为什么信实工业取消了其电池制造计划？（中国终止了技术合作）

Mayur_Kanth
Simple. Indian co are traders. Not innovative. They just believe in maximizing profits.

很简单。印度公司只是贸易商，没有创新能力。他们只信奉利润最大化。


ankit_deo7
Zerodha network sponsers a lot of great yt channels

Zerodha 网络赞助了很多很棒的 YouTube 频道

mithunmahato309
These cash rich companies like Reliance, Tata all are like gocey shop owners. They just retail things sources from foreign companies. They just built business on labor cost arbitrage, product or service reseller model.

像信实、塔塔这些现金充裕的公司，都像杂货铺老板一样。他们只是零售从外国公司采购的东西。他们的商业模式完全建立在劳动力成本套利以及产品或服务转售的基础上。

Trials_By_Errors
It is really shameful that other than Ola no Indian company can build Battery Cells. And this is core technology for National security.

除了奥拉公司，印度没有任何一家企业能够生产电池，这实在是件很丢脸的事。而电池技术可是关乎国家安全的核心技术。

Bharat-stories1
Reliance invests in weddings

信实集团竟在婚礼行业进行投资。

donkeykong516
It comes down character of Chinese society, something India can’t replicate.

这归根结底是中国社会的特质，这是印度无法复制的。

saiajaygarineONE
Hard truths are revealed in this video!

这个视频揭露了一些残酷的事实！

superChat99
More funding news : Reusable rocket startup EtherealX raised $20.5 million yesterday led by TDK ventures

融资新消息：可重复使用火箭初创公司EtherealX于昨日筹集到2050万美元资金，此次融资由TDK风险投资公司牵头。

Jeez001
Reliance and Adani focus on weddings and kickbacks to the government

信实集团和阿达尼集团一心扑在婚礼行业以及向政府行贿上。

AatmaTalks07
Can anyone know how he got the lists of the startups who got funding weekly

有没有人知道他是如何获取到每周获得融资的初创企业名单的？

Quantum_Thread
It takes another 15 years and a drastic change in mindset to develop India.

印度要实现发展，还需要15年的时间，同时人们的思维模式也得发生巨大转变。

Vish4Vibe
In India Bless to you have such channels

在印度，能有这样的频道真是一种幸运。

furyfighter45
Indian manufacturing is basically "SCREWDRIVER" technology ... Dixon, HCL, Tata, Mahindra, TVS, Bajaj etc are all assemblers of CKDs

印度的制造业本质上就是“螺丝刀”技术。迪克森、印度惠普、塔塔、马恒达、TVS、巴贾吉等公司，全都是全散装件（CKD）的组装商。

Tatay-05
Looking at the situation of smart bazaar,this got me

看到智能市场如今的状况，我深受触动。

MidTownHomie
When the Chinese and the world are moving towards new battery technology, the mota bhais of India are just starting to manufacture Lithium ion batteries that too not on their own but through borrowed tech. How pathetic are our tycoons who have to always depend on their executives to put investments , when you are not well versed enough only then you have to depend on them cuz you don't know how to take risks in new ventures. Atleast the govt should penalise these fatrich lords and grant those money to young entrepreneurs who want to take risks and build newer tech

当中国乃至全球都在向新型电池技术迈进时，印度的这些大亨们才刚开始着手生产锂离子电池，而且还不是依靠自身技术，而是采用引进的技术。我们这些企业巨头实在太可悲了，他们总得依靠公司高管来进行投资决策。只有当自身能力不足、不懂如何在新领域承担风险开展业务时，才会如此依赖他人。至少政府应该对这些腰缠万贯的巨头们予以处罚，并将罚没的资金发放给那些愿意承担风险、研发新技术的年轻创业者。

GauravKumar-bt6qz
They are busy in selling सब्जी और दूध

他们正忙着卖蔬菜和牛奶呢。

Hunterr077
Good video narration

视频解说很不错。

lokeshar1513
100% truth analysis

这是完全符合事实的分析。

BankRoller369
If big corporations start spending on r&d how would they afford spending huge money on political fundings?

要是大型企业都开始在研发方面投入资金，那他们哪里还有钱用于大量的政治献金呢？

Ankit_Maurya_12
It start from root. 1. We didn't do proper India research for minerals. 2. If we found somewhere the. Corruption stopped it. 3. After all we started digging then the company couldn't book profit. 4. So no minerals so we need to export. 5. Then again no investment in R&D + corruption. 6. Then after all this our startup comes and gives only false claims and fake reports. 7. Take benefit of PLI Founder get Rich then abandoned company. (There are also other factors also involved like education, health, insurance, Civic sense and people care most importantly like China, Japan and Europe does.)

这要从根源说起。1. 我们在印度国内的矿产勘探工作做得很不到位。2. 就算在某处发现了矿产，腐败问题也会阻碍后续开发。3. 好不容易开始开采了，企业却难以盈利。4. 矿产资源匮乏，就不得不依赖进口。5. 这又导致研发投入不足，腐败问题也愈发严重。6. 在这种情况下，我们的初创企业只会发布虚假声明和不实报告。7. 他们利用生产挂钩激励计划（PLI）谋取利益，创始人赚得盆满钵满后就抛弃公司。（当然还有其他因素在起作用，比如教育、医疗、保险、公民意识等，而最重要的是，我们缺乏像中国、日本和欧洲国家那样的民生关怀。）

getmizan
Ignored the 10 minutes delivery ban news?

难道大家都忽略了十分钟配送服务被禁的消息吗？

jayeshliverpool
Why would Reliance bother for RnD. They have a line item to bribe govt to allow monopolistic practices across all their industries

信实集团又何必费力去搞研发呢？他们有专门的经费用于贿赂政府，从而得以在旗下所有行业内推行垄断经营。

TheBhumbak
India should divert the csir to research funds, because just becom marketing gimik

印度应该将印度科学与工业研究理事会（CSIR）的资金转投到科研领域，因为该机构如今不过是个营销噱头罢了。

srinivasvaranasi1645
what happened to the farradion acquisition by Reliance?

信实集团收购法拉第恩公司的事情后来怎么样了？

VMjr-c3c
so if we know the r and d problem why we are not solving it???

既然我们都清楚研发方面存在的问题，那为什么不去解决呢？

anshulsharma9424
India to India.

印度终究是印度。

Motive13524
Yes!! govt should stop freebies and spend on R&D.

没错！政府应当停止发放各种免费福利，转而将资金投入到研发领域。

durgadass5984
These company sales services but not the product. As they invest nothing in RndD

这些公司只做服务销售，不生产产品。因为他们在研发方面毫无投入。

ishaanarora9113
As long as MBAs keep overtaking startups, RnD spending will remain low.

只要工商管理硕士（MBA）们持续主导初创企业，研发投入就始终会处于较低水平。

iceberg789
they can only make money for themselves. they can make any brand new useful tech.

他们只会为自己赚钱，根本研发不出任何全新且实用的技术。

Sam-m3b5x
In India business is lixed with corruption, no real growth, just money transferring from middle class to the rich.

在印度，商业活动与腐败问题紧密相连，根本不存在真正的经济增长，不过是财富从中产阶级向富人转移罢了。

davidalmes
more than cell manufacturing the level of jobs created after jio due to internet peneteration is phenomenal. there would be no phone pe , no zepto or any ride sharing apps. every driver needs mobile data to work. so crores of new jobs and even the mobile brands like oppo and vevo should all be thankful. if no afforadable mobile data most ppl wouldnt have the need for smartphone . would have stuck with button phone like me in past so more than thr cell manufacturing the effect of jio is

相比电池生产，信实通信带来的网络普及所创造的就业岗位数量极为可观。要是没有它，就不会有PhonePe移动支付、Zepto即时配送以及各类网约车应用。每位司机工作都离不开移动数据。由此催生了上亿个新就业岗位，就连OPPO、vivo等手机品牌也都应为此表示感激。要是没有价格亲民的移动数据服务，大多数人就不会有购买智能手机的需求，可能还会像我过去那样一直使用功能机。所以，信实通信（Jio）带来的影响远比电池生产要深远得多。

noclicheplease
It is not that the Reliance cannot invest on R&D, it is just that their current capital invested on oil will go to waste & the money it keeps churning with less effort, will stop. That is why they invested in & later bought the UK based Sodium ion battery R&D company called "Faradion", only to shut it down. I'm sure that their fallout with the Chinese counterpart would have made the board members happy.

并非信实集团没有能力在研发领域投资，而是一旦涉足研发，他们目前投入石油产业的资金就可能面临损失，而且那种毫不费力就能赚得盆满钵满的日子也将一去不复返。正因如此，他们先是投资了英国的钠离子电池研发公司法拉第恩，随后又将其收购，最后却把公司关停了。我敢肯定，他们与中方合作伙伴合作破裂这件事，肯定让董事会成员们很是高兴。

ruthl2ess
Perfect sales pitch for OLA Look like biased

这简直是为奥拉公司量身打造的完美营销宣传，看起来带有偏见。

illustriSci
this people kill offline kirana shop business in india.

这些企业搞垮了印度的线下小杂货店生意。

me.arbaazkhatib
The Reliance news maybe untrue but the point of investing more in R&D is valid. There's an easy fix to this if we force corporations to invest atleast 5% in R&D by law & governments should also pledge 5% of GDP for a start.

关于信实集团的那条消息或许并非属实，但加大研发投入这一观点是合理的。要解决这个问题其实很简单，我们可以通过立法强制企业将至少5%的资金用于研发，政府也应从一开始就承诺将国内生产总值（GDP）的5%投入到研发领域。

ramireddy76
our so called corporates are BANIA and not companies. run by MBAs and business men and not technocrats.

我们所谓的企业其实都是些商贩，根本算不上真正的企业。这些企业由工商管理硕士（MBA）和商人经营，而非技术专家。

KhattaMeethaOficial
Govt Needs to Push These Big Seths To Invest In R&D otherwise don't give them Consessions

政府必须强制这些大老板们加大研发投入，否则就不给予他们任何税收减免等优惠政策。

papoa9299
what an example OLA! REALLY? hillarious

把奥拉当作正面例子？真的吗？太可笑了。

megamind599
OTT is best

网络流媒体服务（OTT）才是最佳选择。

devawratvidhate9093
Indian companies are only traders they r not intrested in innovation

印度企业都只是贸易商，对创新毫无兴趣。

Jaiswal_Ace
Reliance is just a trading organization neither a engineering company like Adani nor manufacturing like Birla and Tata.

信实集团仅仅是一家贸易机构，既不像阿达尼集团那样是工程公司，也不像贝拉集团（Birla）和塔塔集团（Tata）那样是制造企业。

Mayur_Kanth
China invests $500B on R&D. India doesnt even do $30B

中国在研发领域投入了5000亿美元，而印度的研发投入连300亿美元都达不到。

4thDeutschesReich
but india is vishwaguru and superpower, China is developing

可印度可是世界导师，是超级大国，而中国还处于发展阶段呢。

shalinijrt2120
W OLA for a reason

奥拉公司值得称赞，这是有原因的。

divyanshsingh3764
fake news alx reliance spokesperson said there is no change in plans to make lithium ion batteries threy are going to make it...fake news by bloomberg and reuters

假新闻澄清：信实集团发言人表示，其生产锂离子电池的计划并无变动，他们一定会推进该项目……彭博社和路透社发布的相关消息均为假新闻。

bosepukur
Why is reliance not buying from OLA , is there any concerns to buy internally ?

为什么信实不从奥拉购买电池，难道内部采购有什么顾虑吗？

Leavingnemo
ambani and adani are rich just because governments give them contracts. I can't recall a single useful thing they created like bill gates or elon musk did

安巴尼和阿达尼之所以富有，完全是因为政府给了他们合同。我想不起他们创造过任何像比尔·盖茨或埃隆·马斯克那样有用的东西。

bharamurayar3025
Reliance should stop investment in electoral bonds and start investing in R and D.

信实应该停止投资选举债券，开始投资研发。

rangeela.rasseul
Because Indian business houses are run by families and mostly Gujurati or Marwari or Tatas or Birlas etc. No doubt, they have helped our country to some extent, But they never stressed on Reserach and Development. If Ola could build its cell technology, why can't Reliance do it ? But these companies want instant returns..

因为印度的商业家族大多由古吉拉特人、马尔瓦里人、塔塔或贝拉等家族掌控。毫无疑问，他们在一定程度上帮助了国家，但他们从未重视过研发。如果奥拉都能掌握电池技术，为什么信实做不到？但这些公司只想要立竿见影的回报。

RajendraSingh-tu7wy
but RELIANCE had denied those news about their pause on manufacturing battery cells

但信实已经否认了那些关于他们暂停制造电池的新闻。

hsksbshsj
Ola Electric should license the cell tech to Reliance and earn royalty income.

奥拉电动汽车应该将电池技术授权给信实，以此赚取专利使用费。

Naman-Jainn
How can I invest in seed rounds of such companies. Can anyone tell.

我该如何投资这类公司的种子轮？有人能告诉我吗？

preetham4194
Reliance released the official statement stating that they will move ahead and doesn't make operations, so kindly share upxed info please having 1 million subscribers shouldn't misguide/derail them.

信实发布了官方声明，表示他们将继续推进，不会停止运营。所以请分享最新的信息，拥有100万订阅者不应误导或带偏大家。

points-perfect
India spends 0.6% on R&D and 10% is made to get corrupted by our beloved leaders. Now investors and economists have accepted that India can't beat China for coming 40-50 years.

印度在研发上的投入占比0.6%，而其中的10%还被我们敬爱的领导人贪污了。现在投资者和经济学家已经接受了印度在未来40-50年内无法击败中国的事实。

mohittrivedi1112
The leadership at Reliance utterly fails when it comes to pioneering world-leading technology, their acumen is below zero. Same goes for all other big conglomerates. Seriously sad times for our country, we have money and we're wasting it rapidly

信实的领导层在开拓世界领先技术方面彻底失败了，他们的敏锐度为零。其他所有大型企业集团也是如此。对我们国家来说，这是一个非常可悲的时代，我们有钱，却在迅速地浪费它。

tushnikdas8307
Reliance focuses on cement steel oil
Chinese company spend on Mobiles, EV, Laptop, AI

信实专注于水泥、钢铁、石油。
中国公司则投资于手机、电动汽车、笔记本电脑、人工智能。

Rockstar_london
IS this video funded by OLA ?

这个视频是奥拉赞助的吗？

tirthbhavsar8332
The biggest problem for ola electric is it's founder Bhavish Agrawal

奥拉电动汽车（Ola Electric）最大的问题在于其创始人巴维什·阿格拉瓦尔。

user10-uknown
Forget reliance no baniyas do r&d or have any tech, IT, bank businesses. Their businesses exist on Thelas and cheaper labor

别指望信实了，没有哪个巴尼亚人（印度商人群体）会搞研发或拥有任何技术、IT、银行业务。他们的生意靠的是路边摊和廉价劳动力。

nair_ashwin
Dhandho maxxers would invest in trading or some low margin cola business lMao. Even their 5g roll out in jio wasn't indegenious we have seth and darbari billionaires ffs

那些只想着赚钱的商人会去投资贸易或低利润的可乐生意，笑死。就连他们Jio的5G推出也不是本土技术，我们有的只是老板和依附权贵的亿万富翁，真是见鬼了。

cooper1819
You are correct on R&D investments but is not cause but result. Don't just look at China but also rest of Asia (Korea, Taiwan, Singapore) why their private sectors are so much more competitive, innovative and spend so much on R&D... reason is their very Open internal markets, allowing lots of foreign imports and competition. Like of Chinese EVs starts with Tesla and all other foreign car makers in China for Chinese markets from German, Japanese, Koreans, French, etc... With the many foreign companies and products, this brings Chinese consumers and workers to next levels of expectations. This is very unlike India market that for decades been among most protected domestic market. So the Indian consumers does not have "global / world class" expectations and Indian giants "need not" be too innovative and therefore why invest in R&D instead take profits / dividends. Not rocket science, just pure economics.

你关于研发投资的观点是对的，但这不是原因，而是结果。不要只看中国，还要看看亚洲其他地区（韩国、台湾（地区）、新加坡），为什么他们的私营部门更具竞争力、更具创新精神且在研发上投入巨大……原因在于他们开放的内部市场，允许大量外国进口和竞争。比如中国的电动汽车始于特斯拉和所有其他在中国市场的外国汽车制造商（来自德国、日本、韩国、法国等）……随着许多外国公司和产品的进入，这将中国消费者和工人的期望提升到了新的水平。这与印度市场截然不同，几十年来印度一直是受保护程度最高的国内市场之一。因此，印度消费者没有“全球/世界级”的期望，印度巨头“不必”太具创新性，因此为什么要投资研发而不是获取利润/股息呢？这不是火箭科学，只是纯粹的经济学。

NothingWong-d5x
Even India paytm was setup by Alibaba ant group.

就连印度的Paytm也是由阿里巴巴蚂蚁集团建立的。

kte3847
Sponsored by Ola?

是奥拉赞助的吗？

geninfo21
This is what happens when instead of several industrialist we have 5-6 oligarchs run the economy and iit engineers are engaged in making food delivery apps

当我们只有5-6个寡头在经营经济，而不是拥有众多实业家，且印度理工学院（IIT）的工程师们都在做外卖应用时，就会发生这种情况。

handleXSK
1:16 also sir , 0.6% of 3.5 trillion (approx)= 0.021 21 billion usd ( 20 % to 50 % = corruption )=
2.6% of 20 trillion or plus =0.52=520 billion usd approx .
Feeling sorry and ashamed.

1:16 另外，先生，3.5万亿美元（约）的0.6% = 0.021，即210亿美元（其中20%到50% = 腐败）=
20万亿美元或更多的2.6% = 0.52，约5200亿美元。
感到遗憾和羞愧。

Himel_Editz-T7
Do you want thumbnail Designer?

你需要缩略图设计师吗？

pranay220
Faradion is a technology acquisition, things like manufacturing equipment, battery materials are still coming from China. China is placing export restrictions on these things... they want the world to buy finished products from China and that too not the very cutting edge. They want to keep the latest technology to themselves

法拉第恩只是一项技术收购，像制造设备、电池材料等仍来自中国。中国正在对这些东西实施出口限制……他们希望世界从中国购买成品，而且还不是最尖端的成品。他们想把最新技术留给自己。

donkeykong516
Even if India had the money to spend on R&D and development, money would be gone to corruption

即使印度有钱用于研发和发展，这笔钱也会因为腐败而消失。

pushparajshambulingiah1091
Instead of giving figures of r&d spent ,in % of gdp ,it's better to give in terms of dollars spent , for issue, to sink in to sangis .

与其给出研发支出占GDP的百分比，不如给出以美元计算的支出金额，这样才能让那些桑吉（Sanghi，指印度教民族主义者）们深刻理解这个问题。

TheMichel200504
We India is a super military power that is most important let China manufacture all the stuff we India no care. Jai hind

我们印度是超级军事强国，这才是最重要的，让中国去制造所有东西吧，我们印度不在乎。印度必胜。

UdbhrantoPantha
Reliance is a scam company in India

信实在印度就是一家诈骗公司。

pocketReviews
such a sad thing for India is that people like adani and ambani are the billionaires, they never invest in India future. They just want government contracts. No research nothing. Most of them are willing to fund foreign researchers but trust their own. our government is also useless and powerless against this billionaires. Sadly india is so far behind this countries that it will never reach their even in next 30 years. Sad reality, only good option is to move out to a different country where atleast your taxes will not be used for corruption.

对印度来说，可悲的是像阿达尼和安巴尼这样的人成了亿万富翁，他们从不投资印度的未来。他们只想要政府合同。没有研究，什么都没有。他们中的大多数人愿意资助外国研究人员，却不信任自己人。我们的政府对这些亿万富翁也毫无办法。可悲的是，印度落后这些国家太远了，即使再过30年也永远赶不上。悲惨的现实是，唯一的好选择是搬到另一个国家，至少在那里你的税款不会被用于腐败。

furyfighter45
Most Indian Private companies prefer to invest in jam, pickle, potato chips and beauty products... FMCG... beyond that its almost ZERO makebin India. When Indian agriculture collapse in 20yrs... even FMCG products will be imported.

大多数印度私营公司更喜欢投资果酱、泡菜、薯片和美容产品……快速消费品（FMCG）……除此之外，印度制造几乎为零。当印度农业在20年后崩溃时……甚至连快速消费品也将依赖进口。

susobhanmete8829
Reliance are just like bada dukandars.

信实就像大杂货商一样。

RamChandran-y3b
I don't understand why you said ola company is an innovative company . That 4680 battery is also copied from tesla. And also the Shakthi , no one shows any interest in buying it .

我不明白你为什么说奥拉公司是一家创新公司。那个4680电池也是抄袭特斯拉的。还有Shakthi（可能指其电池品牌），没人有兴趣买。

7GX_FACTS
BHARAT MATA KI JAY

印度母亲万岁。

MunnaJha-e9k
Anil ambani company has totally invested in R&D . Bank to Government do not consider it , R&D is not task of one day

阿尼尔·安巴尼的公司完全投资于研发。从银行到政府都不认可这一点，研发不是一天就能完成的任务。

taurus50000
India is focused on winning elections only period!!

印度只专注于赢得选举，仅此而已！

ram1011
After five minutes, this looked more like publicity for failed & junk Ola!

看了五分钟后，这看起来更像是对失败且垃圾的奥拉的宣传！

SUMITMITRA25
Don't take the name of ola electric lol bhavish agarwal also doing same thing as reliance

别提奥拉电动汽车了，笑死，巴维什·阿格拉瓦尔也在做和信实一样的事。

InfoSoup
Indian companies run with full lala mentality, immediate profits, no RnD , no employees development. Government is no better, in so called premier institutions most of the research budget goes in hiring professors’s loved ones as RAs and buying iPhones and MacBooks for themselves using research budget, pumping out low quality research papers to prep up their profiles.

印度公司完全是“拉拉”心态（指小商贩心态，只看眼前利益），追求即时利润，没有研发，没有员工发展。政府也好不到哪去，在所谓的顶尖机构中，大部分研究预算都花在了雇佣教授的亲属作为研究助理（RA），以及用研究预算为自己购买iPhone和MacBook上，为了美化简历而大量产出低质量的研究论文。

alburaq3290
Why will anyone invest in RnD when some idiot will say AI is casteist and demand reservation in private companies?

当有些白痴说人工智能（AI）有种姓歧视并要求在私营公司保留名额时，谁还会投资研发？

HirenAhir-b5i
Real truth is Ambani is just business man

真实的事实是，安巴尼只是个商人。

furyfighter45
Indians are TRADERS... because most of todays business community were genetically traders ... they just cannot manufacture ANYTHING... even to grow crops they import western Ideas. We need to teach kids in schools 5th class onwards to create useful stuff that they can sell... making stuff with their hands... the school can sell on their behalf... in monetary benefit for the kids. Then their minds will try to create or find new things to make from which they can make money.

印度人是贸易商……因为当今的大多数商界人士天生就是贸易商……他们就是无法制造任何东西……甚至种植庄稼都要引进西方的理念。我们需要从小学五年级开始教孩子们创造有用的东西来卖……用他们的双手制作东西……学校可以代表他们出售……让孩子们获得金钱利益。这样他们的头脑就会尝试创造或寻找新的东西来制作赚钱。

adhithyaLakshman
Video is underated

视频被低估了。

quickSilverXMen
In India they want to be so capitalist making air of capitalism where consumption is 0. India needs to be follow/create own ideology of economy neither from USA nor China. Every country has it own dynamics of society, economy, natural resources, population demographic and reality of the consumption. China made their own version of capitalism/socialism/Communism then only they abled to pull it off! Not copy paste

在印度，他们想成为资本主义者，营造一种消费为零的资本主义氛围。印度需要遵循/创造自己的经济意识形态，既不是美国的也不是中国的。每个国家都有自己的社会动态、经济、自然资源、人口结构和消费现实。中国制定了自己版本的资本主义/社会主义/共产主义，然后才成功的！不是复制粘贴。

Santallo-t9s
As an Indian, I am happy where I am.

作为一个印度人，我对现状很满意。

nishantjaiswal2061
Ola sponsored content?

奥拉赞助的内容？

yongchen8204
India simply does not have the supply chain on cell batteries materials, equipments , expertises. And distribution like China does .reliance inc is not a high end manufacturing companies like byd does. It is a retail and low end manufacturing company.

印度根本没有像中国那样的电池材料、设备、专业知识和分销供应链。信实公司不是像比亚迪（BYD）那样的高端制造公司。它是一家零售和低端制造公司。

vamsikrishna24
Reliance/Adani fail when actual innovation is involved. their claim to fame and profits is always getting govt approvals (over other competitors)

当涉及到实际创新时，信实/阿达尼就失败了。他们成名和获利的法宝总是获得政府批准（优于其他竞争对手）。

vineethk133
this is why I desparetely want ola to succeed. This invest in proper R&D

这就是为什么我迫切希望奥拉能成功。这才是在适当的研发上投资。

Tanmoy-t4h9p
Bcz yeh sab dalal hain

因为这些都是中间商/掮客。

thesaint9286
Reliance is just a big kirana dukhan

信实只是一个大杂货店。

alpham9990
Thanks to congress not opening the economy in time in 90s due to license raj and bureaucracy while China established itself, everything was highly regulated and everything was nationalized combined with scams all over while China was establishing supply chains

多亏了国大党在90年代由于许可证制度和官僚主义没有及时开放经济，而当时中国正在确立自己的地位。一切都受到高度监管，一切都被国有化，加上到处都是骗局，而中国正在建立供应链。

RouFujkn-bh1tu
Adani gante ka adani

阿达尼是计时的阿达尼（意指做事拖沓或按钟点收费，讽刺语）。

sagarpoojary976
The problem with most Indian entrepreneurs is that they are not visionary. They are trend chasers and market followers. Until one or two companies don't emerge with an example that a fully researched indigenous product is successful, they will keep playing it safe and importing and assembling for other companies or repackaging products built on foreign technology.

大多数印度企业家的问题在于他们没有远见。他们是追逐潮流和市场的追随者。除非有一两家公司能树立榜样，证明完全自主研发的本土产品是成功的，否则他们会继续保持安全，为其他公司进口和组装，或者对基于外国技术的产品进行重新包装。

NothingWong-d5x
Anbani brother still owes money from China bank and he never repay any cent.

安巴尼兄弟还欠中国银行的钱，而且他一分钱都没还。

quizzzz377
Reliance is a useless company. Atleast adani takes infra projects and power projects. What ambani does is just harass newer startups. Jio Mart, Trends, petroleum, quick commerce what ambani enters is less risk sectors which are great for newer startups. Tata atleast focuses on everything. But reliance only does low risk shit. When we are thinking of reducing soft drink usage he is trying for campa. Even ambrane atleast makes power banks and cables.

信实是一家无用的公司。至少阿达尼还接基础设施项目和电力项目。安巴尼所做的只是骚扰新兴初创公司。Jio Mart、Trends、石油、即时零售，安巴尼进入的都是低风险领域，而这些领域本应是新兴初创公司的沃土。塔塔至少专注于方方面面。但信实只做低风险的垃圾生意。当我们在考虑减少软饮料使用时，他却在尝试推出Campa（一种汽水）。甚至安巴尼至少还做充电宝和数据线。

k-map224
I think you are being too harsh to indian companies in the contract electronic manufacturing sector. Chinese companies have been in this sector for more than two decades and they get huge subsidies from their government for R&D and harware is a much more matured industry with a fully developed ecosystem in China whereas in India we have started taking baby steps only a few years back into hardware manufacturing so you cannot expect companies in this space to spend on R&D unless there is support from the government and hopefully the 1lakh crore fund alloted by the government proposed for Deep tech startups helps the hardware sector in R&D in some ways

我认为你对印度的合同电子制造行业的公司太苛刻了。中国公司在这个领域已经有二十多年了，他们从政府那里获得巨额的研发补贴，而且在中国硬件是一个更加成熟的行业，拥有完全发达的生态系统，而在印度，我们几年前才刚刚开始涉足硬件制造，所以除非有政府的支持，否则你不能指望这个领域的公司在研发上花钱。希望政府为深科技初创公司划拨的1万亿卢比基金能在某种程度上帮助硬件行业的研发。

rohitvyas5865
Technology dedo vishguru desh ko

把技术给我们吧，世界导师之国（反讽）。

achekholbeck88
India businessman more interested in cheateah business

印度商人对欺诈生意更感兴趣。

tinguzz
The capex in China is controlled by ***, in india companies are answerable to shareholders and they have to increase return . Check stock market return of major markets in last 30 years. It is only india and America has given double digit return not China. That explains a lot. When we do not have descent roads and tolerable civic sense of people forget all this innovation . We are a joke, BTW we happen to be vishwa guru .

中国的资本支出由***控制，在印度，公司对股东负责，他们必须提高回报。看看过去30年主要市场的股市回报率。只有印度和美国给出了两位数的回报，而不是中国。这说明了很多问题。当我们没有像样的道路，人们没有可容忍的公民意识时，忘掉所有这些创新吧。我们就是个笑话，顺便说一句，我们恰好是“世界导师”。(***政党或名字 上下同)

vijaymalapawar7583
No one can build any type of cells without China help because all essential raw materials ie rare warth minerals mines are only present in China. India including most of the western countries, they just assemble it and not manufacture it. Everything is manufactured in China.

没有中国的帮助，没有人能制造任何类型的电池，因为所有必要的原材料，即稀土矿物矿山，只存在于中国。印度包括大多数西方国家，他们只是组装，而不是制造。一切都是中国制造的。

quickSilverXMen
So what you are expecting from these typical guj businessmen, money for R&D take a L from them. They do business in very rudimentary way with heavily traditional way of only making money. All India's start-ups air is built upon foreign fundings specially in the starting era and when they realize it getting success lil bit jumped in to make the money. India need to focus on Education, Critical thinking then R&D will happen. Otherwise we will fail this revolution like others in the past.

所以你对这些典型的古吉拉特商人还能有什么期待呢，想从他们那里拿钱搞研发是不可能的。他们做生意的方式非常初级，带着浓重的传统色彩，只想赚钱。印度所有初创企业的底气都建立在外国资金之上，特别是在起步阶段，当他们意识到能成功时，才会稍微投入一点来赚钱。印度需要关注教育、批判性思维，然后研发才会发生。否则，我们将像过去一样，在这场革命中失败。

neelofazrath
If Ambani spent money on R&D, how they can have lavish marriage ?

如果安巴尼把钱花在研发上，他们怎么能举办奢华的婚礼呢？

parasuramthampi5852
RELIANCE HAS NOT CANCELLED ITS plaNS. The company released an official statement saying so 3 days after the phayk news article by Reuters. Ignore any article that quotes unnamed sources as its origin, it's usually Phayk news.

信实没有取消计划。在路透社发布假新闻的三天后，该公司发布了官方声明这么说。忽略任何引用匿名消息来源的文章，那通常是假新闻。

abhiwins123
R&D in India is punished by government. I am now importing from China for which the company was given 1 million Yuan grant and made local Industries compulsorily but atleast 10% from Chinese companies. For 3 years, and crores of my personal money was funded and not a single government help, infact only hurdles. I cannot even show r&D expenses as r&d because of the complex regulations around it and it's implication on CC and other loans. High time blind voters realise , action not talks matters for growth

在印度，研发会受到政府的惩罚。我现在从中国进口，那家中国公司获得了100万元人民币的拨款，并强制当地工业使用，但至少10%来自中国公司。三年来，我投入了数千万卢比的个人资金，却没有得到政府的一点帮助，事实上只有障碍。由于复杂的法规及其对现金流和其他贷款的影响，我甚至不能将研发费用申报为研发。盲目的选民早就该意识到了，行动而不是空谈才是增长的关键。

samsam198011
KYA CELL KE BAAT KARE HO DHARAM SANKAT MEIN HAI

还在谈什么电池，宗教都处于危机之中了。

sleepyjoe4529
India yaps and yaps while China works hard and stays ahead

印度只会哇哇乱叫，而中国努力工作并保持领先。

Jayanthsanthosh
Private companies in China under *** rule are much batter than our Cronies....

在***统治下的中国私营公司比我们的亲信资本家要好得多……

Emphasis213
Maybe India needs to jump to another technology and stop chasing after what others are doing. China went with the battery ev route because they knew they couldn't compete with existing gasoline tech and evs were a relatively untapped technology at that time. If India can't do batteries? Do hydrogen vehicles. Can't do hydrogen ? Do something else. Also nothing wrong with assembling products. China has been doing it for decades, they learned from that and advanced.

也许印度需要跳跃到另一种技术，停止追逐别人在做的事情。中国选择电池电动汽车路线，是因为他们知道自己无法与现有的汽油技术竞争，而当时电动汽车是一个相对未被开发的技术。如果印度做不了电池？那就做氢动力汽车。做不了氢动力？那就做别的。而且组装产品也没什么错。中国已经做了几十年了，他们从中学习并取得了进步。

manivannana3317
So basically govt and its crony capitalists are not investing in R&D and this idiots online will brag about merit?

所以基本上政府及其亲信资本家不投资研发，而网上这些白痴还会吹嘘功绩/择优录取？

brahm-ahamasmi
That 0.6% on RnD goes to salaries of Babus and advertisements for Modi

那0.6%的研发资金都进了官僚的腰包和莫迪的广告费里。

rajveersanghavi5316
Not really China saw how important research is to lead the world in technology but they knew they had a huge gap but what help them is their army of cyber hunts and hacks and leaks by people working in big companies and research centre in US and Europe

并非如此，中国看到了研究对于在技术上引领世界的重要性，但他们知道自己有巨大的差距，但帮助他们的是他们的网络搜寻大军，以及在美国和欧洲大公司和研究中心工作的人员的黑客攻击和泄密。

justinterested715
I think the whole take is taking a wrong perspective. The reason Indian companies don't invest in R&D is because company cannot afford to pay a researcher fairly. There is a labor shortage in the Europe, America and China, it translates into a bigger shortage of good researchers. So you have Indian companies that have to pay them more than their executives and foreign companies who are ready to pay enormous sums. The benefits of R&D is intangible, unpredictable and unique. In India education is a formality, there are multitude of engineers but still researchers are as rare as they can be despite having the largest population.

我认为整个观点的视角是错误的。印度公司不投资研发的原因是公司无法公平地支付研究人员的工资。欧洲、美国和中国都存在劳动力短缺，这转化为优秀研究人员的更大短缺。所以印度公司必须支付比高管更高的薪水，而外国公司准备支付巨额资金。研发的好处是无形的、不可预测的和独特的。在印度，教育是一种形式，尽管拥有最多的人口，有大量的工程师，但研究人员仍然非常稀缺。

discoveryou2413
India is now in the category of sub-African countries. Need an hour, Punish Modi then India will do something!! What's Reliance ? Sell in a cheap price , that's it !! India's future is dark!! Ola , Market reputation is vanished !!

印度现在处于次非洲国家的类别。需要一个小时，惩罚莫迪，然后印度才会有所作为！信实是什么？低价出售，仅此而已！印度的未来是黑暗的！奥拉，市场声誉已经消失了！

kumar.saurabh
Indian corporates may have zero future planning, but their employee exploitation game is always on point.

印度企业可能没有任何未来规划，但他们剥削员工的手段总是很到位。

ParkerAt941
This person did not show over 3rd elementary school math education, how this type of people can understand and talk high tech field such as EV battery?

这个人表现出的数学水平不超过小学三年级，这种人怎么能理解和谈论电动汽车电池这样的高科技领域？

Jfldhr
India is current world leader in AI, industrial robotics, EV , renewable energy,automation technology, biotechnology, and making meaningful YouTube videos comparing with China

印度目前是人工智能、工业机器人、电动汽车、可再生能源、自动化技术、生物技术以及制作与中国比较的有意义YouTube视频的世界领导者。

cchayk
I understand that India is very proud of their company like China is proud of their own big companies. But the difference is all Indian companies are conglomerate where else in China no business owners are able to monopolize in every segment. This is actually very bad news.

我明白印度像中国为自己的大公司感到自豪一样，为他们的公司感到自豪。但不同之处在于，所有的印度公司都是企业集团，而在中国，没有企业主能够垄断每个细分领域。这实际上是个非常坏的消息。

kumarraj2012
Reliance to now make khakras and paapads..! Lill Ambani is always hungry.

信实现在要做薄脆饼和脆片了！小安巴尼（指安巴尼的儿子）总是很饿（意指贪得无厌）。

Mayur_Kanth
1:25 U need to give ABSOLUTE AMOUNT in $$. Then ppl will understand how far behind India is.

1:25 你需要给出以美元计的绝对金额。这样人们才会明白印度落后了多远。

jondeva
India will never progress as long as we study in English. You can`t understand physics in a foreign language, here kids learn English first and memorize science later..No country ever progressed while studding science in a foreign language..Singapore maybe an exception, coz of its location and service based economy model..

只要我们用英语学习，印度就永远不会进步。你无法用外语理解物理，在这里孩子们先学英语，然后死记硬背科学……没有哪个国家是在用外语学习科学的情况下取得进步的……新加坡可能是个例外，因为它的地理位置和服务型经济模式……