美国海军陆战队员在参议院听证会上大喊：没人想为以色列而战！被搬断手臂拖拽，场面悲壮！

David White Kaweesi.
No one to help this X Soldier?

没有人来帮帮这位退伍军人吗。

Rodimus Feet Guy
what are they supposed to do? get violent? like January 6th? no, we have to be better than that. these people are just as scared and confused as the rest of us

他们应该怎么做？采取暴力吗？像1月6号那样？不，我们必须比那样做得更好，这些人也和我们其他人一样感到恐惧和困惑。

Someone717
I hope his fellow marines stand up for this patriot!

我希望他的海军陆战队战友们能为这位爱国者挺身而出。

°Perception°
lets remember the security have guns

别忘了安保人员是有枪的。

unicorn
where's freedom of speech btw

顺便问一下，言论自由在哪里。

jensen
protest is supposed to unsettle the comfortable, and this is a form of protest

抗议本就该让安逸的人感到不安，而这就是抗议的一种形式。

sussigma17388
yes because shouting is highly effective and doesnt make the silejt majority dislike your cause even more

是啊，因为大喊大叫非常有效，而且不会让沉默的大多数更加讨厌你的诉求。

Alui
if the silent majority is pro us sending troops to Iran to fight on behalf of Israel, then we need to skip the shouting at people in public and probably start wheeling these people out into the streets like it's the French revolution.

如果沉默的大多数支持我们派兵去伊朗为以色列而战，那我们就没必要在公共场合对着人喊叫了，可能该像法国大革命那样把这些人推到街上去了。

jensen
you say that and this video still got like 10x more exposure it needed than the thousands of silent and still some loud protests out there

你虽这么说，但这视频获得的曝光量依然比外面成千上万个沉默的或大声的抗议活动多出十倍。

sussigma17388
real change occurs when the silent majority change their minds. this simply creayes negative rep for ur cause

真正的改变发生在沉默的大多数改变主意的时候，这只会给你的诉求带来负面名声。

jensen
protests exists because they become voices for people who can’t speak up, why don’t you look at the retrospective and think about why they resorted to protesting

抗议之所以存在，是因为它们成了那些无法发声的人的声音，你为什么不回顾一下，想想他们为什么要诉诸抗议。

sussigma17388
yea cuz the government would listen to one dishevlwd dude rambling. organisation matters

是啊，因为政府会听一个衣衫褴褛的家伙瞎嚷嚷，组织性才重要。

morel
You should never rely on protests, because they are often contradictory. For example, this year there have been many protests in favor of immigration, whereas when Biden was president there were protests against immigration. In conclusion, protests do not represent the will of the majority

你永远不该依赖抗议，因为它们经常自相矛盾。例如，今年有很多支持移民的抗议，而在拜登担任总统时，却有反对移民的抗议。总之，抗议并不代表大多数人的意志。

jensen
being contradicting doesn’t mean it’s meaningless, and protests are meant to PERSUADE the majority and is not the majority at all. i’ll ask you, what r ur thoughts on the civil rights movement n the philippine’s people power

自相矛盾并不意味着毫无意义，抗议是为了说服大多数人，而不是代表大多数。我问你，你怎么看民权运动和菲律宾的人民力量。

Noahh
Protests need to be approved

抗议需要经过批准。

jensen
protesting is a form of freedom of speech, it doesn’t need to be approved

抗议是言论自由的一种形式，不需要经过批准。

Noahh
You just said it’s protesting?

你刚才不是说这是抗议吗。

ಠ_ಠ
So you want him to whisper so no one can hear him?

所以你想让他低声细语，好让谁也听不见。

Userunknown
Kicked out or brutally dragging out

是被踢出去还是被残暴地拽出去。

Ugaaska
slave please its 2026 

求你了奴隶，现在是2026年了。

hyroo!(λ)
You haven't seen how it started, and he was not shouting, he was talking very calmly

你还没看到是怎么开始的，他没有大喊大叫，他说话非常冷静。

sussigma17388
not my problem that context wasnt provided is it?

没有提供上下文又不是我的错，不是吗。

c9f
well it is being provided right now, now change your statement

既然现在提供了，那就收回你刚才的话。

c9f
we can do it the easy way, or we can do it the hard way

我们可以好好商量，也可以走着瞧。

yang
your speaking the wrong information and now its not your problem?

你在传播错误信息，现在又说不是你的问题了。

jengga siuuu
so u are zio

所以你是锡安主义者。

sussigma17388
no i dont ljke zionists at all i also dont like screamers. everything can be done in orderly manner

不，我一点也不喜欢锡安主义者，我也不喜欢乱喊乱叫的人，凡事都可以有条不紊地进行。

Ryo
so why would you assume he started shouting when you dont know the context

既然你不知道上下文，为什么要假设他开始大喊大叫了。

sussigma17388
didnt assume i commented on what i saw

没有假设，我只是针对我看到的内容发表评论。

Zozo ️‍⚧️️‍
so no freedom of speech

所以没有言论自由。

sussigma17388
speech doesnt mean being a pubkic nuisance. should i go to a police ststion and start screaming? a school? nothing changes from chaos. chaos brings more chaos

言论自由并不意味着可以扰乱公共秩序。我应该去警察局大喊大叫吗？还是学校？混乱改变不了任何事。混乱只会带来更多的混乱。

Zozo ️‍⚧️️‍
he didnt cause chaos. he spoke in a normal tone especially for someone in the military. chaos was caused by the officers and congressmen

他没有制造混乱。他的语调很正常，尤其是对于一个军人来说。混乱是由警察和国会议员造成的。

sussigma17388
dont know here bro kinda looks like hes screaming and being forcefully removed

不知道啊哥们，看起来他像是在尖叫并且正被强行带走。

Bro-z
Private property n they got rules if you were at your city park legally they can’t move u

那是私有财产且有规章制度，如果你是在城市公园，法律上他们不能赶你走。

Zozo ️‍⚧️️‍
is the private property in the room with us?

你说的私有财产就在这个房间里吗。

Bro-z
It’s owned by the gov courts r not public property

它由政府所有，法庭不是公共财产。

Zozo ️‍⚧️️‍
so public

所以就是公共的。

Rob.E.2698
Oh so now you care about civil disorder. Not on January 6th when your side tries to overthrow the sitting government, but now when a soldier is telling you the truth about who your counties master really is.

噢，所以你现在开始关心社会动乱了。1月6号你那一边试图推翻现任政府的时候你不在意，现在当一个士兵告诉你关于谁才是你国家真正主人的真相时，你倒在意了。

ISA
watch the full clip, they started dragging him out while he was being calm he only shouted after he was being forced out

看下完整视频，他们在他还很冷静的时候就开始把他往外拽，他是在被强行赶走后才开始喊叫的。

#1 jooyeon stan
he wasnt shouting at the beginning. he was calmly speaking and they started manhandling him

他一开始没有喊叫。他冷静地说话，然后他们开始粗鲁地对待他。

80's_rule
They should Try him for Treason...

他们应该以叛国罪审判他。

Crochethugs
So youre cool with that right?

所以你觉得那样没问题，对吧。

Mohammad
He yelled and they retaliated by attempting to body slam him

他喊了一声，然后他们试图通过过肩摔来报复他。

Your a Chud
no freedom of speech in a senate btw

顺便说一下，参议院里没有言论自由。

Zayne
chudboy

土包子。

K_Tailz
he was speaking in a normal volume at first, right away the cop came and stater to pull him away. thn he started shouting when he was being dragged out

他起初是用正常的音量说话，警察立刻过来开始拉他。然后当他被拖出去时，他才开始喊叫。

sussigma17388
well context matters maybe the full video shouldve been posted

好吧，上下文很重要，也许应该发布完整的视频。

anzo
you don't see the whole meeting, you only see this part

你没看到整个会议，你只看到了这一部分。

sussigma17388
not my problemo

这不是我的问题。

Martins Patrick
So can a citizen go to Iran paliament to even protest like this ? He will be h@nged before down

那么公民可以去伊朗议会进行这样的抗议吗？他在天黑前就会被处以绞刑。

Crochethugs
And you really think it’s just a simple as all that right? Just don’t protest just sit there and take it. That’s not what we do in this country that may be fine for you, but that’s not fine for

你真的认为事情就那么简单吗。就是不要抗议，坐在那里忍受。那不是我们在这种国家做的事，对你来说可能没问题，但对我来说不行。

————

Thokozani Dube
The senator had no authority to eject the individual. That responsibility should have been left to law enforcement.

参议员没有权力驱逐那个人。这种责任本该留给执法部门。

Bjornmarais05
wasnt the senator that fully bashed the door open getting his hand stuck in the first place. it was the law enforcement.

最初猛地推开门导致他手被卡住的并不是参议员，而是执法人员。

Allira
Still, he should not have involved himself like that, it was not his place to push his legs like that

尽管如此，他也不该那样介入，他没资格那样推那个人的腿。

Bjornmarais05
i get that but you cant go ahead and blame it all on him, he probably just meant a good gesture trying to help but it definitely wasnt just his fault

我明白，但你不能把责任全推到他身上，他可能只是出于好意想帮忙，但这绝对不只是他一个人的错。

Allira
I’m assuming they manly blamed him since he carries much power as a person and also it would’ve been hard to see what happened from where all of the people were

我想人们主要指责他是因为他位高权重，而且从众人的视角很难看清到底发生了什么。

Bjornmarais05
and if you reallyyy look at the video he was the only one trying to get the guys hand out at first only then did they stop pulling on him

如果你仔细看视频，起初只有他在尝试把那人的手弄出来，之后他们才停止了拉扯。

Allira
I know but nobody is looking out for that when in person they don’t have time to look at every detail

我知道，但在现场没有人会注意到那些，他们没时间去观察每一个细节。

santaklause04
But then he came to his senses and walked away when he realized the marines arm is broken..he should’ve still stand right there to make sure he helps taking him out completely..Shame on him

但他意识到那名海军陆战队成员的手臂断了之后，他就清醒过来并走开了。他本该留在那里确保协助将其完全救出。真为他感到羞耻。

Tamara
Stop. There was no reason for the senator to get involved. In any other workplace, Americans would be fired for this behavior. Maybe even arrested. This senator should be charged and censured. I hope he loses his seat for this. Damn fascists.

够了。参议员没有任何理由介入。在任何其他工作场所，美国人都会因为这种行为被解雇。甚至可能被逮捕。这位参议员应该受到指控和谴责。我希望他因此丢掉席位。该死的法西斯分子。

TinaTurner
Not his responsibility to help. Now someone’s hand is fractured because he wanted to do something above his job descxtion

帮忙不是他的职责。现在有人因为他想做一些超出职责范围的事而导致手部骨折。

Marksman
So unfortunate we won't witness the aftermath

真遗憾我们无法看到后续处理结果。

bc_i_said_so_duh
if he hadn't interjected he could sit blameless

如果他没有介入，他本可以免受责备。

Rat3ggs
He got paid at least 100,000 dollars from Israel I believe.

我相信他从以色列那里至少拿了10万美元。

Robot Pizza
His “good intentions” equate to assault and battery! You or I don’t know what his intentions are as we are not him. He laid his hands on another human being which resulted in that Marine’s injury. The Senator put himself in that situation which he had zero legal authority or obligation to do…period! If that were you or I that had done what that Senator did…we would be arrested and in jail waiting for bail hearing!

他的“好意”等同于人身攻击和殴打。你我都不知道他的真实意图，因为我们不是他。他对手无寸铁的人动武，导致了那名海军陆战队成员受伤。

这位参议员把自己卷入了这件事，而他根本没有法律授权或义务这样做。如果是你我做了这位参议员所做的事，我们早就被逮捕入狱等待保释听证会了。

.~ STAR✨LIGHT ·*
after he yanked that guy’s leg til he broke his arm and had enough sense to not dig his hole any deeper

在他猛拽那个人的腿直到拽断了人家的手臂后，他总算还有点理智，没有给自己挖更深的坑。

Natanya O'Neill
It absolutely was the responsibility of the guards to ensure the gentleman was safely removed. It’s against the law for a Senator to physically assault ANYONE. The actions he took were illegal.

确保该男子安全撤离绝对是警卫的责任。参议员对任何人进行肢体攻击都是违法的。他采取的行动是非法的。

Natanya O'Neill
Not to mention the fact that he completely broke decorum. As a sitting US senator; he should be impeached.

更不用说他完全破坏了礼仪。作为现任美国参议员，他应该被弹劾。

.~ STAR✨LIGHT ·*
the senator is the one lifting his leg then yanking on it til he broke it. he should get sued

就是那个参议员抬起他的腿然后猛拽，直到把腿弄断。他应该被起诉。

Freakaknight
authority or training

无论是权力还是专业训练。

Roxi
That senator grabbed that man and shoved him full force past the door. He broke his hand. He assaulted him. He needs to be arrested

那位参议员抓住那个男人，使出全身力气把他推过门。他弄断了人家的手。他袭击了他。他需要被逮捕。

TypeShi
The senators the one that started shoving him

是参议员先开始推他的。

Marksman
No sense at all.

完全没有理智。

ThompsonTom
He shouldn’t have been ejected in the first place. Free speech is dead

他起初就不该被驱逐。言论自由已死。

TypeShi
He wanted to get his 15mins of fame on Fox News

他想在福克斯新闻上出名15分钟。

rinpops|| Gamer
this country is supposed to have free speech. NO ONE should have kicked him out. not even law enforcement.

这个国家应该有言论自由。任何人都不该把他赶出去。哪怕是执法人员也不行。

Rolando Zamarripa
Jews were present, that’s why

犹太人在场，这就是原因。

——

Sapay
So an active marine suddenly doesn’t have his right to free speech? Shame I won’t fight for this

所以一名现役海军陆战队员突然就没有言论自由权了？真丢人，我不会为此而战。

ArewaGoldHouse
it's totally wrong he betrayed his country, what was his allegiance?

这完全错了，他背叛了他的国家，他的忠诚何在。

Valerie.M✨
His country is not Israel

他的国家又不是以色列。

Nathan
I think it’s a satire

我觉得这是个讽刺。

johnny7861
no they made several comments and videos like this and then made their account private

不，他们发了好几条这样的评论和视频，然后把账号设为私密了。

ArewaGoldHouse
but his country must have allies and he signed for it he is not a civilian

但他的国家肯定有盟友，而且他签署了协议，他不是平民。

madamgirll
Today it’s an active marine, imagine a citizen, we have to stand for ourselves and no wait until it happens to us before we act.

今天是一名现役海军陆战队员，想象一下如果是普通公民，我们必须为自己挺身而出，而不是等到事情发生在我们身上才采取行动。

White Girl Abroad
Specifically, how did he betray his country?

具体来说，他怎么背叛国家了。

ArewaGoldHouse
oath

誓言。

missingm4rvø
he betrayed his country? how so?

他背叛了他的国家？怎么说。

ArewaGoldHouse
the oath

誓言。

missingm4rvø
what about the oath? lMaoooo

誓言怎么了。

Sapay
What about our rights and freedoms?

那我们的权利和自由呢。

Em (Free )
Not to Israel. He is speaking up FOR his country.

不是对以色列忠诚。他是在为他的国家发声。

ArewaGoldHouse
he signed for it he is not a civilian

他签署了协议，他不是平民。

Jimmie_det
He owes allegiance to the constitution, not the president.

他效忠的是宪法，而不是总统。

ArewaGoldHouse
the president is the commander in chief

总统是三军统帅。

David White Kaweesi.
Freedom of speech becoming a crime in the first Country??

在这个头号国家里，言论自由也要变成一种罪了吗。

Nonameeejsjsjsjsxjxnzn
Betraying his country? You mean caring for his fellow comrades’ life?

背叛国家？你是说关心他战友们的生命吗。

ArewaGoldHouse
he is a soldier, this is not how he should do it, he signed for it

他是个士兵，他不该这样做，他签署过协议。

Nonameeejsjsjsjsxjxnzn
So a siolder is a just a puppet now? Suddenly they don’t have morals?

所以现在士兵只是个傀儡吗？突然之间他们就没有道德标准了。

AR55995
do it in the correct manner

用正确的方式去做。

Em (Free )
The correct manner is however you make your voice heard

正确的方式就是任何能让你发出声音的方式。

capterine
A country is just a system to maintain order. The people serves them, but a country doesn't exactly OWN them. Rather, it's the people who are in charge of the government, higher power, the bad thing about letting the people choose their own leader is that it oftens just breaks the people apart into two or more fractions, fighting what they believe is right without reasoning that doesn't include violence and harassment.

国家只是维持秩序的系统。人民为系统服务，但国家并不完全拥有他们。相反，是人民在掌管政府和更高权力。让人民选择自己领导人的坏处在于，它经常让人民分裂成两派或多派，为了各自认为正确的事而争斗，却不考虑通过非暴力和非骚扰的方式来解决。

ArewaGoldHouse
he is a soldier

他是个士兵。

Alexandra Annè
your own president is a felon he is betraying you

你们自己的总统是个重罪犯，他正在背叛你们。

Sleepless in Juland
Last time I checked our passports say United States of America… nothing about Israel on there

上次我查护照时上面写的是美利坚合众国……上面可没写以色列。

——

علی
Freedom of speech they say

他们口中的言论自由。

l_Mitchell_
You are allowed freedom of speech, but when you just yell and interrupt an event and be loud, you’re gonna be kicked out

你拥有言论自由，但当你大喊大叫、干扰活动并制造噪音时，你会被赶出去。

chan
no actually, the ones that are being sent into the wars instead of sitting behind a desk pulling the strings should be the only ones speaking.

不，实际上，那些被送上战场的人，而不是坐在桌子后面操纵局势的人，才应该是唯一有权发言的人。

Un expat Chileno
When you say things against Israel*

是指当你发表反对以色列的言论时。。。

user1874407394748
this is exactly what the 1st amendment protects you from. Republicans hate our constitution and it shows

这正是第一修正案保护你免受的侵害。共和党人讨厌我们的宪法，这已经显而易见了。

Harry Mason/Richter Belmont
so that correlates to them being allowed to break his arm why?

那这和他们被允许折断他的手臂有什么关系。

l_Mitchell_
They obviously didn’t mean to, it was a mistake

他们显然不是故意的，那是个意外。

Harry Mason/Richter Belmont
they shouldn't force him out regardless

无论如何，他们都不该强行把他赶出去。

l_Mitchell_
So what should of they done?

那他们应该怎么做。

JohnS
He is there to listen to his constituents. Why are they grabbing his entire body and breaking his hand over speaking loudly. Conservatives love to speak about freedom of speech until it’s actually defending the ability to vocalize your discontent. What you really support is a police state

他是去那里听取选民意见的。为什么要因为他大声说话就抓住他的全身并弄断他的手。保守派喜欢谈论言论自由，直到真的需要捍卫表达不满的能力。你们真正支持的是警察国家。

Dru
He’s yelling bc there’s forcibly removing him against his will

他在大喊是因为他们违背他的意愿强行带走他。


Yeah he’s speaking, but interrupting a government meeting isn’t what’s right btw

是的，他在发言，但顺便说一下，打断政府会议是不对的。

JohnS
If you’re attacked by five guards breaking your hand because of it guess what you don’t have freedom of speech. Also senators and politicians are supposed to listen to their constituents

如果你遭到五名警卫袭击并因此被弄断了手，猜怎么着，你就没有言论自由了。而且，参议员和政治家本应该听取选民的意见。


But he was resisting peace officers, which is illegal. No matter who you are why you do, you’re not above the law.

但他反抗执法人员，这是违法的。无论你是谁，无论你做什么，你都不能凌驾于法律之上。

JohnS
He spoke that’s not against the law. Please learn what the law is. He can now sue because they used extreme force. Nice to know conservatives love to see our freedom of speech not being allowed when it isn’t hurling slurs

他发言了，这并不违法。请去了解一下法律。他现在可以起诉，因为他们使用了过激武力。很高兴看到保守派在言论不涉及辱骂时，竟然乐于看到我们的言论自由被剥夺。


Freedom of speech until it’s actually something involving freedom

言论自由直到真的涉及到自由。

Linda Smith
okay

好的。

M Long
freedom of speech does not mean freedoms from consequence

言论自由并不意味着免于后果。

Walkthroughfire_
Do you have the same standards for other countries?

你对其他国家也有同样的标准吗。

JoinTheAirForceNow
He’s straight up interrupting something important

他直接打断了重要的事情。

.
Not when your talking about Israel your not

当你谈论以色列时，你就没有自由。

Mindify
I mean you have freedom of speech just not freedom after speech

我的意思是，你有言论自由，只是在言论之后没有自由。

Singleton
yes,very sad

是的，非常悲哀。

IDF
Freedom is not in your vocabulary

自由不在你的词典里。

Theresa
This one is called civil disobedience ❤️

这被称为公民不服从。

Catalan
freedom of speech is guaranteed freedom after speech?

言论自由能保证言论后的自由吗。