美国的自来水喝起来 “香甜”么?
Is it safe to drink tap water in the U.S?
译文简介
PS:实际上,美国好多地方的自来水喝起来都很“甜”的!
正文翻译
Is it safe to drink tap water in the U.S?
美国的自来水能安全地喝吗?

I'm from Australia and my partner is from America (Texas, specifically). We have conflicting views on whether tap water is safe to drink.
He's afraid of the chemicals and pollutants (chlorine, ammonia) - making people sick, causing long term problems such as cancer. He's been drinking from bottled spring water, because it's what everyone has told him to.
We have looked into varying sources and there has been opposing views on each side. Would love more clarity.
Thank you.
我澳大利亚人,我的伴侣是美国人(具体来说是得克萨斯州的)。我们对自来水是否能安全饮用意见不一。
他担心水里的化学物质和污染物(比如氯、氨什么的)——会让人生病,还可能引发癌症等长期健康问题。所以他一直喝瓶装泉水,因为身边所有人都这么建议他。
我们查了不少资料,发现两边的观点完全相反。希望能更清楚地了解。
美国的自来水能安全地喝吗?

I'm from Australia and my partner is from America (Texas, specifically). We have conflicting views on whether tap water is safe to drink.
He's afraid of the chemicals and pollutants (chlorine, ammonia) - making people sick, causing long term problems such as cancer. He's been drinking from bottled spring water, because it's what everyone has told him to.
We have looked into varying sources and there has been opposing views on each side. Would love more clarity.
Thank you.
我澳大利亚人,我的伴侣是美国人(具体来说是得克萨斯州的)。我们对自来水是否能安全饮用意见不一。
他担心水里的化学物质和污染物(比如氯、氨什么的)——会让人生病,还可能引发癌症等长期健康问题。所以他一直喝瓶装泉水,因为身边所有人都这么建议他。
我们查了不少资料,发现两边的观点完全相反。希望能更清楚地了解。
评论翻译
很赞 ( 3 )
收藏
IsotopeX
It's difficult to generalize because the US is so freaking big and there is variation between regions, rural vs. urban. etc. But, in general, we have very safe tap water. There are exceptions, but they are localized. You can find information about local water quality via the EPA, the USGS, or the CDC, among other sources.
For Texas specifically, this looks like your best bet for local information.
Many brands of bottled water are straight from the tap and sold at a massive markup. Spring water is...well...from a spring but not every brand that has "spring" in their name is spring water.
很难一概而论,因为美国太大了,不同地区、城乡之间差别也都很大。但总的来说,我们的自来水非常安全。虽有例外情况,但都属于局部问题。你可以通过美国环保署(EPA)、美国地质调查局(USGS)或疾病控制与预防中心(CDC)等来源查找当地水质信息。
针对德克萨斯州的具体情况,这似乎是获取本地信息的最佳渠道。
许多品牌的瓶装水其实就是直接罐装的自来水,却以高价出售。泉水...确实源自泉眼,但并非所有品牌名称中含"泉"字的都是真正的泉水。
Old_Cyrus
Also, every municipality in Texas is required to post a sign declaring its drinking water grade. https://www.trwa.org/blogpost/1539239/290601/What-Does-a-Superior-Rating-Mean-for-Your-Water-System
还有,德州的每个市政当局都必须张贴告示,声明其饮用水等级。
Mischief_Makers
TIL the US doesn't have universally drinkable tap water.
I mean, I knew about Flint, but aside from that!
现在才知道美国并非所有地方的自来水都能喝。
我的意思是,我只知弗林特市的情况,除此之外就不知了!
tunaman808
Well, Flint aside, there's a difference between "drinkable" and "water you want to drink".
My parents bought a vacation condo in Florida. The water was totally safe to drink - no heavy metals or parasites, or anything like that. But it tasted pretty bad. Most grocery stores in the area had not one, but two of those 5-gallon water vending machines, 'cos someone was always using one of them.
For the record, our washing machine was a front-loader, and by the end of every summer Mom would have to scrape all the lime (scale? calcium?) off the inside of the washer window, because it was completely opaque.
这么说吧,抛开弗林特市的问题不谈,"可以喝"和"你愿意喝"的水是有区别的。
我爸妈在佛罗里达买了套度假公寓。那里的自来水完全能安全饮用——没有重金属、寄生虫之类的问题。但味道实在不怎么样。那里的小超市基本都配备了两台5加仑桶装水饮水机,而不是一台,因为总有人在用。
顺便说一下,我们的洗衣机是前开门的,每年夏天结束时,我妈都得刮掉粘在洗衣机观察窗里侧的水垢(水垢?钙?),因为那里完全被糊住了。
TheCarbonCross
Drinkable v. Palatable. The treated water that comes out of wastewater plants is drinkable, yes, but you would have to be on the verge of death to want to drink it. Also a lot of rural people are on wells so not much/any regulations.
可以喝vs.好喝。污水处理厂处理过的水确实可以喝,但除非快渴死了,否则没人会想喝。另外很多农村地区用的是井水,而且基本没什么监管。
psybertard
Rural on my own well after 20 years on a village well. Water is amazing. Comes from aquifers from way up north. We test every two years on own well. The villages do yearly testing.
用了20年村里的井水后,现在用上自家井了。水质好极了,水源是来自北方的含水层。我们每两年自测一次井水,每年村里也会检测一次。
PrizeStrawberryOil
Look into what chemicals factories near you use. For example fluorinated carbon is often used in manufacturing and that gets dumped into drinking water. Because there are so many types not all of them have been proven to be harmful, especially in your state. Regulations are lax because of it.
查一下你家附近工厂都用什么化学品。比如,制造业常用的氟化碳,然后被排放到饮用水中。化学品种类很多,但并非所有类型的化学品都被证明是有害的,尤其是在你所在的州。监管力度很宽松。
Mischief_Makers
In the UK rules are different. Something doesnt have to be proven to be harmful to be banned, it has to be proven safe to be permitted.
英国的规则不一样。某些东西不需要被证明有问题才会被禁用,而是必须被证明没问题才会被允许使用。
SadExtension524
I live in Maine, the home of Poland Springs Spring water company. And let me tell you about that...
They used to have a spring in Poland, Maine. That's where they got the water from. It dried up years ago. They get that "spring" water right from the tap now.
There's another brand of water bottled in Greenwood, Indiana that also comes right from the tap. It's brand is Pure Life.
Both of these brands are owned by Nestlé, which has a terrible corporate reputation. These bottled water companies are destroying our environment and our public drinking sources.
Yes there are some municipalities that don't have good drinking water, but most have decent water.
我家在缅因州,是Poland Springs泉水公司的所在地。给大家说说吧...
他们以前在缅因州的波兰镇有一个泉。那就是他们取水的地方。多年前就干涸了。现在他们的"泉水"直接来自自来水。
还有一个在印第安纳州格林伍德瓶装水品牌,水也直接来自自来水。牌名叫Pure Life。
这两个品牌都属于雀巢公司,这个公司企业声誉很差。这些瓶装水公司正在破坏我们的环境和公共饮用水源。
确实,有些市政当局的饮用水不好,但大多数地方的水质还是不错的。
hike_me
Nestle sold Poland Springs a few years ago.
You are right that Flfor the most part their water comes from private drilled wells or municipal sources that are drawing from the same aquifer as a natural spring so they are legally allowed to call them spring water, even though in many cases is the same exact water they comes out of the tap. You’re not legally allowed to bottle spring water that makes it to the surface due to possible contamination— you need to drill a well to tap the source of the spring.
几年前雀巢就把Poland Springs给卖了
你说得对,大部分情况下他们的水来自私人钻井或市政水源,这些水源与天然泉水来自同一含水层,所以在法理上他们可以称之为泉水,尽管在很多情况下这和自来水是完全相同的水。法律上不允许灌装涌出地表的泉水,因为可能受到污染,你需要打井来获取源头泉水。
IUsedTheRandomizer
This reminds me of the history of Pease AFB, and all the old Portsmouth residents who'd lament about how good the water was before the Air Force showed up.
这让我想起了皮斯空军基地的历史,还有所有朴茨茅斯的老居民,他们肯定在哀叹在他们空军来之前水有多好啊。
majesticjewnicorn
Yes, it is safe to drink. Your partner is concerned about cancer yet they drink bottled water frequently- the plastic bottles are made from flimsy plastics in which the plastic particles break down into the water. This is carcinogenic.
是的,可以喝,安全的。你的伴侣怕得癌,却经常喝瓶装水,你可知塑料瓶是由单薄的塑料制成的,塑料颗粒会分解到水中。这也致癌的。
UchihaMangekyo
Fuck, i frequently forget to carry my own water bottle and buy bottled water when i go outside.
I will be carrying my own water bottle from now on.
艹,我老忘带水瓶,出门老买瓶装水。
从现在开始我要自带水瓶了
dallassoxfan
When you look on bottled water in the US it has to give the source.
Nestle “flouridated baby water” with a picture of a cute kid on it and marketed to use to make baby formula…
Water source: dallas municipal water system.
The water is safe. People are crazy.
在美国,所有瓶装水都必须标明水源。
比如雀巢那款"氟化婴儿水",包装上印着可爱宝宝,宣传用于冲泡配方奶…
再一看水源:达拉斯市政供水系统。这水能安全?疯了吧。
DarthJarJar242
Your partner seems like he's gullible/a conspiracy theorist. There is an absolute FUCK ton of information available about the safety of tap water in the US, also about the safety of the chemicals used to treat water here. If he genuinely believes US tap water is dangerous he could probably be roped into believing a lot of other dangerous nonsense.
你的伴侣看起来容易上当受骗/像个阴谋论者。关于美国自来水的安全性,以及这里用于水处理的化学品的安全性,有都是海量信息可查。如果他真心认为美国自来水危险,那他很可能还会被忽悠着相信其他危言耸听的胡话。
[](注:匿名或已注销掉用户,以下同)
It depends where in the United States you're talking about. Pretty sure everyone by now has heard what happened in Flint at least once. They're not the only place that has service pipes made of lead. Even in certain parts of Pittsburgh there are still boil water advisory warnings. Whichever treatment plant connects to the town usually has a report indicating what's in the water.
这取决于你谈论的是美国的哪个地方。想必大家如今都至少对弗林特市的水危机有所耳闻。但并非只有那里还在使用铅制供水管道,就连匹兹堡部分区域至今仍会发布烧水警告。通常每个城镇连接的水处理厂都会发布水质成分报告供公众查阅。
DeathTripper
So utilities companies claim that lead pipes are safe, due to years of mineral buildup. I don’t see why this wouldn’t be mostly true. If you ever seen the inside of any kind of pipe that’s been used for decades, there’s a thick layer of buildup. It’s kind of gross looking, but it’s also harmless.
Only issue is, if the water chemistry changes and those service pipes start leeching lead into the water, or if the pipes start to corrode (which they’ll need to be replaced anyway).
所以公用事业公司声称,由于铅管内多年的矿物质沉积,管道反而是安全的。这种说法大体是成立的。如果你见过任何使用了几十年的管道内部,你就会发现里面结着厚厚的水垢层。看起来确实有点恶心,但确实无害。
唯一的问题是,如果水质化学性质忽然发生变化,导致铅成分从老旧管道中渗出,或是管道开始腐蚀(不过到时候也就该换了)。
blanchasaur
One should never boil water with lead in it. It only concentrates the metal in water, making it more dangerous to drink.
千万不可煮沸含铅的水,这只会浓缩水中的金属浓度,喝了反而更加危险。
jdith123
Most but not all tap water is safe to drink. All bottled water sellers and many people on Reddit are happy to imply that bottled water is safer.
多数但不是全部自来水都可以安全饮用。所有瓶装水销售商和Reddit上的许多人都喜欢暗示瓶装水更安全。
papaboynosmurf
On average yes, there are those famous towns with terrible water that the government won’t help but in most places you’ll be fine
总的来说,有虽然有些城镇水质极差,政府也不管,但大多数地方的水还是可以放心喝的。
Steve0512
The important factor is that your partner is from Texas. Politicians in red states would happily let big corporations poison peoples drinking water in return for a huge bribe.
关键问题在于你伴侣来自德克萨斯州。红州的政客们为了巨额贿赂,甘愿放任大企业污染民众的饮用水源。
[]
It depends where you are,but generally, yes. AND bottled water is full of microplastics, and is often just municipal tap water itself.
Best bet? Tap water, plus get a good filter.
这得看具体地区,但总体来说,(自来水)是安全的。而且瓶装水里满是微塑料,很多瓶装水本质上就是市政装瓶的自来水。最佳选择是什么?喝自来水,最好装一个好点的过滤器。
Boondokz
There are very few places it is not safe. Though a lot of people prefer bottled water still for taste.
有问题的自来水的地方不多。不过,仍有很多人因为口感原因而更喜欢喝瓶装水。
bxxxbydoll
My favorite part about living here is when my tap water smells like algae because the city forgot to pour chemicals in the water, then the next couple days it smells like chlorine
我住在这里最令人膈应的一点是,有时候市政部门忘了往水里加消毒剂,其结果是,忘加的时候,自来水闻起来就有一股水藻味。想起来后,接下来两三天,水闻起来又满是氯味。
andmewithoutmytowel
Most have decent drinking water, I’m in Louisville and we have some of the best tap water, my brother used to live in New Orleans, which doesn’t. Some of my relatives had well water that always smelled of sulfur. It’s all relative.
大多数地方的饮用水质量还是不错的。我住在路易斯维尔,这里的自来水算是全美最好的;我哥以前住在新奥尔良,那里的自来水就不行。我有几个亲戚家喝井水,但那水总带着一股硫磺味。所以说,水质好不好都是相对的。
Nerdiestlesbian
Tap water is a concern for some people. I live in Michigan and the city of Flint has not had drinkable water for years due to lead poisoning. If you partner is worried about safe water I would get it tested.
I did water quality testing for a few years while I was getting my chemistry degree.
One of the issues that can happen is bacterial growth. That is not talked about as much as chemical pollutants.
有些人会担心自来水的安全。我家在密歇根州,这个州弗林特市因为铅污染,多年来一直没有可以安全喝的自来水。如果你伴侣担心水质安全,我建议去做个水质检测。我攻读化学学位期间,做过几年水质检测工作。自来水可能存在的问题之一就是细菌滋生,这类问题远不如化学污染受关注。
Ranos131
Most of the time tap water is safe to drink. That’s the entire point of the treatment plants.
There are occasions where there are issues due to some sort of contamination such as the PG&E issue in California in the 90s and the issue in Flint, Michigan more recently.
But the vast majority of the time the water is safe to drink.
大多数时候,自来水是可以安全喝的,而这正是水处理厂存在的核心意义。偶尔也会出现因污染引发的问题,比如 20 世纪 90 年代加利福尼亚州太平洋煤气电力公司(PG&E)的污染事件,以及近年来密歇根州弗林特市的水危机。但绝大多数情况下,自来水都还是能喝的。
[]
It depends. The quality of tap water can vary from county to county. The best, purest-tasting tap water I ever drank was in Seattle. In contrast, many places in The Rust Belt and the South have trouble with water quality due to aging pipes, algae collecting in the aquifers, and factory run-off.
这得看情况。美国不同县的自来水质量差异很大。我喝过的口感最好、最纯净的自来水是在西雅图。与之相反,铁锈地带和南部的很多地方,由于管道老化、含水层滋生水藻以及工厂污水排放等问题,水质一直很差。
外国人总喜欢把我们美国当成一个整体来看待。宝贝,美国面积太大了。每个小镇的情况都有不同,就算在同一个小镇里,情况也不一样,有的家庭用市政自来水,有的则用井水。大体来说,自来水是可以喝的,但最好装个过滤器,因为自来水的净化程度不够,而且水里含有 “永久化学物质”。
sphincterella
Of course it’s safe. Your partner is insanely misinformed because marketing people sell stupid ideas in attempts to capitalize on irrational fears.
Chlorine at the levels it’s present in drinking water will not harm anyone and kills biological stuff to make the water safer. The US has some of the highest standards for drinking water and the enforcement is near 100%.
If you want better taste use a carbon filter, but that’s all you need. All the other terrifying shit the marketing people blather about is at such low level it will never cause an issue.
当然是安全的。你伴侣的认知完全错误,因为营销人员为了利用人们的非理性恐惧赚钱,会故意传播这种荒谬的说法。饮用水中的氯含量处于安全水平,不会对人体造成伤害,反而能杀死有害生物,让水变得更安全。美国拥有全球最严格的饮用水标准,且标准执行率几乎达到 100%。如果觉得口感不好,买个活性炭过滤器就可以了。营销人员胡乱宣传那些骇人说辞,那些物质的含量微乎其微,根本不可能造成实际危害。
ScroungerYT
It depends on where you live. If you live in Flint, Michigan, you don't drink the tap water. If you live in Cincinnati, Ohio, it is safe to drink the tap water.
Also, your "partner" should know that his "spring water" is just tap water.
这得看你住在哪儿。如果住在密歇根州弗林特市,就别喝那里的自来水;如果住在俄亥俄州辛辛那提市,那儿的水还可以喝。还有,你的“伴侣” 应该知道,他喝的 “泉水” 其实就是自来水。
AnotherManDown
Depends on the region.
The story I remember is that at some point, in order to make a profit, companies selling bottled water started a smear campaign to make people afraid of tap water, and apparently it worked.
That led to a norm of tap water not being consumed, which in turn took away the incentive to maintain the system. So eventually completely harmless and drinkable tap became a foul undrinkable mess.
What a waste... to have non-salty water come out of your kitchen and not be able to drink it.
这得看在哪儿。我记得有这么个说法:曾几何时,瓶装水公司为了盈利,发起了一场抹黑自来水的宣传运动,让人们反感喝自来水, 显然他们成功了。这导致 “不喝自来水” 成了一种常态,进而使得维护自来水系统的动力消失。最终,原本完全无害、可安全饮用的自来水,变成了又脏又难喝、无法喝的废水。多浪费啊…… 厨房里流出来的明明是淡水,却不能喝。
jynxthechicken
I would say for the most part no but it depends on where you live. They put a lot of crap in our drinking water.
我想说的是大部分地方的水都不行,但这取决于你住在哪里。他们在我们的饮用水里加了好多垃圾。
Boryalyc
Depends on where you live. Certain places will have tap water better than anything you can buy at the store, the first place that comes to mind is Prescott in Arizona. Other places will taste like dogshit and probably do have a bit of dogshit sprinkled in them.
取决于你住在哪里。有些地方的自来水会比你在商店能买到的任何瓶装水都好,我先是想到的是亚利桑那州的普雷斯科特。其他地方的水其味道就像狗屎一般,弄不好可能真的是掺了点狗屎。
NappyTime5
In the US, water quality is controlled and mandated by the Clean Water Act to be consumable if it is channeled to your house through public works. Some of it tastes strange but that's just the result of certain types of water treatment. BUT the clean water act doesn't cover private wells which a lot of more rural properties have. Fun fact: the quality of bottled water is actually controlled by the Food and Drug Administration which has lower standards than the Clean Water Act ; so in large cities with a culture of bottled water, the bottled water is in fact dirtier than the slightly odd tasting water from your tap
在美国,通过公共工程输送到你家的水,其质量受《清洁水法》控制和规定,必须是可饮用的。有地方的水,味道奇怪,但那只是处理方式的结果。但是,《清洁水法》不涵盖私人水井,而多数偏远地区恰恰依赖井水。讽刺的是,瓶装水标准由食品药品监督管理局制定,不过,监管力度反而低于《清洁水法》。因此在盛行瓶装水的大城市,那里的瓶装水,实际上比你水龙头里流出来的,味道有些怪怪的自来水还更脏。
TheonuclearPyrophyte
I wouldn't. Tap water in my area always reeks of either chlorine or fish, is sometimes so hard it looks like watered-down milk, and is also probably radioactive. New Yorkers say their water is safe, but they're all fucked as everyone else I've ever met. That might not be the water's fault though.
我反正是不喝。我这里的自来水总是散有一股氯气或鱼腥味,有时更像是掺了水的牛奶,说不定还有放射性。纽约人都说他们的水很安全,不过我见过的纽约人一个个都活得够呛,当然这可能也不全是水的错。
Agile-Fee-6057
Its not a conspiracy theory that the airforce dumped jetfuel and industial solvents into my ground water, and it's not a conspiracy theory that Flint, MI had lead pipes
空军往我们的地下水里倾倒喷气燃料和工业溶剂,这不是阴谋论;密歇根州弗林特市用铅管输水,这也不是什么阴谋论。
arcxjo
My local water exceeds legal limits for Haloacetic acids (HAA5) and Total trihalomethanes (TTHMs), and exceeds recommended levels for six other chemicals, but they only took out the fluoride because the dumbasses around here get all their science from Facebook memes.
我们这里的自来水,卤乙酸(HAA5)和总三卤甲烷(TTHMs)含量超过了法定限值,还有另外六种化学物质的含量超过了建议限值,但他们偏偏隐去了氟化物含量,就因为我们这儿的一群蠢货,所有科学知识都来自脸书上的谣言。
[]
I’m from the Bay Area, California and up here it’s safe to drink! But if you go down to LA don’t drink the tap water it’s drinkable just has an awful slight taste
我来自加利福尼亚州湾区,我们这儿的自来水安全能喝!但如果你去洛杉矶,那里的水就算了,能喝到是能喝,就是有股怪味。
MurkyEon
Florida water is terrible. It used to make our dogs sick. Filtered, it's OK.
佛罗里达州的自来水难喝死了,以前给我家狗都给喝出病了。(不过)过滤后的水还可以。
TofuTigerteeth
It’s weird that non Americans don’t realize it’s the 3rd largest country in the world. The conditions in one place do not equal the conditions in another.
外国人没意识到美国是世界第三大国家,这挺奇怪的。一个地方的情况,不能代表所有地方。
dommozart2678
I can’t stand the taste of it but if you like it than that’s fine
我受不了自来水的那股味,但如果你不介意,问题也不大。
sewcrazy4cats
It depends. I'm from texas and my water comes from lake tawakani, which no. I can't drink the water. But when i lived in places sourced by other lakes it was fine
这得看情况。我是得克萨斯州人,我们家的水来自塔瓦卡尼湖,这地方的水可不能喝。但我以前住的地方,水源是别的湖里的水,那里的自来水就没问题。
[]
Depends where you live (I’m originally from Philly and we have some of the best tap water in the United States) my husband is from nj and they had well water . . Then in flint Michigan the water is contaminated with lead . I now live in Arizona and we have great tap water. It really depends on what city you live in.
这得看你住在哪儿(我老家在费城,那里的自来水是全美国最好的)。我老公是新泽西州人,他们家以前就喝井水,但那味道简直让人无法忍受。至于密歇根州的弗林特市,那里的自来水已经被铅污染了。我现在住在亚利桑那州,这里的自来水尤其的好。所以说,自来水水质真的取决于你住的是哪个城市。