印度的肮脏秘密：电力危机如何使印度陷入瘫痪？该如何解决？

@AdityaKumar-ww8qk
Transmission losses are coming down from 21% to 16 or 17% in a decade. We need to take it down to around 6%

输电损耗在十年间已从 21% 降到 16% 或 17%。我们需要把它降到大约 6%。

@kanishkbakshi2004
we need it to be 3-5% world standards and further lead it

我们应该把损耗降到 3–5%，达到世界标准，甚至进一步领先。

@NaveenReddyGujjeti
In transmission loss we have done significantly well, but in distribution there are so many challenges because of the appeasement politics in India

在输电损耗方面我们确实做得不错，但在配电环节仍面临许多挑战，这主要是因为印度的讨好性政治造成的。

@unknown.m.e
Atleast in Andhra my village we rarely see power cuts
Andhra is one of the biggest power producers and it's a surplus power state

至少在安得拉邦我所在的村里，几乎很少停电。
安得拉邦是印度最大的电力生产地之一，是个电力过剩的邦。

@aviralsrivastava7324
But I thought andhra pradesh is seen as bihar of south

但我以为安得拉邦被认为是“南方的比哈尔邦”。

@unknown.m.e
they make it seems like it because Andhra people most work in IT and real-estate are in other cities like bengaluru chennai hyd and also we don't have capital and less per capita compared other states
Doesn't mean we are like Bihar. Andhra is still one of the richest state in India.
You can remove bengaluru and see what is the condition of Karnataka or any other state. They will be poor and migrate to the other state capitals for jobs
Still Andhra has lot of industries and will be top 5 in India in number of industries.
Andhra is like a new state we are building a new capital nee IT Sez and new ports and industrial areas.
Once those are done we will be top. You are comparing state with full infrastructure vs state without any infrastructure.
We build Hyderabad infra like airport ORR and IT sez which brought Andhra debt and those facilities to Telangana for free. We can't really do anything about it.
But we are slowly developing
Do you believe Andhra doesn't have a single central institute or army presence expect Navy when state got divided.
You can imagine how underdeveloped the state is.

之所以会被这样说，是因为安得拉邦的人多数在班加罗尔、金奈、海得拉巴等城市从事 IT 和房地产工作，我们自己没有首府，人均收入也比其他邦低。
但这并不意味着我们像比哈尔邦。安得拉仍是印度最富有的邦之一。
你去掉班加罗尔看看卡纳塔克邦或其他邦的状况，他们很穷穷，人们迁往其他邦首府找工作。
安得拉仍有很多工业，在全国工业数量上能排进前五。
安得拉是一个新建的邦，我们正在建设新的首府、新的 IT 特区、新的港口和工业区。
这些完成后我们会成为领先者。你现在拿一个基础设施完善的邦与一个几乎没有基础设施的邦相比是不公平的。
我们当初建设了海得拉巴的基础设施——机场、环城公路、IT 特区——结果这些都免费成了特伦甘纳邦的资产，还让安得拉背上债务。
但我们正在逐步发展。
你知道吗？邦分裂后，安得拉几乎没有一个中央机构或陆军驻地，除了海军。
可想而知我们当时有多落后。

@raavis2416
FYI ongoing projects in Andhra,,, just visit our state and feel the development
Technology and digital infrastructure
Google AI Hub: A $15 billion investment in Visakhapatnam to build data centers and establish an "AI hub" with a new International Subsea Gateway.
TCS Delivery Centre: A new delivery center for Tata Consultancy Services is slated to begin operations in Visakhapatnam.
Industrial and energy projects
Kurnool development: Projects worth over ₹13,430 crore are planned in Kurnool, focusing on industry, power, roads, railways, and defense manufacturing.
Orvakal and Kopparthi: The government is developing these as new industrial hubs to create jobs and promote industrial growth.
AP Genco thermal plant: A proposal for a 3200 MW thermal power plant at Vennelavalasa village in the Amudalavalasa constituency has been sent to the government.
Sree Rayalaseema Alkalies & Allied Chemicals Limited: A 26 MW captive coal-based power unit is being set up in Kurnool district.
Transportation and infrastructure
Highway projects: Significant investments are being made in road projects across the state, including widening highways, constructing bypasses, and building overpasses to improve connectivity and reduce traffic congestion.
Rajapuram Transmission Line: A new transmission line project is underway in the Rajapuram area.
Yemmiganur-Uravakonda Transmission Line: Another transmission line project is being developed to connect Yemmiganur and Uravakonda.

供你参考，安得拉邦目前正在进行的项目——欢迎亲自来看看我们的发展：
科技与数字基础设施：
谷歌人工智能中心：在维沙卡帕特南投资 150 亿美元建设数据中心，并建立新的国际海底网关“AI 枢纽”；
塔塔咨询服务公司（TCS）交付中心：将在维沙卡帕特南设立新的运营中心。
工业与能源项目：
库尔努尔地区发展：计划投资超过 1343 亿卢比，重点建设工业、电力、公路、铁路和国防制造；
奥尔瓦卡尔与科帕尔提：政府正在将这两个地区发展为新的工业中心，创造就业并促进增长；
安得拉发电公司热电厂：已向政府提交在阿穆达拉瓦拉萨选区维内拉瓦拉萨村建设 3200 兆瓦火电厂的提案；
斯里·拉亚拉西玛碱业公司：正在库尔努尔地区建设一座 26 兆瓦的自备燃煤电站。
交通与基础设施：
高速公路项目：全邦范围内投资公路扩建、绕行路和立交桥工程，以改善交通连通性并缓解拥堵；
拉贾普拉姆输电线：新的输电工程正在建设中；
耶米加努尔–乌拉瓦孔达输电线：另一条输电项目正在开发，用以连接两地。

@srinivasmaddu7833
by whom? Andhra started reforms in the power sector in the 1990s.

谁说的？安得拉早在 1990 年代就开始了电力行业改革。

@RameshKilaru
What are you talking about. We have daily power cuts.

你在说什么？我们这儿每天都停电。

@unknown.m.e
where bro my village I don't see much

哪里啊兄弟？我村里几乎没见过停电。

@rohitr12345
Let summer begin...

等夏天来了就知道了……

@shashidharatm9763
you must be lying. In South India, no domestic Power is cut off from the Grid.

你肯定在说谎，南印度的家庭用电根本没有问题

@GanugoGanugo
Bruh Andhra got divided. United Andhra would've been the 2nd largest GDP contributor to India. Give it a break, it had no capital for the past 10 years.

兄弟，安得拉已经被分成两个邦了。如果还没分裂，联合安得拉会是印度GDP第二大贡献者。算了吧，这十年来我们连首府都没有。

@Blaxe9
its the people the state is beautiful

这里的人很好，这个邦本身也很美。

@chandu25abc20
yes, in terms of HDI rankings like literacy rate, per-capita income etc, it ranks last among southern states, so is called Bihar of South.

是的，就人类发展指数（识字率、人均收入等）而言，它在南部各邦中排名最后，因此被称作“南方的比哈尔”。

@Skytlas
Same …me too I see very rare power outage in my state

我也是，我所在的邦几乎很少停电。

@RameshkumarPenumetsa
Yes.. That is a possibility with leaders like Jagan. He is the one who only trust in distributing money to people. On the positive view he is the great saviour to the nature does not distruct nature in the name of development.

是的，有贾根这样的领导就可能变成那样。他只相信向民众发钱。好的一面是，他在环保上确实做得好，不会以发展为名破坏自然。

@ganeshaguru2187
I agree with you bro. Rare power cuts.

我同意你说的，兄弟，停电确实很少。

@SoapOpera-g9y
Yes , rare power .

是的，很少停电。

@chennau
Our telugu states provides electricity free to so called sc,st people ,infact they are rich people than upper caste.old city of Hyderabad is the biggest theft of power .what a pity on congress government

我们泰卢固语区的邦给所谓的表列种姓、表列部落人群免费供电，但实际上他们很多比高种姓还富。海得拉巴老城区是最大的偷电区，真是可怜的国大党政府。

@Kritz-gg
Nhaa it’s the other way around

不，其实情况正好相反。

@smileplease5567
Their is almost no power cut in Uttar Pradesh. Even villages get 18 hours of electricity.

北方邦几乎没有停电。就连乡村每天都有18小时供电。

@jay19chandra77
Excellent interview and dissemination of facts... This is exactly what is used in the US.

精彩的访谈，信息传播得很到位。我听这位先生解释用户如何成为电力生产者并将多余电能卖给他人——也就是把能源回输电网，由电力公司在结算周期中返还电费。
这当然需要“智能电网”支持，核心是一种能追踪拥有太阳能板或风力发电机用户的智能装置。这正是美国正在使用的系统。

@darshankhandelwal7290
I live in Jaipur and I see the power cuts very very rarely

我住在斋浦尔，几乎很少遇到停电。

@amitproject
Last week I was in my native village in Churu... it’s not liveable if not for inverter or DG sets.

上周我回了楚鲁的老家，每天都要停电好几个小时。自从2004年我搬到古尔冈后，那里的停电也依然频繁。
若不是有逆变器或发电机组，根本没法生活。

@chevvakulasrikanth9260
I highly recommend that you invite Prof. Sajal Ghosh... please do take this up..

强烈建议你邀请MDI冈的萨贾尔·高希教授来谈这个话题。
我保证他对印度及全球能源行业的见解会让你大开眼界，也能揭示出当前能源领域的严重问题。加内什，请一定考虑采纳这个建议。

@zodaxtron_0005
I remember learning in school that India does have abundant coal reserves, but most of it is low-grade coal with a high sulfur content. This means it has a low carbon content, poor energy efficiency, and is highly polluting, releasing sulfur dioxide.
This is why we have to import "cleaner" high-quality coal. It sounds ridiculous, but it's true.

我记得在学校学过，印度确实煤炭储量丰富，但大多数是含硫量高的低品级煤，碳含量低、能效差、污染重，会释放二氧化硫。
因此我们不得不进口更“清洁”的高品质煤。听起来荒谬，但确实如此。

@AK-ny5bz
Ever since the Bilaspur power company switched to a smart meter for me, my electricity bill has gone up from around Rs 1200 to over Rs 1900 (from memory).

自从比拉斯布尔的电力公司给我换成智能电表后，我的电费从大约1200卢比涨到了1900多（凭记忆）。

@sadanandkadiyam2874
While this is possible, as an engineer with over a decade of experience working with smart meters, I can confirm that meters adhere to strict BIS standards and are tested for accuracy at multiple locations. Utilities also retest them before installation to ensure compliance. I recommend reporting to your local substation or online, so they can test the meter in your presence. Most of the time, the problem lies with older mechanical meters—long gone bad without anyone realizing it. Smart meters, on the other hand, can detect any issues in near real time, including attempts by users to tamper with the meter.

虽然这种情况可能存在，但作为一名有十多年智能电表经验的工程师，我可以确认电表都遵循严格的BIS标准，并在多个点位测试精度。
安装前电力公司也会再次检测以确保合规。建议你向当地变电站或在线投诉，他们会在你在场时测试电表。
多数情况下，问题出在旧式机械表上——它们早已损坏却没人知道。而智能电表几乎可以实时监测，包括用户试图篡改电表的行为。

@jeetroy491
They just increased the per unit cost

他们只是把每度电的单价提高了。

@spotoncam3640
The electricity cost is increasing - that's the main reason

电价上涨——这才是主要原因。

@ravichoubey3727
@spotoncam3640recording by new smart meter is accurate old version meter might be recording low consumption or energy

新型智能电表记录准确，老式电表可能记录的耗电量偏低。

@ManjotArora-te1wv
Remember, India has already completed the second phase of its nuclear energy development. Once the third phase is completed, India will be able to generate 500,000 kWh of clean nuclear energy at low cost.

别忘了，印度已经完成核能发展的第二阶段。第三阶段完成后，印度将能以低成本清洁核能发电50万千瓦时。

@aviralsrivastava7324
Bahut time lagega

那要花很长时间。

@michaelgilbert7703
Because they have to make back the money they spend on the election, and the only industry that can make money is this kind of industry.

因为他们得把选举花的钱赚回来，而唯一能赚钱的就是这种行业。

@startyourday6580
The so-called "affordable" policy only applies to sellers, not Indian consumers. Just like cheap crude oil imported from Russia, Indians haven't benefited from it at all.
Instead, Trump's tariff bomb has led to increased unemployment and business closures. Do you know why? Because all the benefits have gone to a few close friends, while ordinary working taxpayers have borne the losses.
Say "Thank you, Mr. Mowgli," because with him, everything is possible.

所谓“可负担”，只是对卖家而言，对印度消费者可不是。就像从俄罗斯进口的廉价原油，印度人却没享受到任何好处。
反而因特朗普的关税炸弹，失业增加，企业倒闭。你知道为什么吗？因为所有利益都进了少数朋友的口袋，损失却由普通工薪纳税者承担。
说声“谢谢吧，毛克利先生”，因为有他，一切皆有可能。

@aaroncruz9181
With Europe and US phasing out nuclear, this can be a real masterstroke.

随着欧洲和美国逐步淘汰核能，这可能成为印度的高明之举。

@BdmshCmpny-to5ow
Australia is also facing crisis of grid infrastructure.

澳大利亚的电网基础设施也正面临危机。

@MrAntonysimon
Not only power crisis. The quality of power is really bad.

不仅是电力短缺，电能质量也很糟糕。

@sanathshetty9130
Quality of power as in are you talking about the throughput or generation to effort ratio? Could you elaborate

你说的电能质量，是指输电效率还是发电投入产出比？能解释一下吗？

@cnvramamoorthy8358
Old transformers have power losses of 4–7%, while new, high-efficiency transformers have power losses of less than 1%. Old coal-fired power plants have very low efficiencies of only 10% to 40%, while new technology coal-fired power plants are much more efficient.

旧变压器的功率损耗为4–7%，新型高效变压器的功率损耗不到1%。旧燃煤电厂效率很低，只有10%到40%，而新技术燃煤电厂效率高得多。

@viveksingh-gs3xz
Solar is the next thing... win win situation

太阳能就是未来。我们通过政府补贴计划安装了太阳能板，花费约13万卢比，扣除补贴后每月电费从6000–7000降到400。每月能省约3000卢比，两三年就能收回成本，而且设备能用至少10年，妥妥的双赢。

@dkh8703
No panel issue with storms?

暴风雨天气时太阳能板不会出问题吗？

@HaiderLeo-p3s
Despite the millions of videos on this concept... People love your new idea's.

虽然网上有成千上万讲这个主题的视频，但我更想听你从“领导力”角度去提炼未来领袖能借鉴的核心经验。
真正的领导者不会照搬他人的做法，而是学习他们的思维方式——如何把问题变成力量，把混乱变成掌控——并用这种思维改造局面。
如果你能从这个视角构建内容，我们就能从全新的维度看待历史。人们都喜欢你这种独到的想法。

@SpiritOfIndiaaa
I am from Telanga ... after 2016 onwards we dont see much power cuts in my village and area...around 22hrs on an average we have power..forget about hyderabad.

我来自特伦甘纳邦……2016年之后，我们村和附近地区几乎不怎么停电了，平均每天都有22小时供电，更不用说海得拉巴了。

@shobadasari5363
Over the years, electrification has improved our lives atleast domestically, by leaps and bounds. Yes, efficiency and efficacy needs thought. But at the same time privatisation is not the answer. The Government has to play a role in endsupply of electricity irrespective from the sources and how it has been drawn from the grid.

这些年来，电气化让我们的生活在家庭层面上发生了巨大改善。没错，效率和成效确实值得思考。
但私有化并不是解决方案。政府必须在电力的最终供给中发挥作用，不论电力来自哪种来源，也不论如何从电网中调度。

@4kMovieTrailers9
Wealth Tax at 30% per annum is the only solution to all financial problems; more effective when implemented Globally.

对财富征收每年30%的税是解决所有财政问题的唯一办法——如果能在全球范围内实施会更有效。

@arjunrendale7726
For reducing AT&C losses, The Bhiwandi franchise model can be used as a reference. In Bhiwandi, Torrent Power, a private power company, supplied electricity under a franchise from Maha Power (a government-owned enterprise), reducing losses from 60% to 9%. This can serve as a case study.

为了减少输配电综合损耗（AT&C），可以借鉴比万迪特许经营模式。在比万迪，Torrent私营电力公司以马哈电力公司（政府企业）特许经营的方式供电，将损耗率从60%降到9%。这可以作为一个案例研究。

@ravichoubey3727
Dear major reason for higher AT&C loss is theft of electricity rampantly

亲，其实导致输配电损耗高的主要原因是普遍存在的偷电现象。

@maheshsikka4376
Can’t wait to watch the entire episode

等不及要看完整一期节目了。

@BillionaireInMatrix-is7ix
I work in a power plant and I can confirm that most of the time the plants are running at low capacity or even below the technical minimum. Either the state governments are unwilling to provide electricity to the people or your analysis is wrong or you are only concerned about peak hours.

我在发电厂工作，我可以肯定地说，大多数时候电厂都是低负荷运行，甚至达不到技术最低限。要么是各邦政府不愿给民众供电，要么你的分析有误，或者你只关心高峰时段。

@babytv6821
One thing that people have forgotten or haven't realized over the years is the previous administration. Those who really knew about it know that there were countless scandals, and many cases that were upheld by the Supreme Court. I remember that there was a new scandal in the newspaper almost every day, and people were used to it.

有件事大家这些年都忘了，或者没意识到——那就是前一届政府时期的事情。那些真正了解情况的人都知道，当时爆出了无数丑闻，而且被最高法院证实的案子也不少。
我记得几乎每天都有新的丑闻登上报纸，人们都见怪不怪了。

@kissanwalia2786
yes correct, if possible please list down some. Not able to find any big bold scam by searching!

对，说得没错。如果可以的话请列出几个吧，我搜了一下都找不到什么大的丑闻。

@obizidho
Arunachal Pradesh CAMPA scam being probed by the CBI. 1200 crores. Read about it.

中央调查局正在调查（中国藏南）的“森林补偿基金（CAMPA）丑闻”，金额高达1200亿卢比。你可以去查查看。

@anirbanbhattacharya2874
None of the alleged scandals of the previous government have ever been proven, except in the case of “WhatsApp University.” Modi has successfully co-opted and weaponized the mainstream media and various institutions, which are now only responsible for covering up the scandals of this government.

前一届政府所谓的那些丑闻没有一个被真正证实，除非是在“WhatsApp大学”里。而莫迪已经成功收编并武器化主流媒体和各类机构，它们如今只负责掩盖本届政府的丑闻。

@amritanshbaghel6386
Our politicians can't get over corruption. Just leaching of our hard work

我们的政客根本离不开腐败，只知道吸食普通人的辛苦劳动成果。

@karma__73
Imagine a family of four or five living in a rented apartment with no solar panels but a smart meter. They're poor. The father is preoccupied with the electricity bill and neglects the children. The landlord isn't willing to install solar panels, and the family can't afford them. Financial pressure forces this family to move out. What's the solution?

想想看，一个四五口之家租住在没有太阳能、却装有智能电表的公寓里，而且家庭贫困。父亲只关心电费而忽视孩子；
房东又不愿意装太阳能，家里也负担不起安装费用。这样的家庭因为经济压力不得不搬离，这种情况下该怎么办？

@maheshsikka4376
This should be an eye opener

这应该让大家清醒过来。

@aK8585-x6k

i know a guy who got a government job in DISCOM... (略)
我认识一个在电力配售公司（DISCOM）拿到政府岗位的人，出身非常贫困。刚入职时工资七到九万卢比，但工作两三年后，他就买下了价值上千万卢比的房产，还有另一处价值数十万的物业。
你觉得腐败不是造成亏损的主要原因吗？
正常上班族一辈子都难赚到这么多钱。如果一个人都能如此，那整个电力系统的腐败程度可想而知。难怪他们一听到政府要私有化DISCOM就哭天喊地。

@rexofuty
Only One Real genuine Man who telling the truth love u brother

只有你是真正说真话的人，爱你，兄弟。

@ARS298
You have to look at the overall situation. A lot of electricity is given away for free in the form of subsidies, which is what drives down the average profit margin.

你得看整体情况。很多电力以补贴形式免费发放，这才导致平均利润率下降。

@Crimson4ed
ARPU is the correct parameter for profit if you want to calculation.

如果要计算利润，“每用户平均收入（ARPU）”才是正确指标。

@dineshtripathi3995
We have surplus power in UP.We are moving ahead.

北方邦现在电力过剩，我们正在不断进步。

@KirtiBhaga
No corruption like in India nowhere in the world we are now 5 highest economy.

世界上没有哪个国家像印度这么腐败，但我们却成了全球第五大经济体。

@amitwargantiwar8384
In your opening remarks, you attempted to lix Modi's remarks to the fact that "some people still live in darkness," but this is somewhat inaccurate. Modi's statement that "we have electrified all villages" is not the same as stating that "some people still lack electricity." The central government has ensured that electricity reaches every village by building transmission lines, but the "last mile" of electricity is the responsibility of state governments, regardless of which party is in power. After all, the power sector falls under the jurisdiction of state governments, so please also point out their responsibility when criticizing.

在开场时，你试图把莫迪的言论和“仍有人生活在黑暗中”联系起来，但这有点不准确。莫迪说“我们已让所有村庄通电”和“仍有人没电用”是两回事。
中央政府已经通过架设输电线确保电力到达各村，但“最后一公里供电”由各邦政府负责，不论哪个政党执政都一样。毕竟电力部门都归邦政府管辖，因此请在批评时也指出邦政府的责任。

@obizidho
Yes, you're absolutely correct about the state politics responsibility. But the problem is the states win elections in Modi's name. So it comes full circle.

是的，你关于地方政治责任的看法完全正确。但问题是，各邦都是借着莫迪的名义赢得选举的。结果就成了一个循环。

@kaushlendrasahu8375
· Indian bureaucrats (Babus) are the main reason behind this. (Personal experience: my file for installing a business electrical connection was delayed for a year, even after spending extra money to speed up the process.)
· Capitalism should be implemented more openly and widely in India.

印度的官僚体系才是造成这一切的主要原因。（我亲身经历：为了给企业安装电力连接，我的申请文件被拖了一年，即使我额外花钱想加快进度也没用。）
印度应该更公开、更广泛地推行资本主义。

@Qseggytgb
True in electricity department in bsnl in railway same everywhere

确实如此，无论是电力部门、国营通信公司，还是铁路部门，到处都一样。

@vikaspot
very good compilation of power sector discussion and very well summarised

对电力行业的讨论整理得很好，总结得也很到位。

@durastar2024
Do you know how many lakh people don’t have power access even in China ?

你知道在中国还有数十万人没有用上电吗？

@justgrewal
Plz tell the numbers

请说出具体数字。

@justgrewal
Forget lakhs China has only few thousand houses where is no electricity kyn compare krte ho China humse 20 saal aa ge hai bro accept it or not

别说几十万了，中国现在只有几千户人家没电。为什么要拿中国和我们比？中国比我们领先二十年，无论你承不承认。

@PirateKid003
you actually compare with someone who is better than us.

确实，应该拿比我们更强的人来比较。

@uditbasumatary7145
yes you are right

是的，你说得对。

@uditbasumatary7145
dumbo tum kaise improve karoge apne apko competition karke. Toppers ko target karke.

笨蛋，如果不拿最优秀的人当目标，你怎么能提升自己？

@adarshkumarsingh6683
India became power surplus country before covid

印度在新冠疫情之前就已经成为电力盈余国家了。

@illpyogaming1914
Meghalaya no longer faces load shedding since last 8 years
Accept during a month or so each year
That to only 15 30 minutes not like before 5 to 7 hours everyday
It's getting better as time goes by
After several hydro power dams r Completely build some bext year some in 2027
We will not face power supply shortage any more including rural areas

梅加拉亚邦过去八年来几乎没有再实行限电，
每年只有一两个月偶尔停电十五到三十分钟，
不像以前那样每天停五到七小时。
情况正越来越好。
等几个水电站建成（有的明年完工，有的在 2027 年完工），
我们全邦包括农村地区将彻底告别电力短缺。

@sanathshetty9130
It would sound like an irony but a loss making market is like a honeypot trap for investors, they get easily convinced!

这听起来像个讽刺，但亏损的市场反而像蜜罐陷阱——投资者很容易被吸引进去！

@honeysingh4954
Please do the same in Hindi too, it will reach out to a lot and help them understand the smart meter and its role.

请也做一版印地语的，这样能让更多人了解“智能电表”及其作用。

@smileplease5567
India is third largest producer of electricity, India is third largest solar and renewable energy producer. Their is no dirth of electricity, more industrialization is required to consume extra electricity we are giving to Bangladesh.

印度是全球第三大电力生产国，也是第三大太阳能和可再生能源生产国。电力并不短缺，只是需要更多工业化来消化多余的电力——我们现在都把电出口到孟加拉国了。

@karma__73
Everything will be fine untill the per unit cost of power is increased, like jio with 249/- and 199/- pack but they now charging more for same benefits?

一切都好，直到电价像电信服务套餐那样涨价为止。以前 249 或 199 卢比的套餐，现在花更多钱才能享受同样的服务。

@luckylemur6449
Yes there are challenges and they are being addressed. So to say that the challenges in the power sector is paralysing India is quite a stretch of imagination.
The world's fastest growing big economy is a paralysed one, really?

没错，电力行业确实有挑战，但问题正在被解决。说“电力问题让印度瘫痪”，这就太夸张了。
世界上增长最快的大型经济体，会是一个“瘫痪的国家”？真荒谬。

@karma__73
2% of India's GDP my god , that money can be used for EDUCATION, HOSPITALS , R&D and at least FOR POOR

天哪，损失占印度GDP的2%啊！这些钱本可以用来发展教育、医疗、科研，至少也该帮帮穷人。

@DuhSciFur
Govt. runs away from questions

政府总是逃避问题。

@izharshaikh-o4m
Power shortages are severely impacting the export competitiveness of small and medium-sized enterprises. Vast variations in electricity prices across cities across China are leading to significant internal friction among businesses. This is particularly true in the plastics industry, which recyclers like us understand best how difficult it is.

电力问题严重影响中小企业的出口竞争力。国内不同城市电价差异巨大，导致企业间内耗严重。尤其是塑料行业，我们这些回收商最清楚，他们现在举步维艰。

@sai7mahadev
The power grid isn't collapsing—the claim at the beginning of the video needs to be corrected. If the grid were truly broken, the data center industry wouldn't be booming. While insufficient power generation is a problem, the grid itself simply needs further upgrading and strengthening. This work has already begun, with numerous projects underway and many more planned.
Solar energy isn't a sudden rise; the government has long set renewable energy targets. To address solar's limitations, the State Renewable Energy Corporation (SECI) is promoting hybrid energy projects. Meanwhile, they fail to mention the ongoing transmission modernization projects. Utilities have also begun investing in FACTS and high-voltage direct current (HVDC) technologies.

电网并没有崩溃——视频开头的说法需要纠正。如果电网真坏了，数据中心产业就不会蓬勃发展了。确实，发电不足是个问题，但电网本身只是需要进一步升级和强化。这项工作其实早已启动，许多项目正在进行，还有不少在规划中。
太阳能也不是突然兴起的，政府早就设定了可再生能源目标。为了弥补太阳能的局限，国家可再生能源公司（SECI）推动混合能源项目。同时，他们没提到正在推进的输电现代化项目。电力公司也已开始投资于FACTS和高压直流（HVDC）技术。

We should be cautious when comparing ourselves to China. China is not a democracy, and its dependence on semiconductors is different. India faces significant obstacles in areas such as land acquisition and political interference.
Overall, the panelists could have explored these issues more deeply, but this also depends on the moderator's questioning. It would be advisable to invite true technical experts rather than equity investors.
Reducing distribution losses will be a key focus in the coming years, and technological investment is already underway. Ultimately, however, this depends on state governments—if free electricity policies can be limited to economically disadvantaged groups, states will have more funds to invest in improving distribution efficiency.

我们拿自己和中国比较要谨慎，中国不是皿煮国家，而且半导体依赖程度也不同。印度在土地征用、政治干扰等方面阻力重重。
总的来说，嘉宾们本可以更深入探讨这些问题，但这也取决于主持人提问方向。建议邀请真正的技术专家，而非股权投资人。
未来几年，降低配电损耗将成为重点，技术投资正在到来。不过最终还是取决于各邦政府——如果免费供电政策能仅限于经济弱势群体，各邦就能有更多资金用于改善配电效率。

@tkentertainment2776
Indeed...India's nuclear power plants should use thorium-based fuel. India has had a 40-megawatt thorium pilot reactor in operation since 1985, and it should be expanded. More thorium-based reactors would significantly reduce costs.

确实如此……印度核电站应该采用钍为基础的燃料。印度自1985年以来就有一座40兆瓦的钍试验反应堆在运行，现在应扩大规模。更多钍基反应堆将有效降低成本。

@mr.leo6
I think and predict modiji will not finish this term for 5 years...

我认为并预言莫迪这届任期不会干满5年……

@myvlogs1927
Why such a bizarre prediction bro?

兄弟，为什么会有这么奇怪的预言？

@Hello-kh6bk
India needs more Ambani, Adani, Birla, Tata, and JSW to invest in our country and create jobs

印度需要更多像安巴尼、阿达尼、比尔拉、塔塔和JSW这样的企业家来投资国家、创造就业。

@AK-ny5bz
Where have you got the data of non-electrified homes/people?

你提到的“未通电家庭或人口”数据是从哪里来的？

@jansonmathew6605
Its multi billion dollar industry......investment is too much needed.....

这是一个数十亿美元级别的产业，非常需要大量投资。

@sjgghosh7677
Why do we need to store energy in the first place???? Why can't we fully use solar energy during daytime & for night current conventional energy??? If we can generate & use half of our energy using solar that would already be very big win.

我们为什么一开始就非得储能？为什么不能白天全用太阳能、晚上再用常规能源？如果能用太阳能满足一半的能源需求，那已经是巨大的胜利了。