为什么大多数印度人不使用卫生纸？
Why do most Indians not use toilet paper?
译文简介
网友：我们更注重卫生，而且我们很幸运生活在一个自然资源丰富的国家，不必担心清洁所需的两三杯水
正文翻译
为什么大多数印度人不使用卫生纸？
评论翻译
很赞 ( 9 )
收藏
Sharib Zafar
·
Follow
Hardcore IndianUpvoted by
Snehasis Chakraborti
, lives in India (2005-present)upxed 6y
Originally Answered: Why most Indians don't use toilet paper?
Because our culture dates back to times when we did not have any paper to wipe (sh)it off.
因为我们的文化可以追溯到没有纸张用来擦拭的时代。
我们更注重卫生，而且我们很幸运生活在一个自然资源丰富的国家，不必担心清洁所需的两三杯水
考虑到10亿人每天使用纸张，这将是多么的浪费，砍伐数百万棵树木来擦拭我们的屁股...我们并非如此愚蠢。
修改：1000个点赞，现在让我成为了最受欢迎的厕所作者。
人惊讶的是，人们竟然想知道屁股是如何擦的。
干杯
Sadaf Zehra Rizvi
· 8y
Err I don't understand the concept of the westerners and most of the world of using TP alone and feeling absolutely OK with that.
嗯，我不太理解西方和大多数世界使用纸巾而感到完全无所谓的概念。
如果你身上有唾液甚至泥巴，你会洗手或者洗那个部位吗？或者你会只是用卫生纸擦拭一下然后继续你的日常生活吗？
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
扯犊子。忽略肛门不谈，由于排泄物在大肠中形成并附着在结肠上，因此需要进行结肠清洁/排毒/结肠治疗时。那么，你认为仅仅使用干燥的方法就能实现么吗？
现在为什么印度人使用水。与一般认为我们只是苍蝇和蚊子相反，事实上我们维持着卓越的个人卫生。我不是在谈论公共意识，那另外的事情，我们在那方面得分很低。所以，我们喜欢做到全方位的清洁。用水冲洗自己，用卫生纸擦干，然后就可以离开。说到这一点，美国职业安全与健康管理局（OSHA）应该发布普遍的指导方针，并将这变为强制性的。
我告诉你另一个（不太）有趣的事实。印度很多五星级酒店，因为它们服务于西方人（也可能因为他们感到西方人无法理解使用水的概念而感到羞愧），已经放弃了坐浴器或水龙头的概念，这是一种非常不方便且愚蠢的做法。
对于在公共厕所使用卫生纸的概念，我仍然可以理解。减少了一些麻烦。但是拜托，一想到你可能走在大街上时身上某个部位可能还残留着粪便，这真是让人感到难受。
还有一个非常重要且令人难以接受的事情。对于女性，尤其是在月经期间，我真不明白她们怎么只用卫生纸就能应付。真是太恶心了。
Umang Jain
· 8y
You should post this as an answer.
您应该将其作为答案发布。
Suresh Balakrishnan
· 8y
never ever understood how the same 5 star will have a 'hand shower' through out the middle east but not in India...personally avoid those 5 stars which dont have a proper washing facility..
我从来都不明白为什么同一家五星级酒店在中东地区到处都有"手持花洒"，而在印度却没有。个人而言，我会避免那些没有适当洗涤设施的五星级酒店。
Profile photo for Sadaf Zehra Rizvi
Sadaf Zehra Rizvi
· 8y
Completely. Totally agree. So being classy and upmarket is not to clean urself properly? Thank you I'll pass , I'm better off being down market , uncouth and vernacular but clean.
完全同意。所以，高档和上档次不等于不能正确清洁自己？谢谢，我会放弃，我宁愿保持低调、粗俗和朴实，但是干净。
Profile photo for Anshul Dalal
Anshul Dalal
· 7y
Maybe the cold climate in the western countries made them choose paper over water
也许是西方国家寒冷的气候使他们选择了纸而不是水
Sanniv Bhaduri
· 7y
Post this as an answer!
发布此作为答案！
Nikhil Bhardwaj Balaji
· 7y
Currently, I live in the US and a few months back it was unthinkably disgusting for me as an Indian to wipe shit off my ass with paper after pooping. But later after coming here, I understood the logic behind them using toilet paper. Try to look at things from their point of view. In most of the western countries it gets bitterly cold during the peak of winter with sub zero temperatures and the water in the pipes either freezes or becomes ice cold, making it unfit for washing purposes. And that’s how the tradition of using paper for you know what started. And they don’t move around with stinking, unclean asses either as we may like to think! They shower properly and give their asses a good wash while bathing. In our country water has never been a problem and moreover, winters aren’t as cold as found in the West. And just as you have an issue with them wiping their asses with paper, they also find using our hands to wash the shit off our asses utterly gross (though we wash our hands with soap properly afterwards before eating or doing something else).
目前，我住在美国，几个月前，作为印度人，用纸擦屁股是令人难以想象的恶心事情。但后来来到这里，我理解了他们使用卫生纸的逻辑。试着从他们的角度看待问题。在大多数西方国家，冬季高峰期气温骤降，达到零下，水管中的水要么结冰，要么变得非常冰冷，使其不适合清洗。这就是使用卫生纸的传统开始的原因。而且他们并不像我们想象的那样走在身上有臭味、不干净的屁股。他们洗澡时会彻底淋浴，好好清洗屁股。在我们国家，水从未是问题，而且冬季的寒冷程度也不如西方国家那么严重。就像你对他们用纸擦屁股有意见一样，他们也觉得我们用手清洗屁股非常恶心（尽管我们在吃饭或做其他事情之前会用肥皂彻底洗手）。
Farhad Tarapore
· 7y
They obviously have heated water I think. Either that or it’s so cold that even the (sh)it would come out as frozen powder.
他们显然有加热的水，我认为。要么是这样，要么是天气太冷，甚至（屎）也会变成冻粉。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
Profile photo for Nikhil Bhardwaj Balaji
Nikhil Bhardwaj Balaji
· 7y
That’s some good sarcasm! LOL :D
这是一个很好的讽刺！LOL:D
Tintu Praveen
· 8y
Yuk!!! Wiping your shit with paper... Can't imagine doing it
噫！用纸擦屁股…无法想象会这样做。
Profile photo for Raj Kumar Chauhan
Raj Kumar Chauhan
· 7y
and they feel same for us also :p
他们对我们来说也一样:p
Tintu Praveen
· 7y
Simple logic...you spill some juice on the table let's say Pepsi...if you wipe it with a paper you think the table won't be sticky???
简单的逻辑……你在桌子上溅了点果汁，比如百事可乐……如果你用纸擦，你认为桌子不会粘吗？
Suresh Venkat
· 8y
Very cold countries Water turns to Ice and so they use Toilet Paper. India Temperature are above 15 degrees even during Winter at most places so why not use water? We have to reduce cutting of Trees to make Paper.
在非常寒冷的国家，水会变成冰，所以他们使用卫生纸。印度大多数地方即使在冬季温度也在15摄氏度以上，为什么不使用水呢？我们要减少砍伐树木以生产纸张。
Sohil Mehta
· 7y
Your answer makes sense. But the answer you've connected on is nonsense.
你的回答很有道理。但你所引用的回答确实没有意义。
SOP
· 6y
as water freezes, they shouldn't be even drinking water, But they do! Hence frozen water can in no way be the reason for Europeans and Americans proudly maintaining dirty and stinky rear end!
当水结冰时，他们甚至不应该喝水，但他们确实喝了！因此，冰冻的水绝不能成为欧洲人和美国人自豪地保持肮脏和臭气熏天的后端的理由！
Vijayan Odukkathil
· 7y
The temperature is the exact reason. The habit has nothing to do with trees!
温度正是原因。这个习惯与树木无关！
Paul Dsouza
· 6y
WE DONT USE TOILET PAPER BECAUSE WE HAVE COUNTLESS IDOLS TO APPROACH AND TO BEG. OUR CULTURE BECAME LIKE AGRICULTURE. WE ARE GOOD IN ONLY CLEANING OUR ASS SHIT BUT NOT CLEAN OUR HEART. ALSO IT IS OUR CHARACTER TO JEALOUS ON OTHERS PROGRESS. ONE DROP OF WATER IS MORE PRECIOUS THAN THE PAPER. SAVE WATER AND USE PAPER TO CLEAN SHIT. THIS POLICY SUITS CURRENT GOVERNMENT. FEEDING NOTHING BUT PROMOTING TO MAKE TOILETS (souchalaya). SINCE YOU HAVE NOTHING IN STOMACH… FROM WHERE PEOPLE SHIT. THAT PROJECT TOO FAIL. THAT PROJECT TOO FAIL. DO…WHATEVER YOU WANT YODO MAN…!!! ENJOY SHITTING.
我们不使用卫生纸是因为我们有无数的偶像可以供奉和祈求。我们的文化变得像农业一样。我们只擅长清理屁股，而不擅长净化心灵。而且我们的性格是嫉妒他人的进步。一滴水比纸更宝贵。节约水资源，使用纸张来清理粪便。这一政策适用于当前的政府。只是提倡建造厕所而不提倡解决饥饿问题。因为你们肚子里什么都没有，只有推动建造卫生设施（souchalaya）的宣传。然而，由于没有人的胃里有东西，那个项目也失败了。那个项目也失败了。做吧，尽管你想做的吧，YOLO ！尽情享受排泄吧。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
A person with good heart wouldn’t have this shit!
一个善良的人是不会说这样的话的！
Raja Povaiah
· 8y
We HAD abundant natural water resources. Now with the corrupt politicians looting the timber reserves and hoarding money, the water sources are drying up and desertification is fast spreading. Soon we will not have water or paper and perhaps will have to use dry sand for wiping.
我们曾经拥有丰富的自然水资源。但现在由于腐败的政治家掠夺木材储备和贪污钱财，水源正在枯竭，荒漠化正在迅速蔓延。很快我们可能既没有水也没有纸，也许不得不用干燥的沙子擦拭。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
Vinayak Sharma
· 7y
I think there is abundant of water for wiping purpose ..we can even use sea water for that purpose .. the scarcity you are talking about is of drinking water ..
我认为擦拭的目的有足够的水资源，我们甚至可以使用海水。你所说的稀缺是指饮用水。
Abhishek Yadav
· 6y
Yes but sea water have to be supplied to toilets in some way. And that would lead to incrustation of pipes. Cause of high salt content.
是的，但是海水必须以某种方式供应到厕所。这会导致管道结垢，因为海水含有高盐分。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
Sadaf Zehra Rizvi
· 8y
Actually a valid question. Will be. How can the rest are f the world use only toilet paper , douse themselves with cologne and be judgemental or confused about using water?
这确实是一个合理的问题。其余的世界是如何仅使用卫生纸、用古龙水洒洒自己，并对使用水感到疑惑或判断的呢？
Profile photo for Ranjit V Srivatsaa
Ranjit V Srivatsaa
· 8y
The West has finally discovered how Indian commodes are better for the health! The Stanford modified Indian style is only half as effective as the original, but using Indian style commode one will hardly get arthritis in old age. I have witnessed >95 year olds feeling at ease only with Indian style, they simply hate the Western style.
西方最终发现了印度式马桶对健康更有益！斯坦福大学改良的印度式马桶只有原始设计的一半效果，但使用印度式马桶，人在老年时几乎不容易得关节炎。我亲眼见过95岁以上的老人只有用印度式马桶时感到轻松，他们对西式马桶简直是厌恶。
Pradip Shah
· 8y
I visited a factory in Italy to buy some photo processing machinery. I was surprised to see only Indian style toilets for the workers on the shop floor.
我曾经去意大利参观一家工厂，想购买一些照片处理的机器。让我感到惊讶的是，在厂房的工人区域只有印度式的厕所。
Saiprasad Mahendra Pashupulate
· 7y
I had a tough time in the US without any washing facility in the toilet. Developed a rash in the backside.
在美国没有洗涤设施的厕所让我感到很困扰。我在屁股上长了一片红疹。
Anshul - I am Batman (jk)
· 7y
You just needed a bottle of water in your toilet. I figured that out after day 1.
It works when there is no toilet shower or mug.
你只需要在厕所放一瓶水。我在第一天后就明白了这一点。在没有马桶淋浴或水杯的情况下，这很有效。