印度比中国更适合经商吗？印度人会英语有优势吗？

 
@dragonz369
If dreaming makes Indian people happy, then let them be. Living in dreams is better than living in their reality.
 
如果做梦能让印度人开心，那就随他们去吧。活在梦里总比活在现实中强。
 
@DouglasW-m9z
dreaming is actually a good thing, hallucinating is a different story
 
做梦其实是件好事，但幻觉就是另一回事了。
 
@rajsub3884
Atlest it gives them way to reach to alien planet where they get what they desire
 
至少这给了他们通往外星球的途径，在那里他们能得到想要的一切。
 
@colinlee9678
You can always tell the Indian version of English as it is heavily Indian - accented!
 
你总能听出印度式的英语，因为它带着浓重的印度口音！
 
@mythbusterthe6749
Very true. In some places you don't even think they are spatuling England.
 
太真实了。在某些地方，你甚至不觉得他们说的是英语。
 
@stephenleung9189
they cannot even spell the word 'English' correctly.
 
他们连"English"这个单词都拼不对。
 
@superfarzan3996
Surprisingly enough, the first ever English words ever read by any Indian is literally "Made In China"
 
令人惊讶的是每个印度人读到的第一个英语单词都是"中国制造"。
 
@ah5878
I go to India for work couple times a year. Not most people speak English, India doesn't even have a standard language and the heavy English accent is hard to understand. When Indian shake head to you, you don't know that means "yes" or "no". Most Japanese don't speak English neither. 10% of people in the world native language is Chinese.
 
我每年去印度工作几次。印度不是大多数人都会说英语，印度甚至没有标准语言，他们浓重的英语口音很难听懂。当印度人对你摇头时，你不知道那表示"是"还是"否"。大多数日本人也不会说英语。世界上10%的人的母语是汉语。
 
@PoppinC-l3w
The Indian head shake goes with literally everything and anything and has no rhyme or reason to it.
 
印度人的摇头适用于任何场合，毫无规律可循。
 
@INDIANSARESICKMENOFASIA
While China is busy hosting the FOCAC summit 2024, leaders from 50+ out of 54 countries in the entire African continent and UN Chief António Guterres flew past India to get to China. Shortly after/during the event, Norwegian Prime Minister and Spanish Prime Minister flew past India to get to China to dicuss trade. The number of country leaders that had visited China in a week is more than the number of country leaders that had visited India in a decade and probably more. India consoles herself and went to Brunei/Singapore to beg for more investments/technology transfers/jobs for their unemployed economic refugees. There is a thousand year old saying that says.....If you are rich, everybody wants to be your friend but, If you are poor, nobody wants to be your friend.
 
当中国忙于举办2024年中非合作论坛峰会时，整个非洲大陆54个国家中有50多位领导人和联合国秘书长安东尼奥·古特雷斯飞越印度前往中国。活动期间/之后不久，挪威首相和西班牙首相也飞越印度前往中国讨论贸易。一周内访问中国的国家领导人数量超过了十年内访问印度的数量，可能更多。于是印度寻求自我安慰，前往文莱/新加坡乞求更多投资/技术转让/为失业的经济难民提供工作。有句千年古语说......穷在闹市无人问，富在深山有远亲。
 
@supergroovy8346
India should first start competing with SE Asia and Europe before trying to take on China.
 
印度应该先与东南亚和欧洲竞争，然后再试图挑战中国。
 
@BharatSuperPower3020
SE Asia and Europe? This is akin to putting a 12 year old in the Octagon with a trained UFC fighter. No competition.
 
东南亚和欧洲？这就像让一个12岁的孩子与训练有素的UFC拳手在八角笼中对决，他毫无胜算可言。
 
@misterbig9025
We only play cricket. I'm sure we can beat SE Asia
 
我们只打板球，我相信我们能打败东南亚。
 
@edhiepitz
well India actually bigger and stronger than many Individual SE country, if you mean whole of them then that will be a different story
 
好吧，印度实际上比许多个别东南亚国家更大更强，如果你指的是整个东南亚，那就另当别论了。
 
@RoseRose-gk6ku
Singapore is 100 years beyond India. Malaysia & Thailand are much much much better than India. And Vietnam & Indonesia are much better than India.
 
新加坡领先印度100年，马来西亚和泰国比印度好得多，越南和印尼也比印度好得多。
 
@supergroovy8346
@edhiepitz Yes. As a group the population is closer. So ASEAN and EU. India is basically like EU, several countries speaking different languages grouped together. Like EU has Christianity, India has Hinduism.
 
确实如此。印度从人口规模来看更接近东盟和欧盟。印度本质上就像欧盟，由多个说不同语言的地区组成。就像欧盟以基督教为纽带一样，印度则以印度教为纽带。
 
@nanyanguo1
@misterbig9025 cricket was a fav sport of brit aristocrats. It has no mass or global appeal but the indians revered this anachronistic game as they always revered the aristocracy element of their former brit colonial master. As there are insufficient countries taking up cricket seriously, it could not be included as competitive sport in Olympic Games even as india tried to get it included in the recent paris olympics.
 
板球曾是英国贵族最爱的运动。这项运动缺乏大众和全球吸引力，但印度人却对这种过时的运动情有独钟，就像他们一直崇拜前英国殖民统治者的贵族元素一样。由于认真开展板球运动的国家太少，尽管印度努力推动，仍未能将板球纳入最近巴黎奥运会的竞赛项目。
 
@johnlay3040
@MrHunzi Indonesia is its matching competitor, but it might have a difficulties to win, due mainly to its excessively oversized population.
 
印度尼西亚是与之匹配的竞争对手，但由于人口规模过于庞大，印度可能难以胜出。
 
@MrHunzi
@johnlay3040 Indonesia has never thought about defeating anyone, they just want to live a better life, become a high-income country and live a decent life. In Aisa, except for India, who thinks about defeating others all day long.
 
印度尼西亚从未想过要击败任何人，他们只想过上更好的生活，成为高收入国家，过上体面的生活。在亚洲，除了印度整天想着打败别人，还有谁是这样呢？
 
@johnlay3040
@MrHunzi I don't think India is that sort of country either. Economically, yes they are quite ambitious, but not militarily. Indians, like Chinese, are peaceful people. There is only one Asian nation that copies the West to become an aggressive warmonger in Asia. Everyone knows which country that is.
 
我也不认为印度是那种国家。在经济上，他们确实很有野心，但军事上并非如此，印度人和中国人一样都是热爱和平的民族。亚洲只有一个国家效仿西方成为好战分子，大家都知道是哪个国家。
 
@nshadow888
India compete Africa first, south America before talk about south east Asia, please.
 
印度还是先和非洲、南美洲比一比，再来说东南亚吧。
 
@therover65
China first made sure everyone within its borders are educated and spoke a common language (an amazing feat for a country as huge and as diverse as China). We see stories of village kids in desolate areas walking miles to school in the middle of winter. China will still be the "next China". The West can propagandize all they want. India is a frightful mess compared to China and will need half a century to fix, if they know the roadmap and they start now. (I'm Singaporean and have nothing against India.)
 
中国首先确保其境内的每个人都受过教育并说一种共同的语言（对于一个像中国这样庞大而多样的国家来说，这是一项惊人的壮举），我们看到过偏远地区的农村孩子在严冬中步行数英里去上学的故事。中国仍将是"下一个中国"，西方可以随心所欲地宣传。与中国相比，印度是一团糟，如果他们知道路线图并现在开始行动，将需要半个世纪来修复（我是新加坡人，我对印度没有任何敌意）。
 
@victorwong4938
Lol, there are real commonalities and common roots of the eight main Chinese dialects to Mandarin, that is why there is only one Chinese language but about a dozen spoken are only dialects, but India has over 1600 languages.
 
哈哈，八种主要的汉语方言与普通话有真正的共性和共同的根源，这就是为什么只有一种汉语的原因，有大约十几种口语只是方言，但印度有超过1600种语言。
 
@therover65
 @victorwong4938  Why “lol”? Not all people within China’s borders are Han Chinese. China recognizes 56 minorities, who do not share any language commonalities with Han Chinese. You think minorities don’t matter? Minorities who felt neglected or discriminated against are the biggest source of instability: eg. India, Burma, just to name a couple.
 
为什么要“笑”？中国境内的人并非都是汉族。中国承认56个少数民族，他们与汉族没有任何语言上的共同点。你认为少数民族不重要吗？感到被忽视或被歧视的少数民族是不稳定的最大根源：例如印度、缅甸，仅举几例。
 
@victorwong4938
 @therover65  These days, nearly all younger generations of minorities speak good Mandarin, so there is no problem communication between Han and minorities. Second, although minorities languages but like Tibetan  don't belong to the Han family language, some of those minority languages are somewhat similar to Han.
 
如今，几乎所有少数民族的年轻一代都能说一口流利的普通话，所以汉族和少数民族之间的交流不成问题。其次，少数民族语言虽然不属于汉族语系，如藏语，但有些少数民族语言与汉族有些相似。
 
@DouglasW-m9z
Indians loves their English colonial master, without their master they wouldn't have India as today. India would be like Africa continent with more than 50 countries.
English colonial master already divided India into a few countries luke Sri Lanka, Pakistan, Bagandash, part of Afghanistan, Nepal.
Despite all these, Indians still in loves with their colonial master.
 
印度人热爱他们的英国殖民统治者，没有他们的主人就不会有今天的印度，印度就会像非洲大陆一样分裂成50多个国家。
英国殖民统治者已经把印度分裂成了几个国家，如斯里兰卡、巴基斯坦、孟加拉国、阿富汗的一部分、尼泊尔。
尽管如此，印度人仍然热爱他们的殖民统治者。
 
@peterhsieh380
I believe you have missed out Malaysian because they spesk better English than Indian.
 
你漏了马来西亚人，他们的英语比印度人好得多。
 
@Utube1024
That is true their English proficiency is on par with Singapore.
 
确实，马来西亚人的英语水平与新加坡人不相上下。
 
@IceCream-8668
India won Zero Gold in 2024 Olympics
while US and China won 40 Golds each
 
印度在2024年奥运会上获得了零枚金牌。
而美国和中国各获得40枚金牌。
 
@hengongchua6250
And just last week the Indian beat the Chinese in chess and all Indians chanting India is superpower.
 
就在上周，印度人在国际象棋中击败了中国，所有印度人都在高呼印度是超级大国。
 
@BharatSuperPower3020
They actually regressed because they won one gold in the Tokyo Olympics ��
 
印度反而退步了——东京奥运会好歹还拿过1块金牌呢。
 
@Facts..Checker
43 Gold medals for China if Territories which are part of China are counted. Even China national anthem were played 42 times not 40!
 
若计入中国领土范围内的地区，中国获得了43枚金牌，中国国歌实际奏响42次而非40次。
 
@electromega3077
Each time when an Indian nationalist is becoming a grammar gestapo because he/her is loosing an argumentation, I always reply back by saying that he/her is so lucky that he/her ancestors were ruled by the British for almost 200 years and English is still their official language.
 
每当印度民族主义者在辩论失利充当语法警察时，我总会回应：他们该庆幸他们的祖先被英国统治了近200年，英语至今仍是他们的官方语言。
 
@orozcoapaza1660
I speak English but am learning Chinese cause more and more technical material is in Chinese nowadays, India should promote it's own languages for soft power rather than an invader's one...
 
我虽会说英语但正在学中文，因为现今技术资料多采用中文。印度应推广本土语言而非殖民者的语言来提升软实力。
 
@MrHunzi
Language is just a tool. I have been learning English all my life, on and off. I would learn it when it was needed for work, but I would regress after a while. However, English has benefited me a lot and I have seen a lot of different things.
 
语言仅是工具。我断断续续学了一辈子英语，工作需要时学，闲置后会生疏，但英语让我受益匪浅，见识到了更广阔的世界。
 
@dehua-2730
English is overrated. It's good to know it but it also means that the country has no more sovereignty and identity like India. India has no unified system, it's a victim of long colonialism like the Philippines that praise itself as democratic and proud of being Fd by the Spaniards and US. Anybody with integrity and pride would not brag about this.
 
英语被高估了。掌握它虽好，却意味着如印度般丧失主权与认同。印度缺乏统一的体制，是与菲律宾同样的长期殖民受害者——后者还以被西班牙和美国殖民为荣，但凡有尊严者都不会炫耀这点。
 
@blcheah2672
The Philippines doesn't even have its own name. (It's named after their conqueror, Philip II.)
And the name India is literally invented by the British. (Natives called the South Asian region different names because they have so many languages.)
 
菲律宾甚至没有自己的国名（其名源自征服者菲利普二世），而"印度"这个名称完全是英国人发明的（南亚原住民因语言众多对该地区有不同的称呼）。
 
@stevewang2
The countries you mentioned, India and Philippines, their people are suffering from very serious cases of "colonialism of the mind".
 
你提到的印度和菲律宾等国人民正遭受严重的"思想殖民主义"的荼毒。
 
@hanmi1216
Indonesia also suffer for long colonialism, for about 300 years with the Netherland. But we don't speak Dutch
 
印尼同样承受了长达300年的荷兰殖民统治，但我们并不说荷兰语。
 
@privacyhelp
The Romans, Ancient Egyptians, Ancient Chinese, Soviets, Japanese, Mongols, and various civilizations didn't care about English. Why should we?
 
罗马人、古埃及人、古代中国人、苏联人、日本人、蒙古人等众多文明都未曾在意英语，我们为何要在乎？
 
@johnlay3040
Since British imperialism following its industrial revolution, English has become world linguafranca until today. That's why we care; that's why we could communicate with each other here. It's a good easy language, relatively speaking.
 
自工业革命后的英国殖民时代起，英语就成了世界通用语言，直至今日。这就是为什么我们重视它，这就是为什么我们才能在此交流的原因。相对而言，这是一种简单易学的语言。
 
@privacyhelp
Not really, it's all about multilingualism these days. Even many Americans themselves say they don't speak English, they speak American.
 
未必，当今是多语种时代，连很多美国人都自称不说英语而说美式英语。
 
@johnlay3040
Don't be silly. They are all English spoken with different accents and slightly different grammatical rules.
 
别犯傻了，这些都只是带不同口音和轻微语法差异的英语的变体。
 
@michihofer587
German engineers are still better than all of you combined because Chinese, Japanese can copy but they can't innovate technology.
 
德国工程师仍然比你们所有人加起来都强，中日两国只会模仿而不会技术创新。
 
@jonihiu3954
I live in Indonesia. What you said about Indonesia is 100% true.
 
我生活在印尼，你关于印尼的论述完全正确。
 
@edhiepitz
no he isn't. Indonesia had similarity with India, i remember back then when i still a kid, Indonesian leader used to boast BS shit like Modi. it just recently we become more humble because we has to! other ASEAN beat us like a dog.
 
并非如此。印尼与印度相似，我幼时记得印尼领导人也像莫迪那样吹嘘。近年我们被迫变得谦逊，因为东盟其他国家把我们打得落花流水。
 
@Huaxiaviewpoint
Indonesia and Malaysia still have serious policies of discrimination against non-Muslims. There have been brutal massacres against Chinese in history. Unfortunately, they have not yet publicly apologized or compensated. I have a very bad impression of these two countries.
As for India, I think it is still a relatively peaceful country. Although there are territorial disputes between us, the former colonizers caused the territorial disputes. We just hope that India can respect history and not continue the mistakes of the colonizers.
 
印尼和马来西亚仍然存在严重的非穆斯林歧视政策，其历史上针对华人的血腥屠杀至今未公开道歉或赔偿，我对这两国印象极差。
至于印度，我认为它仍是一个相对和平的国家。尽管中印存在领土争端，但这是前殖民者埋下的祸根。我们只希望印度能尊重历史，不再延续殖民者的错误。
 
@iechuanlee9326
Yes india win with its english & can keep its colonial past but Chinese is proud of its own language mandarin and all its ethnic languages.
 
是的，印度凭借英语"获胜"并保留了殖民历史，但中国以普通话和各民族的语言为傲。
 
@INDIANSARESICKMENOFASIA
Fact 1: Date: X/ 09/ 2024
Putin said, "some of my family members, the little ones, speak Chinese too - they speak it fluently".
Fact 2: Trump's grand daughter, Arabella Kushner, singing in Mandarin.
Fact 3: Stock market genius, Jim Roger, told his daughters to learn/speak Mandarin.
Fact 4: Date: 13/09/2024
Putin said this in his own words: "Russia and China jointly defend the principles of a fair democratic world order based on international law, sovereignty, and equality
Nothing was mentioned about India, Hindi or any other Indian languages.
What do these facts tell you? India is not going to be a superpower country in your or my lifetime. Trump and Putin and Jin Rogers have decided that their descendants will not touch Hindi or any Indian languages. Why? Because these languages are not going to help them in their life/career/business/diplomatic relations etc.
Putin knows who can be trusted and who can't be trusted.
India has left the chat.
 
事实1：普京称"我的部分家庭成员，年幼的那些，也会说中文——他们说得很流利"。
事实2：特朗普的孙女阿拉贝拉用中文演唱。
事实3：股市天才吉姆·罗杰斯要求女儿学习中文。
事实4：普京原话："俄中共同捍卫基于国际法、主权与平等的公正民主世界秩序"。
全程未提及印度、印地语或其他印度语言。
这说明了什么？这说明印度在你我有生之年都不会成为超级大国。特朗普、普京和罗杰斯都已决定不让后代接触印地语等印度语言。为何？因为这些语言对他们的生活/事业/商业/外交毫无助益。
普京清楚谁值得信任。
印度已退出群聊。
 
@dongiovanni8899
The UN has 6 working languages: English, French, Russian, Chinese, Spanish, Arabic. But no superpower language Hindi or other Indian languages, yet India is asking to be a UNSC permanent member
 
联合国的六种工作语言：英语、法语、俄语、中文、西班牙语、阿拉伯语，但没有"超级大国的语言"印地语或其他印度语言，印度却还想当安理会常任理事国。
 
@patrickkoh1056
A very good analysis.
India does not have much advantage. China has far more advantage in politics, economy, education, social culture, IQ, technology, software. Industry leadership, etc.
India is too far behind in almost everything.
 
分析很到位。
印度没有什么优势。中国在政治、经济、教育、社会文化、智商、技术、软件、行业领导力等方面的优势大得多。
印度几乎在所有方面都落后了太多。
 
@yaphonghor4409
Salute you for speaking the truth, hopefully the Indians can see your information as useful!
 
向你说出真相致敬，希望印度人能认识到这些信息的有用性！
 
@Kanchhakaji1731
India wouldn't be India today without British colonialism
 
没有英国的殖民统治，印度就不会是今天的印度。
 
@johnlay3040
There wasn't India as a country before British colonialisation.
 
在英国殖民之前，印度根本不是一个国家。
 
@rtc3000
They also forgotten Koreans who mostly don't speak English but their innovative mindset and greater competitiveness is world class. Also Taiwanese.
I guess Indians feel that they are better due to Indians as CEO of Microsoft and once a PM of UK but they forgotten that yet are just taking over from others.
Even English speaking countries like UK and Australia... What are they known for? Certainly not innovations and works class brains.
Lastly... If what was said is true? That India has advantage in population and English....will they be satisfied mentally and then leave it at that? I don't see efforts been made to realize this potential... Yet
 
他们还忘了韩国人——他们大多数人不说英语但创新思维和竞争力世界一流，还有台湾（地区）。
我猜印度人因微软的CEO和英国前首相是印度裔而自视甚高，却忘了这只是在接替他人位置。
就连英国和澳大利亚等英语国家...以什么闻名？肯定不是创新和一流的头脑。
最后...如果人口和英语真的是优势，印度人会满足于此吗？我看不到他们发挥潜力的努力...
 
@PoppinC-l3w
Don't forget Kamala Harris who was raised in an Indian household and is half-Indian who was US vice president. Ireland (Leo Varadkar) and Portugal (Antonio Costa) have had presidents of Indian descent too.
 
别忘了在印度家庭长大的美国副总统哈里斯（半印度血统），爱尔兰（瓦拉德卡）和葡萄牙（科斯塔）也有印度裔总统。
 
@cheekeong3045
from my point of view knowing English is just a small advantage in helping a country in economy but most importantly the working attitude of citizens
 
在我看来，懂英语对经济只有微小的助益，最重要的是国民的工作态度。
 
@jure2008
Keep up the good work. Your postings are really true - nothing is exaggerated. You are capturing the small minds of Indians perfectly.
 
请继续输出好作品。你的视频完全真实——毫无夸张，你精准捕捉了印度人的狭隘思维。
 
@採菊绚麗
Great respect for your profound thoughts on the building blocks of national competitive advantages and the importance of a national education.
India is an ex-colony but the colonisation of the Indian minds continues because of its educational system. This system creates Anglicised political, media and business demagogues. They embrace elitism and Western political culture indeed. This explains India's divisive politics and the alienation of the" ruling classes" from the "working classes"; similar to that in the Anglo-Saxon countries, in particular India's ex- colonial master, the UK. It's unfortunate. Indians are trapped in their British colonial past by its Anglicised educational system.
 
我深深敬佩你对国家竞争优势基石和国民教育重要性的深刻见解。
印度虽是前殖民地，但因教育体系导致思想殖民持续。这个体系培养出了英式政治、媒体和商业煽动者，他们拥抱精英主义和西方的政治文化。这解释了印度分裂的政治和"统治阶级"与"劳动阶级"的疏离——类似盎格鲁-撒克逊国家，尤其是印度的前殖民宗主国英国。不幸的是印度人被英式教育体系困在了殖民历史中。