen as many Muslims or Sub-Saharan Africans in my entire life. And I’m not from some low density farm town, I live near Los Angeles. If Europe won’t stop the replacement of our people, why do they expect me to stay silent here?!
 
我生活在美国西南部，我所在的州确实多元化得很，白人只占百分之三十四——虽然我爷爷那辈人长大的时候，白人的比例还高达百分之九十呢。就因为我是个白人，居然有人叫我“滚回欧洲去”，可我们家在加州已经整整五代人了，从新英格兰移民时期就在美国扎根。上个月我终于全家去欧洲转了转，那情形简直让人目瞪口呆。我只去了巴黎和阿姆斯特丹，但我这辈子都没见过这么多穆斯林和撒哈拉以南的非洲人。我可不是从什么人口稀少的农业小镇来的，我家就在洛杉矶附近啊。如果欧洲自己都不阻止我们的族裔被取代的趋势，凭什么指望我在这儿保持沉默？
 
@tmib6744
Been watching things for the last 40 years, and while I still don’t know if it’s been orchestrated by someone homegrown or afar, someone really started to stifle the Canadian economy some time ago. Wages vs cost of living went down. Reproduction went down. Now we have immigrants using it like a drop over, realizing it’s set up to not get ahead and then leaving.
Wage covers living expenses, and the business owners are certainly not going broke.
 
过去四十年里我一直在观察各种现象，虽然至今仍然不确定这究竟是本土势力还是境外势力在暗中操纵，但确实有人在若干年前就开始扼杀加拿大的经济。工资与生活成本的对比持续下降，人口再生产也在萎缩。如今连移民都把这个地方当作临时跳板，发现根本难以出头后就纷纷离开。
工资勉强覆盖生活开销，但企业老板们可绝对没有亏钱。
 
@coalsilvermuzzle3111
I'm a Canadian senor, although I'm out of the work force. Due to the cost of living in Canada I have to go back to work.
But that aside, I think they should cancel all work visas and start to hire Canadian citizen. Not temporary ones, but people actually ones born in Canada, with at least 2 generations.
Don't like what I have to say, to f'in bad.
 
作为加拿大老年人，我虽然本已退出劳动力市场，但迫于生活成本的压力不得不重新工作。
撇开个人的处境不谈，我认为政府应该取消所有工作签证，优先雇佣真正意义上的加拿大公民——不是临时居民，而是在本土出生且至少有两代家族根基的人。
不爱听这些话？那就憋着吧。
 
@sagmilling
Greetings from sunny Uruguay. I am a provisional resident here having left Canada a couple of years ago. Moved my company to Ireland also two years ago. Big expense to depart, but that's all paid for now and I an free from Canada's BS.
 
来自阳光明媚的乌拉圭问候。两年前离开加拿大后，我在此地获得临时居留权，同期也将公司迁至爱尔兰。虽然撤离的代价高昂，但如今已清偿所有成本，终于摆脱了加拿大那摊烂事。
 
@IllpayForTheWindows
It's racist not to see someone's skin color but it's also racist to notice that a whole influx of people of color suddenly entered your area.
 
忽视肤色是种族主义，可突然意识到有色人种大规模涌入自己的社区竟然也算种族主义？
 
@2ScoopsOfSmackMaster
Mid 30s Canadian here, our politicians don't work for us (none of the major parties, not just the one in power). They are all beholden to the housing ponzi scheme and corporate interests, we are not a serious country (and don't even start with the 51st state shit, not at all interested in that, yanks). Yet my fellow Canadians keep blindly electing the same fucking parties; the bread and circuses, pitting left vs right is extremely effective. This country is fucked, and I am tired of getting screwed at every turn.
To any young (ish?) fellow Canadians reading this, don't let family or friends be the reason you stay in Canada (my mistake, working on it) and for your own sake emigrate, this country will not stop sacrificing your future.
 
我这位三十多岁的加拿大人不得不说咱们的政客压根就不是为老百姓服务的——所有主要的政党都一个样，我可不是单单指现在执政的那个。他们全都深陷在房地产庞氏骗局和企业利益的泥潭里，说实在的，咱们这国家根本算不上个正经国家（也别跟我扯什么第五十一个州那套，我完全不想听这种鬼话，美国佬）。可悲的是我的加拿大同胞还在盲目地选那些该死的同一批政党；这种"面包与马戏"的把戏，还有刻意挑动左右派对立的伎俩，实在是效果显著。这个国家彻底没救了，我真是受够了处处被人坑的滋味。
任何年轻一点的加拿大同胞们，如果你们看到这段话，千万别让家人朋友成为你们留在加拿大的理由（这可是我的血泪教训，现在正在努力摆脱中），为了你们自己着想，赶紧移民吧——这个国家会毫不犹豫地牺牲你们的未来。
 
@RobertP.Trebor
I wanna get mad at this video and say it's not that bad... but then I remembered I'm a young professional leaving the GTA to work abroad because my options are so much better elsewhere
 
我本来想对这个视频发火，说情况哪有这么糟糕……但转念一想，我自己不就是个正要离开大多伦多地区去国外工作的年轻专业人士吗？说到底，还是因为在别处我能有更好的选择啊。
 
@ItsUdenity
I'm living in Canada and my family used to live in our 20 year old townhouse for over $1200 per month, before we were kicked out for no reason, even though we had paid the rent in full and other expenses. We have been living in our grandmother's house for 8 months now because living is to expensive. Canada's is going to hell.
 
我现在生活在加拿大，之前我们一家人住在一个有二十年历史的老联排别墅里，月租超过一千两百加元。可是后来我们竟然被无缘无故地赶了出来，明明我们已经付清了所有租金和其他费用。这八个月来我们一直借住在奶奶家里，因为现在的居住成本实在高得离谱。加拿大这个地方真是要完蛋了。
 
@AloneRacecar
Canadian here. And I can confirm that it’s sad to see how things have unfortunately been going downhill with the economy, or dare I say in general. However throughout our lifetime Canada will come and go dozens of leaders and political powers, it doesn’t matter if it’s Conservative or Liberal. BOTH parties have their fair share of faults in this country. Sometimes it feels like it doesn’t matter one way or another.
While I am aware of the issues that are ongoing and the fact that things need to be improved quite a lot, my love for this country still remains. I remember watching Bofang’s video about this very topic, and he believed that to potentially turn things around: It's not about going back in time, it's about learning of what made this country work in the first place to create a whole new golden era.
I think he might be on to something if you ask me.
 
身为加拿大人，我不得不承认眼看着国家的经济——甚至可以说整体国势——这么一路走下坡路，实在是令人痛心。不过话说回来，在我们有生之年，加拿大政坛来来去去的领导人和执政党团少说也有几十拨了，不管是保守派还是自由派掌权，其实都一个样。这两个党派在治理国家方面，谁都有数不清的失职之处。有时候我真觉得不管选谁上台，结果根本没什么差别。
虽然我清楚地意识到了当前存在的种种问题，也明白很多方面亟需改进，但我对这片土地的热爱始终不曾消减。记得之前看过博方关于这个议题的视频，他提出了一个观点我觉得很有见地：要想扭转局面，关键不是开倒车回到过去，而是得弄明白这个国家当年之所以能兴旺发达的根本原因，从而开创一个全新的黄金时代。
要我说啊，他这个思路还真是找对方向了。
 
@spnked9516
I don't think there is any viable way out of the current situation. In the simplest terms possible, the kinds of changes we need would require Canadians to sacrifice in the immediate short term (i.e. the next decade or so), and the reality is that the average Canadian just isn't willing to do that.
Expect things to get worse.
 
说实在的，我看不出当前的局面还有什么可行的出路。往最简单里说，我们所需要的种种变革，都要求加拿大人在短期内（也就是未来十年左右）做出牺牲，可现实情况是普通老百姓根本不愿意这么做。
大家还是做好情况继续恶化的心理准备吧。
 
@westindie8561
Most of the jobs created are also part-time. I hope those that voted for Carney are ready to go fight against Russia. I say they should go when Carney conscxts Canadians and also the immigrants too.
 
新增的就业岗位大部分也都是兼职而已，但愿那些给卡尼投票的人都准备好去跟俄罗斯打仗了。要我说，等卡尼开始征召加拿大公民还有移民参军的时候，这帮人就该自己主动上前线。
 
@jamesmotiv8989
Also, yep, my wifes best friend is a researcher. She has a doctorate but is not what you would call a doctor. She went to school for like 9 years and was working at that school after making like $28 an hour or about 80K a year. She just moved to the U.S. for the same job making 130K USD. After the difference in our dollar its double. She's also super bleeding heart internet left and hates guns and most men but moved to the place she deemed most toxic just to survive. That is where we are at.
 
再说个真实的例子，我太太最好的闺蜜就是一个研究员。她虽然拿了博士学位，但并不是那种看病的医生。她读了差不多九年书，毕业后就在母校工作，时薪大概28加元，折合年薪八万左右。结果人家刚跳槽到美国干同样的工作，直接拿到13万美元年薪。算上汇率差之后，这个收入简直翻了一番。更讽刺的是她本来是个特别理想主义的网络左派，既反感枪支也讨厌多数男性，如今却为了生存不得不搬去她自己口中"最有毒"的地方。咱们的现状已经糟糕到这种地步了。
 
@MarcinMoka1
I immigrated from Poland with my family 30 years ago because we wanted to be Canadian. We recently, along with thousands of other, especially east and south Europeans, moved back.
 
三十年前我们全家从波兰移民过来，就是因为一心想要成为加拿大人。可最近却和成千上万人一样——特别是东欧和南欧裔的移民——全都选择回流故土。
 
@Shivera1963
The capitalists have always wanted to import cheap labor - especially the kind that will not complain about abuses by employers. I would like to know how so many people are allowed into Canada who cannot speak either English or French fluently, if at all. When I immigrated to Canada it was a requirement that you speak one of the official languages.
 
资本家们一直都想引进廉价的劳动力——特别是那种就算遭到雇主剥削也不会吭声的。我真搞不懂，加拿大怎么会允许这么多连英语法语都说不利索的人入境。当初我移民加拿大时，硬性规定必须掌握一门官方语言才行。
 
@leapnlarry
I am a dual citizen, us/canada, i have lived in the us for the last 45 years, i spent two months in Ontario for the first time in decades, i was amazed at the difference in population, it was like i was visiting a third world country. I thought about moving back to canada permanently but, not anymore. Thanks for this kind of content, this is what has really changed my mind. Larry
 
我是美加双重公民，过去45年都生活在美国。隔了几十年头一回到安大略待了两个月，简直被人口结构的变化惊到了——恍惚间还以为到了第三世界国家。我本来考虑过搬回加拿大长住，现在彻底打消这个念头了。感谢这类内容，真正让我看清了现实。拉里敬上。
 
@TheLiamster
I live in the UK and the exact same problems are happening here. I’m honestly worried for our future. We have a problem with a huge influx of immigrants being used for cheap labour and essentially skewing the job market leaving native Brits worse off. Unfortunately immigration has been politicised and tensions inflamed to the point where any meaningful conversation can’t even happen without shouting, name calling and even violence. Unfortunately some people are using it as an excuse for racism and xenophobia which is horrible or are trying to mask it under the guise of “nationalism”. People are even rioting and vandalising public property. Of course we can and should accommodate refugees and have some level of immigration but the current rate is unsustainable and something needs to be done about it.
 
我生活在英国，这里也正在发生一模一样的问题。说实在的，我真的很为我们未来的处境感到担忧。眼下我们面临的核心矛盾在于大量涌入的移民被当作廉价劳动力使用，这种状况从根本上扭曲了就业市场的公平性，导致本地英国人的日子反而过得更加艰难。更糟糕的是移民问题如今已经被高度政治化，社会的紧张气氛煽动到如此极端的地步，以至于任何试图理性讨论的对话最终都难免演变成大吼大叫、人身攻击、甚至暴力冲突。令人遗憾的是有些人正以此为借口散布种族主义和仇外情绪——这种行为实在太恶劣了；还有人试图用“爱国主义”当作遮羞布来掩盖他们排外的真实意图，现在甚至发展到有人上街骚乱、故意破坏公共财物的地步。当然，我们能够也应当为难民提供人道主义庇护，并保持一定规模的移民通道，但目前的接收速度已经完全超出负荷，我们必须采取有效的措施来应对这个局面。
 
@AandM21
I moved out because I was jobless from July 2022 when my baby was born and was jobless until I moved out. That job that was paying me 27 bucks hourly, employers were offering 17 and 18 just a little above minimum wages. The temporary workers (student) started doing those jobs without an experience, skills and knowing the background of it.
 
我选择搬离的根本原因是从2022年7月孩子出生后就一直失业，这种状态持续到不得不离开的那天。之前那份时薪27加元的工作，现在雇主们只肯开17、18加元，比最低工资高不了多少。更糟的是连毫无经验、技能和行业背景的临时工（学生）都开始抢着做这些工作了。
 
@Fae_Rust
born and raised here, 25yrs old. I cant get my life started... no one is paying a wage that matches our cost of living here. Student debt is drowning me. I need to leave...
 
我在这里出生长大，如今已经25岁了，却根本没办法真正开始自己的生活……因为根本没有雇主愿意支付匹配本地生活成本的工资。学生贷款都快把我淹没了，我必须离开这个鬼地方。
 
@kazwalker764
I'm waiting to see how the Alberta independence referendum goes next year, the latest polls show it sitting at around 45% in favor of independence, so there's hope.
If Alberta chooses independence, I'll stay in the former province, and newly minted country I was born in.
If Alberta chooses to remain a colony of Ottawa, then it'll be time for me to find somewhere other than Canada to live.
 
我正在观望明年阿尔伯塔独立公投的结果，最新的民调显示支持独立的比例大概在45%左右，所以还是很有希望的。假如阿尔伯塔选择独立，我就会留在这片生我养我的土地——尽管那时它已从加拿大一省变成新兴的国家。但如果阿尔伯塔决定继续做渥太华的殖民地，那我就只能彻底离开加拿大，去别处寻找安身之所了。
 
@mutatedAi
Last year I moved my money out of Canada and into another country because the taxes in Canada are just ridiculous. I am a Canadian patriot, but just like Carney did, it makes no sense to keep money in Canada once wealth grows enough.
What the liberals do not realize or maybe they do not care is a country can only be taxed so much before diminishing returns hits.
And I think that is where we are now. Anyone who makes any decent money in Canada moves it out of country or they end up moving their entire family out.
A major changes needs to happen
 
去年我把资金全部从加拿大转移到其他国家，就因为那边的税收政策实在荒唐到令人发指。我虽然是个忠实的加拿大爱国者，可像卡尼那样操作，财富积累到一定程度还留在国内根本说不通。
自由党那些人要么是没意识到，要么根本不在乎：一个国家能征收的税收是有上限的，超过临界点就会适得其反。
依我看加拿大现在正处在这样的危机边缘。但凡在加拿大赚到可观收入的人，不是把资金转移到海外，就是举家移民离开了这个国家。
彻底的变革已经迫在眉睫。