印度教育系统的阴暗面，为什么学校辜负了你?
Dark Side Of Indian Education System Why School Failed You ?
译文简介
印度的教育体系经常受到批评，因为它在过去70年里没有改变。2020年，印度政府宣布了NEP(新教育政策)，根据该政策，政府计划给印度教育体系带来相当大的变化。印度的教育系统正在使孩子们在智力上破产，因为我们的教育系统已经产生了恶性竞争，这是一个严重的问题。
正文翻译
The Indian education system is often criticised because it hasn't changed in the past 70 years. In 2020 the government of India announced NEP ( New Education Policy) under which the government plans to bring considerable changes to the Indian education system. The Indian education system is currently making the children intellectually bankrupt and because our education system has given birth to cut-throat unhealthy competition, this is a serious concern. The unhealthy competition in the Indian education system has resulted in depression among students, serious anxiety issues, social pressure and much more as a result of which many students commit suicide. A lot of students end their lives because of the pressure built by the Indian education system. This video talks about the Dark Side of the Indian education system, the video highlights several points which make it clear how poorly our education system is run, what changes should we bring and most importantly how one can focus on their skills to earn money rather than just depending on a piece of paper or degree to make money in their lives. Earning money today has nothing to do with a college degree but has everything to do with the skills that help one make money. The video highlights the dark side of the education system, the issues revolving around our education system and the remedies that people can take at individual levels to fightback the Indian education system and earn money.
印度的教育体系经常受到批评，因为它在过去70年里没有改变。2020年，印度政府宣布了NEP(新教育政策)，根据该政策，政府计划给印度教育体系带来相当大的变化。印度的教育系统正在使孩子们在智力上破产，因为我们的教育系统已经产生了恶性竞争，这是一个严重的问题。印度教育系统中的这种不健康竞争导致了学生的抑郁，严重的焦虑问题，社会压力，以及更多问题，很多学生因此而自杀。很多学生因为印度教育体系的压力而结束了自己的生命。这段视频讲的是印度教育系统的阴暗面，并且强调了几点，清楚地表明我们的教育体系运行得多么糟糕，我们应该带来什么样的改变，最重要的是人们应该如何专注于自己的技能来赚钱，而不是一辈子仅仅依靠一张纸或学位来赚钱。如今，挣钱与大学学历无关，而与赚钱的技能息息相关。这段视频突出了这个教育系统的阴暗面，围绕着我们的教育系统的问题，以及人们在个人层面上可以采取的补救措施，以反击印度的教育系统，并赚钱。
评论翻译
很赞 ( 0 )
收藏
My parents used to compare me with other children for their knowledge and skills, so I started comparing them with those parents who allowed their kids to do such out-of-the-box things.
Now they have stopped comparing.
我的父母过去常常拿我的知识和技能和其他孩子进行比较，所以我开始把他们和那些允许自己的孩子做些出格事情的父母进行比较。
现在他们不比较了。
Hahahah badass
哈哈哈，牛逼。
Even I do the same
我也这么搞。
Bruhh I compare my parents with their friends who r earning more than them... The solution is right here
噗，我把我的父母跟他们那些挣钱更多的朋友做比较……这不就结了嘛。
@ASHWIN KASHYAP even better solution, thanks for the idea! I'll try that
@ASHWIN KASHYAP 这个办法更好，感谢！我会试试。
which is 50% true and let's be honest majority of people watching this video are avg 12-16 y'o kids who blame the whole world rather than reflecting upon themselves that watching Netflix, eating junk food, playing video games, scrolling on your phone IS your mistake not the education system learn to discipline your self before blaming the situations
有50%是对的，说实话，大多数看这个视频的人平均12-16岁，他们责怪整个世界，而不是反思自己，看Netflix，吃垃圾食品，玩电子游戏，刷手机，这是你自己的错，而不是教育系统的错，在责备环境之前学会约束自己。
@Moon knight true brother blaming the situation is never right but lets be honest the kids may blame the system as an excuse but that excuse is just the sad reality
@Moon knight 确实，兄弟，指责这种状况从来不是正确的做法，但我们要诚实，孩子们或许把指责制度作为借口，但可惜这个借口完全是事实。
“The function of education is to teach one to think intensively and to think critically. Intelligence plus character , that is the goal of true education” – Martin Luther King
“教育的功能是教会一个人仔细思考和批判性思考。智力加性格，这是教育的真正目标。”——马丁·路德·金
Indian education system help with neither of these
印度的教育系统对这二者都没有帮助。
@??Akshat kalantry?? I too agree with u.
@??Akshat kalantry?? 我也同意你的看法。
Yeah My son
是啊，对对对。
They don't want to this happen because if this I'll happen then you'll forget your Relegion and culture and you'll start live like a standard life which requires western culture ??
他们不希望这种事情发生，因为如果这样，那么你就会忘记你的宗教和文化，开始过上标准的生活，而那需要西方文化。
"The function of the indian education system is to make students learn math formulas and get a degree"
“印度教育系统的功能就是让学生学习数学公式，然后拿到学位。”
Going to college just to maintain 75% attendance is a universal constant in India
上大学只是为了保持75%的出勤率，这在印度是一个普遍的常态。
unless someone is from BITS or dtu., my friend is doing btech and they have to maintain 90% attendance to get internal marks.
但BTS（博拉理工学院）或者DTU（德里科技大学）除外，我的朋友在学技术学士，必须维持90%的出勤率，才能拿到内部学分。
Beleive me or not I had 100% attendence :D. As i use to feel relief at college than at home.
信不信由你，我的出勤率是100%。我好像觉得在大学比在家里感到轻松。
@Anonymous 1 sometimes conditions make you suffer more at home than outside. Sending hope
@Anonymous 1 有时的情况会让你在家里比在外面更难受。祝你好运。
Few years ago I also tried suicide after fail in JEE exam ....I was in serious depression... something must be done ...I appreciate new education policy... It will make education less burden....I am from KOTA .....you are absolutely right
几年前，我在JEE考试失败后也试图自杀……我当时严重抑郁……必须采取措施……我很欣赏新的教育政策……这将减轻教育负担……我来自KOTA.....你说的完全正确。
I hope you make it out well, I am suffering from depression too
我希望你能好起来，我也患有抑郁症。
@Burning Hamon bro, get a break im telling you.... i was in depression when i was in 10. my school just started... first unit test, i failed in one subject... i was insanely depressed... then i began to study too much to get good scores i was forcing my brain even though i didnt wanted to study... but then i realised... nothings gonna work until we take frequent breaks and make ourselves realise... that life is all about falling im rising ?
@Burning Hamon 兄弟，休息一下吧，我告诉你……我10岁的时候就抑郁了。我的学校刚开学……第一个单元测试，我有一门科目不及格……我极度沮丧……然后我开始为了取得好成绩过度学习，即使我不想学习，我也强迫我的大脑……但后来我意识到……除非我们经常休息，让自己意识到……生活就是起起伏伏。
@Burning Hamon honestly telling play games, its stupid but believe me, its a great mind diverter
@Burning Hamon 但老实说，玩游戏是愚蠢的做法，相信我，它很容易让人分心。
@Burning Hamon don't think too much our education system is like basically judging all animals by the ability of swimming.... stay happy brother!
@Burning Hamon 不要想太多，我们的教育系统基本上是通过游泳的能力来判断所有动物……保持快乐，兄弟!
And the worst of all in the system :-
1. You need to worthless study physics to become a doctor.
2. You need to worthless study Physics & Chemistry to become a software engineer.
If Any one is disagree with the video, please answer me *Why ?* for the following point ??
而且它是所有系统中最糟糕的：
1. 要成为一名医生，你必须毫无价值的学习物理。
2. 要成为一名软件工程师，你需要毫无价值的学习物理和化学。
如果有人不同意这个视频，请回答我“为什么?”
Just curious...but don't we need maths for programming/coding
只是好奇……但我们不是需要学数学才能编程吗？
@phoenix Short answer : No
Big answer : Yes.
In general, we don't need high level math for coding. Just a little math only for logic is needed. If we specialise further in CS , you will need basic physics if you go to game development and Nice math (Statistics part) for data science or machine learning. There is no need for specific Math for software development.
@phoenix 简单回答：不需要。
大话的回答：需要。
一般来说，编程不需要高级数学。只需要一点逻辑数学。如果专攻CS，如果从事游戏开发，就需要基础物理，如果从事数据科学或机器学习，就需要精通数学(统计学部分)。软件开发不需要特定的数学。
@Andro developer thanks brother/sister....sorry for asking too many questions, but do I need to know advanced level maths to learn cybersecurity.
@Andro developer 谢谢兄弟/姐妹……很抱歉问了这么多问题，但是学习网络安全需要懂高等数学吗?
@phoenix it's okey, you can ask as many questions as you wish.
Nope , none of the math is needed for cyber security.
@phoenix 没关系，你想问多少问题都可以。
不，网络安全不需要数学。
Does physics help in radiology or biotech branch?
物理对放射学或生物技术有帮助吗?
Physics is imp subject to become doctor it test ur mental ability ...and reasoning ... which very needed and also during mbbs study there are lot of subject which related indirectly with pysics...
物理学是成为医生的重要科目，它可以考验你的智力……和推理能力……这是非常需要的，而且在MBBS的学习过程中，有很多科目是与物理间接相关……
原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
Guys tell me the truth, how many of yall have been Out of stress during covid times because of no school? ??
I literally learnt more knowledgeable things during lockdown and when the school was online than I did in school plus it was such a stress free time..!
Imagine a country with such an education system in which kids pray to god for covid to increase and schools to get online...
伙计们，请告诉我真相，你们中有多少人在疫情期间因为没有上学而感到压力??？
在封锁期间和线上授课期间，我学到了比在学校时更多的知识，而且这是一段没有压力的时期。
想象一下，我们国家的教育制度是这样的，孩子们向上帝祈祷，希望疫情扩大，网上上课……
I learned basic Java and C++ during the lockdown period
我在封锁期间学会了基础Java和C++。
True bit schools have now opened for me and its all stress and nothing else
确实，现在又开始上学了，全是压力，别无其他。
Off course it was great time for students mental stability,peaceful life thi tab....aisi jindagi 1st time mil rahi thi...... thanks to God....studies to tab bhi thi but peaceful study without pressure ....i want it again....but ??
当然，封锁期间对学生的心理稳定来说是一段好时光，感谢上帝，学生们可以没有压力的平和学习……我希望再来一次……但是……
I wanted to be same but my physics was too weak so I dropped the idea of becoming Astronaut
我也想成为宇航员，但我的物理太差了，所以我放弃了成为宇航员的想法。
I want to become an economist but DU needs maths till 12th standard and My maths is the weakest although other subjects are good
This is what they are doing to me.
我想成为一名经济学家，但是它需要12级的数学，我的数学是最差的，尽管其他科目都很好。
这就是他们对我做的事。
All Are Mentioning The Problems And Nobody Trying To Make A Change
所有人都在谈论问题，没有人试图做出改变。
原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
My Goal Was To Be A Quantum Physicist By Seeing Our Education System And I Dropped My Goal And Sorted My Goal As Changing our Education ?? System
我的目标是成为一名量子物理学家，通过观察我们的教育体系，我放弃了我的目标，把我的目标列为改变我们的教育系统。
@Surya Jayanth I am with you ??
@Surya Jayanth 我资瓷你。
@Tanish Salunke Channel Thanks Bro I Need Your Help But I'll Reach You When I Need
@Tanish Salunke Channel 谢谢，兄弟，我需要你的帮助，但我会在我需要的时候联系你。
7:46 a harsh reality , but the problem is 90% parents will not watch these things and 10% will think, he is wrong.
If any parent reading comment please try to implement it.
7:46说了一个残酷的现实，但问题是90%的父母不会看到这些事情，10%会认为他错了。
如果任何家长正在阅读评论，请尝试执行它。
Education Minister needs to watch this
教育部长需要看看这个视频。
Our main motive of India education system is to complete the syllabus ??
我们印度教育制度的主要动机是完成教学大纲。
Rote learning is the main motive
I heard this statement in one school,"ratafication is the best fication for examination"
死记硬背是主要的动机。
我在一所学校听到过这样的说法:“死记硬背是考试的最佳办法。”
I agree with every point in this video 1000%. I have been raising these issues for the past 3 decades.
我完全同意这个视频中的每一点。过去30年来，我一直在提出这些问题。
原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
30年前(当时我在上9年级，大约14岁)，我曾经问过我的老师、父母和长辈，通过学习莎士比亚、萧伯纳、泰戈尔、钱德拉、萨拉特等人的戏剧、诗歌和散文，我们的生活能达到什么目的? 每个人都让我闭嘴，通常的回答是:“你是个孩子，叫你做什么就做什么，不要问愚蠢的问题。这个加入教学大纲肯定是有目的的。”
作为一个过去23年一直从事教育的人，当来自商业背景的学生问我“学习三角和微积分的目的是什么”，或者科学专业学生在上经济学课时问我“对他们来说学习经济学有什么目的”，或者两个人都问我30年前所提的问题，我会直接对他们说：“这是为了让我们这样的老师受益，这样我们就能从对你们的精神折磨中获得报酬，浪费你们的时间，阻止你们做任何有意义和有趣的事情，确保给那些擅长阅读大量欧洲文学的人创造就业机会，通过研究他们留给我们的东西来满足我们昔日的殖民统治者，让他们相信我们仍然是他们忠诚的狗，让国家机器在不久的将来创造更多的奴隶，等等”。
没有一个当权者有这种头脑去清理我们教育体系中的混乱。我承认我是这个犯罪集团的一员。.
I feel this is a well made video. Even if we talk about developed countries like the USA, there are many people who don't like school/college or say the system itself. They prefer doing their own business or follow their passion. No system is flawless but ours is very far from being flawless so it is okay to blame but we cannot change it. What we can do in the meantime is teach ourselves various skills that will actually bring happiness and joy in the long run.
我觉得这是一个很好的视频。即使说起美国这样的发达国家，也有很多人不喜欢学校/大学，或者教育系统本身。他们更喜欢自己创业或追随自己的激情。任何制度都不是完美的，但我们的制度远非完美，所以指责是可以的，但我们无法改变它。与此同时，我们能做的是教会自己各种技能，从长远来看，这些技能实际上会带来幸福和快乐。