这位16岁的日本女孩为何沦为无家可归者

@Sin606
I like this video a lot, I don't enjoy the situation but it feels like USA and Japan has similar issues that we'd just never noticed. Over here we have a severe issue with student loans and college is a pipeline to eternal debt because it's treated as a debt that can't even be removed if you file for bankruptcy. We also have an issue with single mothers, but I can't even say if it's the same...but because of how humans work there will always be the person who prioritize pleasure and neglects responsibility sadly. I know while this video was about women, would you consider doing a follow-up about the men side? I didn't think the situation would ever be used to create scammers and if feels like higher learning other than for something super specific is a nationwide scam, because you'll end up doing unsavory things to keep your head above water.

我很喜欢这段视频，虽然我并不喜欢这种情况，但我感觉美国和日本也有类似的问题，只是我们从未注意到。在我们这里，学生贷款问题很严重，大学是通向永恒债务的管道，因为它被视为一种债务，即使申请破产也无法消除。我们也有单亲母亲的问题，但我甚至不能说这是否相同......但由于人类的运作方式，总会有一些人把享乐放在首位而忽视了责任，这很可悲。我知道这个视频是关于女性的，你能考虑做一个关于男性方面的后续视频吗？我不认为这种情况会被用来制造骗局，如果觉得除了超级特殊的东西之外，其他的高等教育都是全国范围内的骗局，因为你最终会做一些不光彩的事情来保持你的头脑清醒。

@NeostormXLMAX
Usa caused most of the current issues of japan lMao, look up the plaza accord and us dumping strategies targeting japan in the 80s

日本现在的问题大部分都是美国造成的，笑死我了，查查广场协议和上世纪80年代美国针对日本的倾销战略吧。

@Labyrinth6000
@NeostormXLMAX duh, America didn’t want to see Japan surpass them, that’s why their bubble burst in the 90s

@NeostormXLMAX 咄，美国不想看到日本超过他们，这就是为什么他们的泡沫在上世纪90年代破灭了的原因。

@blakemckee295
Here in the US I turned 18 and went into a skilled trade, you can make middle-middle high income doing construction here. Sometimes more than college graduates. The pipe dream has been sold for so long decades upon decades that you have to go to college you have to go to college you have to go to college and now there's a huge demand for people in construction and skilled trades that you can make a great living by avoiding college.

在美国，我18岁就进入了技术行业，在这里做建筑可以赚到中高收入，有时比大学毕业生的收入还高。几十年来，“你必须上大学，你必须上大学，你必须上大学”的空想已经被灌输了很久，而现在，建筑和技术行业对人才的需求量非常大，不上大学也能过上好日子。

@foogod4237
This is a very interesting video, thank you for covering this subject.
However, I think you may be using the word "scholarship" wrong in some places. Scholarships are when a business or charitable organization gives money to a student for use in their education, because of their past performance or because they meet some particular criteria. Scholarship money does not need to be repaid, so it is not a debt.
The debts you are referring to are typically referred to as "student loans", which are different from "scholarships" (gifts).

这是一段非常有趣的视频，感谢您对这一主题的介绍。
不过，我认为您在某些地方可能用错了“奖学金”这个词。奖学金是指企业或慈善机构因学生过去的表现或符合某些特定标准而向学生提供的用于教育的资金。奖学金无需偿还，因此它不是债务。
您所说的债务通常是指“学生贷款”，它与“奖学金”（礼物）是不同的。

@magnumrpg
I have always liked a lot about japanese culture to the point i am once again trying to learn the language but, I know no country is perfect its good there is videos like this one exposing the flaws in a down to earth way. i'll be checking your content much more from now on you earned a sub

我一直都很喜欢日本文化，以至于我又一次尝试学习这门语言，但是我知道没有一个国家是完美的，好在有这样的视频，以脚踏实地的方式揭露了日本文化的缺陷。

@armartin0003
Bravo Meshida. Stand up for the young women of Japan. They deserve to have the luxury of marrying for love without fear, as all people do. If Japan truly wants to solve its population problem, this needs to be addressed. Because having sex without commitment makes it near impossible to have strong stable bonds with others romantically. Without a deep bond and passion, you can't trust a spouse and you don't want children.

太棒了，Meshida。你为日本的年轻女性挺身而出，她们理应像所有人一样毫无顾忌地为爱结婚。如果日本真的想解决人口问题，他们就必须解决这个问题，因为没有承诺的性行为几乎不可能与他人建立牢固稳定的爱情纽带。没有深厚的感情和激情，你就无法信任配偶，也不想要孩子。

@cbradley857
If they are both working day and night. They are just too tired to have kids. That is a reality for many Japanese couples. Money is the number one cause for all divorces around the globe.

如果他们都没日没夜地工作，那么生孩子就太累了，这是许多日本夫妇的现实。钱是全世界所有离婚的首要原因。

@zechariahp8206
I could solve their population problem if they're ok with some half gaijin children.

我可以解决他们的人口问题，如果他们能接受一些半混血儿的话。

@octane7047
@zechariahp8206 If gov can pay for all child expense and for the labour people have to put in raising the child, people will have kids. If gov don't pay, then there will be no solution.

@zechariahp8206如果政府能支付孩子的所有费用和人们养育孩子所付出的劳动，那么人们就会生小孩。如果政府不支付，那就没有解决办法了。

@restlessfae2407
@zechariahp8206 That isn't going to solve the problem. There are already mixed kids in japan and the fathers leave the country. And leave the Japanese women they are involved with as single mothers. So that won't help because a lot of foreign men are no better.

@zechariahp8206 这解决不了问题，日本已经有混血儿了，他们的父亲都离开了这个国家并让与他们有关系的日本妇女成了单身母亲。所以这也无济于事，因为很多外国男人也没好到哪里去。

@douglasharveyii
Sad to see still many places won't hire these young ladies out of college for fear they will leave once they start families. Just today I saw at least three companies in Japan- Mitsubishi Heavy Industries, Toyota, and Panasonic, are actively searching out women from universities, and are offering scholarships to those in the 'STEM' fields to work for them. They will offer much more than most women can get today in terms of money, at the very least. We can only hope this is a start to a better life for the ladies of your great nation.

很遗憾看到仍然有很多地方不愿意雇用这些大学毕业的年轻女士，因为担心她们一旦成家就会离开。就在今天，我看到日本至少有三家公司--三菱重工、丰田和松下正在积极寻找大学女生，并为那些在“STEM”领域工作的人提供奖学金。至少在金钱方面，他们提供的奖学金要比现在大多数女性所能得到的多得多。我们只能希望这将是你们伟大祖国的女性过上更好生活的一个开始。

@GurraDesu
I agree with your point about the work law reforms. It really does feel like the politicians wanted to impoverish women particularly to create a flood in the sex work field so there would be younger and cheaper prostitutes.
The more I learn about the non-tourist version of Japan the less I want to move there for work.

我同意你关于劳动法改革的观点，因为这确实让人觉得政客们想让妇女陷入贫困，尤其是想在性工作领域制造来源，这样就会有更年轻、更廉价的妓女。
我对非旅游版的日本了解得越多，就越不想去那里工作。

@StarboyXL9
While I'm all for cheaper prostitutes the reality is those are women who should be raising happy families for Japan's future. So I have to agree.

虽然我支持廉价妓女，但现实情况是这些女性应该为日本的未来养育幸福的家庭，所以我必须同意。

@JundArbiter
@StarboyXL9 Japan isn't really known for birthing children at the moment. And I think that the rate is still going down so it's not just that the birth numbers are lower than the deaths, it's like increasing in that direction.

@StarboyXL9 日本目前并不以生育闻名，而且我认为日本的生育率还在下降，所以不仅仅是出生人数低于死亡人数，而是在朝着这个方向增长。

@Suicide_Kid
For one it’s a cash society meaning nobody really knows how much anyone is making unless the person paying wants to report their payment to the government for a 100% tax deduction on the money spent. If you run a small business selling directly to consumers you’re completely off the grid, so if you work part time and make fuck all money on paper you can’t really force them to pay. It’s also the general way relationships work in Japan, maybe more so than other countries where a girl will have a kid with an attractive person and then find a less attractive person to pay for it. Infidelity among females in Japan is also really high. Why would you pay someone that’s fucking a bunch of other dudes when they’re probably just gonna spend it on getting their nails done. A lot of kids struggle as a child but it toughens them up. I grew up in Japan in an abusive household and tried to kms a couple times, but once you get past that you learn to live for others instead of for yourself and you realize the beauty of the system, and it’s probably one of the reasons theres no PC culture. It might seem weird but it’s a win-win for everyone imo.

首先，这是一个现金社会，这意味着没有人真正知道每个人赚了多少钱，除非付钱的人想向政府报告他们的付款以便对所花的钱进行100%的减税。如果你经营的是一家直接向消费者销售的小企业，你就完全不需要向政府报税，所以如果你是兼职，赚的钱都是纸面上的，你就不能强迫他们付钱。这也是日本两性关系的一般运作方式，也许比其他国家更甚，因为在其他国家，女孩会和一个有魅力的人生个孩子，然后找一个没那么有魅力的人为其买单。日本女性的不忠率也非常高，你为什么要付钱给一个和其他男人上床的人，而她们可能只是把钱花在做指甲上呢。日本的很多孩子小时候都在挣扎，但这会让他们变得坚强。我在日本一个受虐待的家庭长大，有几次想要自杀，但一旦你克服了这一点，你就会学会为他人而不是为自己而活，你就会意识到这个系统的美妙之处，这可能也是没有个人主义文化的原因之一。虽然这可能看起来很奇怪，但在我看来，这对每个人来说都是双赢。

@esploratoredelvuoto9204
The solution I think is simply to leave Tokyo and live somewhere a little more rural, since Tokyo is expensive and overpopulated, and it's also difficult to find work, Japan is full of places where they even give you a free house if you go to live there since many places are remaining empty, but the problem is that everyone wants to live in Tokyo, I heard that the Japanese government had even promised to give money to anyone who decided to leave the capital

日本有很多地方，如果你去住，他们甚至会给你免费的房子，因为很多地方都空着，但问题是每个人都想住在东京，我听说日本政府甚至承诺给任何决定离开首都的人一笔钱。

@pe1eterek
That's so weird. Seems like countries that before were considered third world (eg. Poland, Czech Republic - overall Central and Eastern Europe) seems much better now, then even such developed countries like Japan. I didn't hear such things happening there, and education is free even at University level (of course because of this there are a lot of people wanting to study - so there is certain tests and exams before entering or after high school).

这太奇怪了。以前被认为是第三世界的国家（如波兰、捷克共和国--整个中欧和东欧）现在似乎比日本这样的发达国家要好得多。我可没听说过那里发生过这样的事情，而且那里的教育甚至连大学都是免费的（当然，正因为如此，有很多人都想学习--所以在高中入学前或毕业后都要进行一些测试和考试）。

@user-et7rh2pm5n
My Japanese friend told me one of the reasons single mums are often poor is because a proportionally low number of them claim the state benefits they are actually entitled to! She said there is such a stigma that they are a burden to society financially that they would feel ashamed to accept that money. So with no state welfare and often zero child support they struggle to live off low wages for part time employment.

我的日本朋友告诉我，单亲妈妈往往很穷的原因之一是她们中申请实际应得的国家福利的比例很低！她说，人们认为单亲妈妈在经济上是社会的负担，所以她们会觉得接受这笔钱是一种耻辱。因此，她们没有国家福利，子女抚养费往往为零，只能靠兼职的低工资艰难度日。

@marginbuu212
"If this were France, there would be riots." Unfortunately, being Asian myself, I understand the culture of enduring the hardship, not complaining, not rocking the boat, and minding one's own business. There needs to be change in Japan and other modern Asian countries but the culture prevents people from talking about the problems.

"如果这里是法国，肯定会发生暴乱"。不幸的是，我自己也是亚洲人，我理解吃苦耐劳、不抱怨、不摇摆和管好自己的文化。日本和其他现代亚洲国家需要改变，但文化阻碍了人们谈论这些问题。

@eschelar
Same thing happening everywhere.
Parents keep their money for their house and retirement. Don't invest in their children. Then when they get so old that they need a nursing home, they do that on their own money.
They don't rely on their children for that, like happened before. Unfortunately, part of that is because before, it was more common for women to stay home as caretakers of the children, then caretakers of the parents.
Instead, we now have a problem where young people have no financial support early on when it is needed and useful. No money for uni. So they don't go to uni or they go much later. This creates a very difficult employment scenario as their experience is less than others in their field. This means that their salary is much lower. Also, it takes a lot longer to gather funds for uni.
This happened to me and I finished uni at age 28. No debt, true, but low earning too.
It's funny because the law of supply and demand says that if you increase supply, the value decreases.
Turns out that the decrease of wages coincides with feminism and women flooding the employment market. Especially instead of getting married and becoming housewives...
Ooooops. Feminism got it wrong? What?
And the stakes will cost society... The entire middle class and dichotomizing to a two-class, caste system?
Wow, who would have thunk it?

到处都在发生同样的事情。
父母把钱留着买房和养老而不投资在子女身上。当他们老得需要住养老院时，他们就用自己的钱去住。
他们不会像以前那样依赖子女，不幸的是部分原因是以前妇女更多的是在家照顾孩子，然后再照顾父母。
相反，我们现在的问题是年轻人在需要的早期阶段得不到经济支持。由于没钱上大学，所以他们不上大学或者上得更晚。这就造成了一种非常困难的就业局面，因为他们的经验比同行业的其他人要少，这意味着他们的工资要低得多。此外，他们还需要更长的时间来筹集大学学费。
我就是这样，我28岁才完成大学学业。虽然我确实没有负债，但收入也很低。
这很有趣，因为供求定律表明，如果增加供应，价值就会下降。
事实证明，工资下降与女权主义和女性涌入就业市场不谋而合，特别是她们不再结婚，不再做家庭主妇......
噢噢噢，女权主义搞错了？什么？
这将使社会付出代价...
哇，谁能想到呢？

@lilanisi
I understand the balance of population in Japan, with the higher elderly population more funding will be geared towards their needs but more importantly their voice. There is a reason why prostitution is the oldest industry, it will always be a fallback for women with no other alternative. I don't think many women would ever chose that line of work, so sad but that doesn't change reality.

我理解日本的人口平衡，随着老年人口的增加，更多的资金将用于满足他们的需求，但更重要的是他们的声音。卖淫是最古老的行业，这是有原因的，因为它永远是妇女别无选择的退路。虽然我不认为有多少女性会选择这一行，因为这太可悲了，但这并不能改变现实。

@feral_shade
It sounds scary if you think about the repercussions...
1st, it explains why sexism is such a huge problem, and why it will get much worse
2nd, Currently Japan has an impressive reputation for being safe
...but history invariably shows that desperation breeds crime.
3rd, with so many young underemployed people....when they're old enough to qualify for social security...the government won't be able to afford to pay it.

如果考虑到影响，这听起来很可怕......
首先，它解释了为什么性别歧视是一个巨大的问题以及为什么它会变得更加严重。
第二，目前日本在安全方面享有盛誉......但历史无一例外地表明，绝望会滋生犯罪。
第三，现在有这么多年轻的就业不足者....，当他们到了有资格享受社会保障的年龄时......政府将无力支付。

@iamotaru
Japan and Korea are similar in this sense.
Elder people get power and politics, write laws that only benefit them or their inner circle.
Society tends to see age as wisdom but fail to notice this time and age, some people grow old physically but did not grow wise mentally (grow up)
May need a huge country wide level of shift in politics.
But then again, Rich people funds politics, so its just who is steering the wheel

在这个意义上，日本和韩国是相似的。
老年人掌握着权力和政治，他们制定的法律只对他们或他们的核心圈子有利。
社会倾向于将年龄视为智慧，但却没有注意到在这个时间和年龄，有些人虽然身体上老了，但精神上却没有增长智慧（长大）。
他们可能需要在全国范围内对政治进行巨大的转变。
不过话又说回来，是有钱人在为政治提供资金，所以这只是在说明谁在掌舵而已。

@andyst4750
I'm not a Japanese, but it still pains me just the same to see so many Japan people slaving away in our so-called modern times. Forced sex jobs are as atrocious as torture during wartimes.

我不是日本人，但看到这么多日本人在我们所谓的现代社会里做苦工，我还是一样感到痛心。强迫性工作就像战争时期的酷刑一样残暴。

@blackbelt2000
Speaking of forced sex jobs, atrocities, and wartimes....you should take a look at jpan's WW2 warcrimes. Perhaps jpn brought this upon themselves as punishment...deservedly so.

说到强迫性工作、暴行和战时....，你应该看看日本在二战中的战争罪行。也许这是日本自找的惩罚......罪有应得。

@genesishep
What a nonsensical suggestion. What you are insinuating amounts to the idea of karma. If so, I ask how would such a thing be satisfied by punishing a generation which had nothing to do with those crimes? If such a force of justice existed wouldn't it demand retribution upon those actually responsible for those acts? Unless you believe that karma can and should be passed down generationally. If so, I ask how such forces of justice can exist for the Japanese yet remain dormant for numerous cultures around the globe responsible for unleashing far greater suffering upon the world? For instance, how could the Caucasian civilizations of the western world escape said karma when they inflicted so much injustice upon the world? From the mass GENOCIDEs and enslavements of numerous cultures in the past to the constant war mongering that continues even today. Why karma for one and not the other?

这真是个荒谬的建议。你的暗示等同于在宣扬因果报应的理念。如果是这样的话，我倒要问问，惩罚一个与那些罪行毫无瓜葛的后代世代，怎么能让这种所谓的报应得到满足呢？倘若真的存在这样一种正义之力，它难道不应该向那些真正该为那些行为负责的人索求偿还吗？除非你相信因果报应能够，并且应该代代相传下去。如果是这样，我又要问了，为何这种正义之力对日本人就有效，而对全球众多其他文化——那些给世界带来了远比这更为深重苦难的文化——却始终沉睡不醒呢？举例来说，当西方世界的那些高加索文明对世界施加了如此多不公时，他们又是如何逃脱了这种所谓的报应的呢？从过去对众多文化进行的大规模种族灭绝和奴役，一直到今天仍在持续的、持续不断的战争煽动行为。为何报应只针对一方，却放过了另一方？

@user-qm7jw
A famous influencer who used to work in the Japanese sex industry for over 10 years said on social media, "I have never seen a single woman forced to work in a brothel because of poverty." And when she questioned women who were doing パパ活 on her social media, she found out not a single woman started papakatsu because of poverty. I'm not saying, of course, that there aren't women who suffer from poverty and would sell their bodies, but the reality is that there are probably quite a few. I think it's quite misleading to say that many of the women selling their bodies are suffering from poverty and are forced to work.

一位曾在日本性产业工作超过10年的著名网红在社交媒体上说过：“我从来没有见过任何一个女人是因为贫困而被强迫在妓院工作的。”而且，当她在自己的社交媒体上询问那些从事“爸爸活”的女性时，她发现没有一个人是因为贫困而开始从事爸爸活的。我当然不是说不存在遭受贫困并因此出卖身体的女性，但现实情况是这样的女性恐怕也不在少数。我认为声称许多出卖身体的女性都是深受贫困所迫、被强迫工作的，这种说法是相当具有误导性的。