QA：您认为韩国、中国还是日本的历史剧更好？为什么？
Do you think Korea, China, or Japan produces better historical dramas? Why?
译文简介
网友：我无法中立地评判哪个国家的历史剧更好，一千个人有一千个哈姆雷特。但我可以确认的一件事是，中国历史剧的多样性和丰富性是日本和韩国无法比拟的。一般来说，日本的所有历史剧看起来都和中国以唐朝为背景的历史剧相似......
正文翻译
rofile photo for Aya Shawn
Aya Shawn
Knows ChineseAug 25
I can't neutrally judge which country's historical drama is better, there are a thousand Hamlets for a thousand people.
But one thing I can confirm is that the diversity and richness of Chinese historical dramas cannot be compared with Japan and South Korea.
Generally speaking, all historical dramas in Japan look similar to historical dramas with the background of the Tang Dynasty in China.
我无法中立地评判哪个国家的历史剧更好，一千个人有一千个哈姆雷特。
但我可以确认的一件事是，中国历史剧的多样性和丰富性是日本和韩国无法比拟的。
一般来说，日本的所有历史剧看起来都和中国以唐朝为背景的历史剧相似。
Aya Shawn
Knows ChineseAug 25
I can't neutrally judge which country's historical drama is better, there are a thousand Hamlets for a thousand people.
But one thing I can confirm is that the diversity and richness of Chinese historical dramas cannot be compared with Japan and South Korea.
Generally speaking, all historical dramas in Japan look similar to historical dramas with the background of the Tang Dynasty in China.
我无法中立地评判哪个国家的历史剧更好，一千个人有一千个哈姆雷特。
但我可以确认的一件事是，中国历史剧的多样性和丰富性是日本和韩国无法比拟的。
一般来说，日本的所有历史剧看起来都和中国以唐朝为背景的历史剧相似。
This is historical dramas in Japan
historical dramas with the background of the Tang Dynasty in China.
1、这是日本的历史剧
2、以中国唐朝为背景的中国历史剧。
All Korean historical dramas are similar to Chinese historical dramas of the Ming Dynasty.
所有韩国历史剧都与中国明朝历史剧相似。
所有韩国历史剧都与中国明朝历史剧相似。
This is Korean historical dramas
This is Chinese historical dramas of the Ming Dynasty.
1、这是韩国历史剧
2、这是中国明朝历史剧。
However, China has more than a dozen different dynasties, and their cultural styles, architecture, and clothing are completely different. The richness of China is beyond the reach of Japan and South Korea.
Look at these:
This is a costume drama with the background of the xia Dynasty, 4000 years ago
This is a costume drama with the background of the Shang Dynasty, 3000 years ago, the golden bronze armor
2,200 years ago, the costume drama of the Qin Empire, these soldiers are exactly the same as the Terracotta Army of Qin Shihuang
1800 years ago, the Han Empire. General of the Han Dynasty played by Jack Chen
1600 years ago, the Three Kingdoms period. famous three brothers
1500 years ago, stills from the Sui Empire period. unreliable emperor
1300 years ago, a costume drama of the Tang Empire. gorgeous clothes, gorgeous times
1000 years ago, a costume drama set in the Song Dynasty. Clothing becomes elegant and restrained
600 years ago, the background of the Yuan Dynasty. Actors wear two braids, which is a Mongolian custom
400 years ago, a costume drama of the Ming Empire. The bright colors of clothing are back again, the age of self-confidence. Zheng He's Great Voyages
300 years ago, during the Qing Dynasty. Manchu hats and hairstyles
100 years ago, the Republic of China was established. At this time, the costume drama, the ladies wear cheongsam
然而中国有十几个不同的朝代，他们的文化风格、建筑、服饰都完全不同。中国的丰富程度是日本、韩国所望尘莫及的。
看看这些：
这是一部以4000年前夏朝为背景的古装剧 （配图：大禹治水）
这是一部以商代为背景的古装剧，展示了3000年前的金铜甲 （配图：封神）
2200年前，秦帝国古装剧，这些士兵和秦始皇兵马俑一模一样 （配图：大秦帝国）
1800年前，汉帝国。陈龙饰演的汉武将 （配图：神话）
1600年前，三国时期。著名的三兄弟 （配图：三国）
1500年前，隋帝国时期剧照。不靠谱的皇帝 （配图：隋唐演义）
1300年前，一部大唐古装剧。华丽的衣服，华丽的时光 （配图：长安12时辰）
1000年前，一部以宋朝为背景的古装剧。服装变得优雅内敛（配图：知否知否应是绿肥红瘦）
600年前，背景为元朝。演员扎两条辫子，这是蒙古族的习俗 （配图：倚天屠龙记）
400年前，一部明帝国的古装剧。服装的鲜艳色彩又回来了，自信的时代。郑和下西洋的时代 （配图：山河明月）
300年前，清朝时期。满族帽子和发型 （配图：延禧攻略）
100年前，ROC成立。这时候的古装剧，名媛们都穿旗袍 （配图：花样年华）
Look at these:
This is a costume drama with the background of the xia Dynasty, 4000 years ago
This is a costume drama with the background of the Shang Dynasty, 3000 years ago, the golden bronze armor
2,200 years ago, the costume drama of the Qin Empire, these soldiers are exactly the same as the Terracotta Army of Qin Shihuang
1800 years ago, the Han Empire. General of the Han Dynasty played by Jack Chen
1600 years ago, the Three Kingdoms period. famous three brothers
1500 years ago, stills from the Sui Empire period. unreliable emperor
1300 years ago, a costume drama of the Tang Empire. gorgeous clothes, gorgeous times
1000 years ago, a costume drama set in the Song Dynasty. Clothing becomes elegant and restrained
600 years ago, the background of the Yuan Dynasty. Actors wear two braids, which is a Mongolian custom
400 years ago, a costume drama of the Ming Empire. The bright colors of clothing are back again, the age of self-confidence. Zheng He's Great Voyages
300 years ago, during the Qing Dynasty. Manchu hats and hairstyles
100 years ago, the Republic of China was established. At this time, the costume drama, the ladies wear cheongsam
然而中国有十几个不同的朝代，他们的文化风格、建筑、服饰都完全不同。中国的丰富程度是日本、韩国所望尘莫及的。
看看这些：
这是一部以4000年前夏朝为背景的古装剧 （配图：大禹治水）
这是一部以商代为背景的古装剧，展示了3000年前的金铜甲 （配图：封神）
2200年前，秦帝国古装剧，这些士兵和秦始皇兵马俑一模一样 （配图：大秦帝国）
1800年前，汉帝国。陈龙饰演的汉武将 （配图：神话）
1600年前，三国时期。著名的三兄弟 （配图：三国）
1500年前，隋帝国时期剧照。不靠谱的皇帝 （配图：隋唐演义）
1300年前，一部大唐古装剧。华丽的衣服，华丽的时光 （配图：长安12时辰）
1000年前，一部以宋朝为背景的古装剧。服装变得优雅内敛（配图：知否知否应是绿肥红瘦）
600年前，背景为元朝。演员扎两条辫子，这是蒙古族的习俗 （配图：倚天屠龙记）
400年前，一部明帝国的古装剧。服装的鲜艳色彩又回来了，自信的时代。郑和下西洋的时代 （配图：山河明月）
300年前，清朝时期。满族帽子和发型 （配图：延禧攻略）
100年前，ROC成立。这时候的古装剧，名媛们都穿旗袍 （配图：花样年华）
评论翻译
很赞 ( 83 )
收藏
Rhoda Fort
· Aug 25
I love it all whether it is Korean, Japanese or Chinese. The Chinese drama is strong on plots while Korean drama excels on strong character development. I would agree there is far more variety of styles in Chinese since it has such a long history compared to the other two nations. The Chinese productions are visually stunning and the music well blended. These productions tend to run longer and are extremely immersive. As of now Western entertainment is in a big creative slump, so I and other people in the West are more motivated to watch productions from East Asia now they are so abundant on streaming services. The discovery has enriched my life and helped open my eyes more to the world around me.
Thanks for sharing these photos and the captions. It does help make sense of it all.
无论是韩国、日本还是中国，我都喜欢。中国电视剧注重情节，而韩剧则注重人物塑造。我同意中国的风格要多样化得多，因为与其他两个国家相比，它有着悠久的历史。中国作品视觉效果令人惊叹，音乐融合得很好。这些作品往往持续时间较长且极具沉浸感。截至目前，西方娱乐业正处于创意大衰退中，因此我和其他西方人更有动力观看来自东亚的作品，因为他们的流媒体服务非常丰富。这一发现丰富了我的生活，帮助我更多地了解周围的世界。
感谢您分享这些照片和标题。它确实有助于理解这一切。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
Joe Huang
· Aug 25
I remember as a small child in Hong Kong in the 1950s (yes, I’m that old now 75) and even as a young adult in the US watching historical movies from Hong Kong and Taiwan and feeling unsatisfied that the sets, costumes, and scenery all looked the same, probably due to budgetary and locale constraints and a lack of seriousness of the movie makers.
One of the cultural contributions of the PRC that I haven’t heard too much comment( maybe there are but I just haven’t paid attention) are the historical dramas sine the 1990s that have tapped into the true richness and diversity of China’s historical past. To me, it all started when a dear old professor from Shanghai who has since passed away recommended that I watch the TV series 唐明皇which I thoroughly enjoyed. That was around the year 2000. I’ve since seen quite a few historical movies and TV series that have expanded my view of different periods of the Chinese past. I think the movie industry in China has a unparalleled advantage compared to that of Hong Kong and Taiwan in being immersed in the historical legacy rather than imagining it from one’s mind or books. I also think that’s why Western movies set in Chins also tend to be stilted and stereotypic. When I was growing up in Denver Colorado in the 60s my parents would take my brother and me to movies that portrayed China but then afterwards they’d complain about how bad they were. I especially remember the General who died at dawn, a movie with Gary cooper(?) and a Chinese warlord who was played by a local Chinese American and spoke in Cantonese! When a soldier spilt tea on the general’s clothes, the general told him to “da say gee gay’” 打死自己！go shoot yourself! I was just 10 years old but even I knew that wasn’t right;-)
我记得小时候在 20世纪 50年代的香港（是的，我现在已经 75 岁了），作为一个在美国的年轻人，观看香港和台湾的历史电影，对布景、服装和风格感到不满意。风景看起来都一样，可能是由于预算和场地限制以及电影制作人缺乏严肃性。
我没有听到太多中华人民共和国文化贡献（也许有，但我只是没有注意到）。直到 20世纪 90年代才开始出现历史剧，它们挖掘了中国历史的真正丰富性和多样性。对我来说，这一切都是从上海一位已去世的老教授推荐给我的一部电视剧《唐明皇》开始的，我很喜欢。那是在2000年左右，我看了很多历史电影和电视剧，扩大了我对中国过去不同时期的看法。我认为中国电影业比香港和台湾电影业有一个无可比拟的优势，那就是沉浸在历史遗产中，而不是凭自己的头脑或书本想象。我也认为这就是为什么以中国为背景的西方电影也往往显得生硬和刻板。六十年代，当我在科罗拉多州丹佛长大时，我的父母会带我和我的兄弟去看描绘中国的电影，但后来他们会抱怨这些电影有多糟糕。我特别记得黎明时分死去的将军，加里·库珀的电影，还有一个由当地华裔美国人扮演，说粤语的中国军阀！当一名士兵把茶洒在将军的衣服上时，将军告诉他“da say gee gay”，打死自己！去开枪吧！我当时只有 10 岁，但我也知道这是不对的;-)
TCC
· Aug 25
What are the names of the xia and Yuan dynasty dramas?
图片里夏朝和元朝的历史剧叫啥名字？
Lu Liu
· Aug 29
封神榜
Jim Kam
· Sep 8
封神榜 relates to the era of late Shang/early Zhou which came after the xia dynasty. In fact, so little is known about the xia I doubt enough material could be gathered to make a drama (not a lot is known about the Shang either except for that 封神榜 part, and it’s mostly a legend).
封神榜涉及夏朝之后的商末周初时代。事实上，人们对夏朝知之甚少，我怀疑是否能收集到足够的材料来制作一部戏剧（除了封神榜部分之外，对商朝也知之甚少，而且这主要是一个传说）。
Tai Fu
· Aug 25
It's kinda like films on Roman empire, medi Europe, post reformation Europe, American colony, industrial revolution, and modern times.
All different countries, but same amount of time nevertheless.
The 1800s and 1900s were so vastly different that there was a huge generational gap, with each generation having unique cultures.
这有点像关于罗马帝国、中世纪欧洲、宗教改革后的欧洲、美国殖民地、工业革命和现代的电影。
虽然都是不同的国家，但时间却是一样的。
1800年代和1900年代差异巨大，代沟巨大，每一代人都有独特的文化。
Profile photo for Yashariku (夜叉戮)
Yashariku (夜叉戮)
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
you’re right that neutral judgement of these drams is not possible. None of us are unbiased.
答主是对的，对这些电视剧的中立判断是不可能的。我们中没有人是公正的。
Nursofiatul Aini
· Aug 26
Could anyone share the titles of every Chinese dramas above?
谁能分享一下上面答主贴图的每部中国电视剧的名字吗？
Selene Ni
· Sep 5
I highly recommend Empresses in the Palace and Scarlet Heart(2011). This Scarlet Heart should be the Chinese one, it is not to be confused with the Korean adaptation called Scarlet Heart Ryo which is not the original. Empresses in the Palace and Scarlet Heart of 2011 are one of the most classic period dramas that won everyone’s heart when it came out.
For a more recent one, I highly recommend The Untamed.
我强烈推荐《甄嬛传》和《步步惊心》(2011)。这个《步步惊心》应该是中国版的，不要与韩国改编版《步步惊心 Ryo》混淆，后者不是原著。 2011年的《甄嬛传》和《步步惊心》是最经典的古装剧之一，一经推出就赢得了大家的喜爱。
对于最近的一部，我强烈推荐《陈情令》。
Nursofiatul Aini
· Sep 5
Thank you for the recommendation. I only ever watched The Myth (2005), Ruyi’s Royal Love, and The Longest Day in Changan. They are all great.
谢谢你的推荐。我只看过《神话》（2005）、《如懿传》和《长安十二时辰》。他们都很棒。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
ZhiG Chen
· Nov 19
If you like watching Chinese historical dramas, I recommend watching "The Ming Dynasty 1566" 《大明王朝1566》and "The Qin Empire"《大秦帝国》，and there are some good historical documentaries you can watch on China Central Television
如果你喜欢看中国历史剧，我推荐看《大明王朝1566》和《大秦帝国》，中央电视台也有一些不错的历史纪录片
Máté Bakk
· Aug 25
I mean the clothes are gorgeous, but that’s just one aspect, isn’t it? Production value, acting, fight scenes (if there is any), plots (from what I understand China and Japan have historical periods that would make Game of Thrones look like a walk in a park /I would also assume that Korea have one as well/). How do they compare?
我的意思是衣服很华丽，但这只是一方面，不是吗？制作价值、表演、打斗场面（如果有的话）、情节（据我了解，中国和日本都有历史时期，这会让《权力的游戏》看起来就像在公园散步。我也认为韩国也有这样的历史时期，他们如何比较？
판 간
· Sep 15
I don't like watching China-related videos because of the Chinese language. This sounds louder than Japanese and Korean languages.
因为中文，我不喜欢看与中国相关的视频。这听起来比日语和韩语更吵。
Ssc Ventures
· Aug 31
China = fake history and fake costume (a copy of korean hanbok called hanfu )
中国=J历史和J服装（韩国韩服的复制品，称为汉服）
Profile photo for 张 克庭
张 克庭
I think you're the joker actor who outdid Robert De Niro.
我认为你是超越罗伯特·德尼罗的小丑演员。
Clist shain
· Nov 8
I kind of understand why Mr. Aya said in an answer before that Chinese people hate Koreans very much.
After reading this reply, I also think they are really annoying.
我有点理解为什么Aya先生之前在一个回答里说中国人非常讨厌韩国人了。
看了这个回复之后，我也觉得他们真的很讨厌。
ZhiG Chen
· Nov 19
Ancient Korean documents were recorded in Chinese. Guess why?
古代朝鲜文献是用中文记载的。猜猜为什么？
Wei Cheng
· Sep 13
Hanfu is a broad term.
Some hanfu from certain period might be influenced by hanbok, but that doesn’t mean that hanfu is a copy of hanbok.
汉服是一个广义的术语。
某些时期的汉服可能受到韩服的影响，但这并不意味着汉服是韩服的复制品。
Profile photo for 诅咒你 画个圈圈
诅咒你 画个圈圈
korean hanbok copied Chinese hanfu , LMAO .
韩国韩服抄袭中国汉服，你是要笑死我吗。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
Sampoerna Adi
· Aug 25
Partially agreed. I think it isn't fair, kinda comparison of apples and oranges.
Let's change the question to be more specific and less biased:
Among China, Korea and Japan, which historical drama achieved international awards and highly praised the most?
Do you think the answer is Chinese drama? I highly doubt.
部分同意。我认为这是不公平的，有点像苹果和橙子的比较。
让我们把问题改得更具体、更少偏见：
中、韩、日三国历史剧中，哪部历史剧获得国际奖项和好评最多？
你认为答案是中国戏剧吗？我非常怀疑。
Wei Shi
· Aug 25
Korean Historical Drama have insane amount fake stuff.
韩国历史剧有大量虚假内容。
D Westfield
· Aug 28
It’s called fiction and entertainment, not documentary! Since you know nothing about Korean history how would you even know what’s genuine and what’s fake? Who died and left you an expert in Korean history and Korean entertainment????
这是小说和娱乐，而不是纪录片！既然你对韩国历史一无所知，你怎么知道什么是真的，什么是假的？谁死了，给你留下了韩国历史和韩国娱乐方面的专家？？？
Sampoerna Adi
· Aug 26
I'm unsure about that but Wen... publicly said he's a big fan of KDrama titled “大长今”
我对此不太确定，但温公开表示他是韩剧《大长今》的忠实粉丝
Wei Shi
· Sep 2
It Kdrama regarding female cooking & medical officer (I never see the whole, but wonder what happen to her exfriend-teacher when her family fallen.).
这是关于女性厨师和医生的故事（我从来没有看到全部，但想知道当她的家人倒下时，她的前朋友老师会发生什么。）。
Sampoerna Adi
· Sep 2
Honestly Chinese dramas mostly aren't targeted for international audiences and the storylines are strange, uncommon or unfamiliar for us foreigners.
Meanwhile Korean dramas adapted for international audiences and Japanese dramas are very distinctive but in general they have universal storylines accepted for international audiences (for example the popularity of Oshin). Ask your parents about Japanese drama titled Oshin and what their impression of it.
老实说，中国电视剧大多不是针对国际观众的，故事情节对我们外国人来说很奇怪、不常见或不熟悉。
同时，针对国际观众改编的韩剧和日剧虽然各具特色，但总体上具有为国际观众所接受的通用故事情节（例如《阿信》的受欢迎程度）。询问您的父母有关名为《阿信》的日剧以及他们对它的印象。
진석 황
· Oct 8
We are some dramas have fiction also some dramas only documentary
but why Chinese documentary title but still have fake ? This is why no one watch Chinese drama
我们有些戏剧有小说，有些戏剧只有纪录片
但为什么中国的纪录片片名却还是有假的呢？这就是为什么没人看中国电视剧的原因
Goushis
· Aug 30
Chinese dramas are generally blocked by Western media because of their social form, which makes no sense.
中国电视剧普遍因其社会形态而受到西方媒体的封锁，这是没有道理的。
ERIC MOGENT
· Nov 8
To me Chinese historical dramas are better aligned with tradition & message ight wanna send. There's a drama name Treacherous is well done but my gosh I didn't think a king could be that wicked. One thing I can say is that women & the poorer citizens is looked down upon it's scary. I guess that goes across all race eh?
对我来说，中国历史剧更符合传统和文化。我想发送这条消息。有部剧叫《奸臣》，做得很好，但天哪，我没想到国王会那么邪恶。我可以说的一件事是，无论女性和男性。较贫穷的公民被瞧不起，这很可怕。我想这适用于所有种族吧？
Tjhai Hok Djumadi
· Nov 12
Wouw, thanks
哇 感谢答主
Chang jack
· Nov 12
I am a lover of East Asian history
It is undeniable that China, South Korea and Japan both have ancient histories.
However, China has a long history and rich content that is unmatched by other countries. Both Korea and Japan have very short histories that can be recounted in detail; most of their histories are legends or fragments of Chinese history.
Therefore, the Chinese can make up an infinite number of stories by picking just a little bit from their vast history. This is something that Koreans and Japanese cannot do.
我是个东亚历史爱好者
不可否认，中国韩国和日本，都有古代历史
但是中国的历史时间之长，内容之丰富是其他国家无法比拟的。韩国和日本可以被仔细叙述的历史都很短，大部分历史都是传说，或者来自中国历史中片段的叙述。
所以，中国人只要从他们海量的历史中挑出一点点，就可以编出无限多的故事。这是韩国人和日本人不能做到的。