《流浪地球》IMDB影评：有惊喜但也不乏俗套，较真吐槽，善意期待中国更多科幻电影

6/10
The main characters suck.

主角很烂。

jasonshuhezhang11 February 2019
Warning: Spoilers
I'm just going to be blunt here: The main characters suck. The main protagonists, a brother and a sister, are depthless and one dimensional. The sister literally spends 90% of her lines crying or shouting for someone to save her. The brother is arrogant and apparently a "genius", yet seems to have no redeeming qualities. Overall, the story and CGI are decent,
409 out of 503 found this helpful.

剧透警告
我准备在这里直言不讳：主角很烂。主人公这两兄妹是肤浅且扁平化。妹妹简直是用90%的台词来哭着喊着让别人来救她。哥哥傲慢且貌似是一个“天才”，然而看着没有任何可取的品质。
总得来说，这个故事和CG特效是不错的，但是人物形象还有很大的进步空间。

5/10
Incredible effects, unlikable characters, confusing story line

不可思议的特效，不受喜欢的角色，令人困惑的故事情节。

kmsmith-613538 February 2019
Went in with big expectations as a fan of Liu Cixin's Three Body Problem. Have not read Wandering Earth, so can't compare, but perhaps reading it would have made the movie easier to follow. Outside of Wu Jing, the main characters in general were hard to like, especially his son Liu Qi and adopted daughter, Duoduo, both acting like petulant children. Expected high levels of cheesiness, but the jokes fell flat and the emotional tear jerking scenes were milked dry. While you should go into a sci-fi with an open-mind, temporarily suspending reality, this had hole after hole and jumped all over the place. At one point, one of the special force team members suddenly fell on his face - he froze to death for no apparent reason. Kind of summed up the movie. While I am sure the novel is as unique as anything Liu Cixin has written, the movie is a lesser version of Armegeddon, lacking the fun, character building (I know, I am talking about a Michael Bay movie) and star power. Did enjoy seeing a Chinese perspective and wasn't overly nationalistic like Wu Jing's former Wolf Warrior. Living in Shanghai, was also fun seeing the city and the rest of the country highlighted as it fell beneath natural disasters, joining NYC, Paris, London and the rest of the major cities that regularly are destroyed for popcorn munching sake. China continues to head in the right direction when it comes to great movie making and hope it continues. If anything, this has me heading out tomorrow to buy Wandering Earth, the novel.
216 out of 286 found this helpful.

作为刘慈欣的《三体》的粉丝，我带着极大的期待进影院。没有读过《流浪地球》，所以无法比较，但也许读过它会更容易理解这部电影。除了吴京，多数主要人物都很难让人喜欢，尤其是他的儿子刘启和养女朵朵，两人都表现得像爱耍性子的孩子。预计到会非常俗套，但没想到包袱全都没抖响，还在绞劲脑汁地展现煽情催泪的场面。虽然你应该以开放的心态去看科幻电影，暂时搁置现实，但整部电影都接二连三地出现漏洞。有一幕，一名特种部队队员突然摔倒在地——他无缘无故地冻死了。这就像是电影的总结。
虽然我相信这部小说和刘慈欣写的任何一部小说一样独特，但这部电影就是《绝世天劫》的翻版，缺乏趣味、性格塑造（我知道我说的是迈克尔·贝的电影）和明星魅力。我喜欢看到中国人的视角，而不是吴京上一部《战狼》那样过于的民族主义。作为生活在上海的人，看到这座城市和这个国家的其他地方与纽约、巴黎、伦敦和其他经常因吃爆米花而被摧毁的主要城市一样因为遭受自然灾害被万众瞩目，也感到非常有趣。在制作伟大的电影方面，中国持续地朝着正确的方向前进，我希望希望它能继续下去。如果要说看完这部电影有什么改变我的东西，那就是我明天要去买《流浪地球》这本小说。

3/10
Overly ambitious, laughably implausible, clumsily edited mess

过于野心勃勃，难以置信的可笑，剪辑拙劣的烂摊子

Suave-428 February 2019
The Wandering Earth is an overly ambitious, laughably implausible, thoroughly confusing, clumsily edited mess. The plot runs amok with too many hollow characters making stupid decisions without reason. Action sequences were so badly shot and edited it was hard to figure out what was going on. The CGI varied from passable to worse than a 90's video game. Acting was stilted and expressionless. Dialog was rambling and inefficient with an overuse of weird computer voices to explain what was going on. By the end I couldn't care less about the characters and fell sleep. The filmmaker's intention to build a sci-fi epic were noble but lacked the budget, talent and experience to pull it off. 3/10.
208 out of 289 found this helpful.

《流浪地球》是一部过于野心勃勃、荒谬可笑、非常迷惑、剪辑拙劣的烂片。这部电影情节混乱，无数空洞的角色无缘无故做出愚蠢的决定。动作镜头的拍摄和剪辑非常糟糕，很难弄清楚到底发生了什么。CG特效有的还可以的，也有的比90年代的电子游戏更差。表演生硬且呆板。对话杂乱无章，信息表达低效，过度使用奇怪的计算机声音来解释发生了什么。到最后，我完全不关心剧中的角色并且睡着了。这位电影人制作科幻史诗的意图是伟大的，但缺乏预算、天赋和经验来完成。3/10.

3/10
Absurd fantasy nonsense

荒谬的幻想

NurgleTheUnclean30 April 2019
Moving earth like a space ship is so dumb! 1) An asteroid that hits the earth and kills all the dinosaurs, didn't budge the earth from it's orbit. 2) The moon creation even that suggests that 4.5b years ago an obxt the size of Mars collided with the earth to create the moon. Yet it didn't budge the earth from it's orbit around the Sun. 3) The Mass of the earth is 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 kg. the force required to move that obxt 1meter per second is Force = Mass * Acceleration. or 6 * 10^24 newtons. So to change the speed of the earth by a nearly useless 1m/s or 2.25 MPH, would require the energy of 142 million megatons of TNT. Over 10,000 times the total amount of all the worlds nuclear weapons. Or in other words if we detonated every single nuke in the world in the same place at the time that would be enough to budge the earth .000225 MPH or 14 inches per hour. 4) Even if there was an energy source that abundant to move the earth to Jupiter much less another star light years away, we would simply not need a star at all. We could just set the earth to a further orbit from the sun, and use all that propulsion energy to substitute for the sun. 5) Lets be ridiculously generous and say the earth could reach Jupiter in 1 year 365,000,000 miles away, that would very roughly equate to a speed of 41,000 mph (which is way faster than the 14" per hour all the nukes in the world could move the earth). To travel to our next nearest star (alpha centauri) is 25 trillion miles away, that would take 70,000 years, or if we used the 14" per hour speed it would take 17,580 billion earth years. 6) The Hiroshima nuclear blast was 20ktons of TNT. So imagine what 700,000 of those would do to the surface and atmosphere of the Earth. And that's to move 14" an hour.
351 out of 513 found this helpful.

像宇宙飞船一样移动地球太愚蠢了！
1）一颗撞击地球并杀死所有恐龙的小行星没有使地球偏离轨道。
2）月球的形成甚至表明，45亿年前，一个火星大小的物体与地球相撞，形成了月球。然而，它并没有改变地球绕太阳运行的轨道。
3）地球的质量是6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000公斤。每秒移动地球一米所需的力是：力=质量*加速度，6*10^24牛顿。因此，要将地球的速度改变几乎毫无用处的1米/秒或2.25英里/小时，需要1.42亿吨TNT的能量。这是全世界核武器总量的1万多倍。或者换句话说，如果我们在同一时间在同一地点引爆世界上的每一枚核弹，足以使地球以每小时0.000225英里或每小时14英寸的速度移动。
4）如果有足够的能量将地球移动到木星甚至距离我们几光年远的另一颗恒星，我们也根本不需要恒星。我们可以把地球置于离太阳更远的轨道上，用所有的推进能量来代替太阳。
5）让我们荒唐地大方地决定，地球要在1年内到达365000000英里以外的木星，那这大致相当于41000英里/小时的速度（比世界上所有核武器可以移动地球的每小时14英寸要快得多），而要到达的距离我们最近的恒星（半人马座阿尔法星）在25万亿英里远的地方，需要70000年，如果我们使用每小时14英寸的速度，需要175800亿地球年。
6）广岛核爆炸相当于2万吨TNT。想象一下，70万个这样的核导弹会对地球表面和大气层造成什么影响。而且这也仅仅就是每小时移动14英寸。

7/10
Devoid of realism, but still rather enjoyable...

没有现实主义，但仍然很有趣……

paul_haakonsen1 August 2020
I finally had the chance to sit down and watch the 2019 Chinese movie "The Wandering Earth" (aka "Liu lang di qui") here in 2020. I had heard about the movie, of course, but just never gotten around to actively sitting down to watch it.
So was the wait worth it? Oh yeah. This movie was definitely an epic Chinese production, and the movie was very enjoyable. Sure, you need to fully forget everything about realism, science and probability. This was without a doubt a very entertaining and enjoyable sci-fi adventure, but there was not an ounce of realism in the movie. But hey, hence the purpose of being a movie meant for entertainment and not enlightenment of facts.
I was really surprised with the epic feel that there was to this movie. This easily outdid a lot of Hollywood produced movies. And I was really enjoying the CGI, the props, the sets, the costumes, etc. While the movie failed to have a single ounce of realism in it, it more than made up for that in terms of visuals and pure eye candy.
The storyline was fully and wholeheartedly unrealistic, but it was entertaining. "The Wandering Earth" is a very, very predictable movie, and you knew exactly what would happen a long time before it transpired on the screen. But this overly predictable formula really wasn't a hindrance to the movie.
"The Wandering Earth" also had a good ensemble of casted actors and actresses, whom portrayed their respective characters quite well. And that definitely also contributed a great deal to the overall enjoyment of the movie.
All in all, "The Wandering Earth" was an all-round pleasing movie, and I was more than entertained with it. I am rating it a seven out of ten stars.
10 out of 11 found this helpful.

2020年，我终于有机会在这里坐下来观看2019年的中国电影《流浪地球》。当然，我听说过这部电影，但还没有主动坐下来看过。
那么等待是否值得呢？是的。这部电影绝对是一部史诗般的中国作品，而且让人非常愉快。当然，你需要完全忘记关于现实主义、科学和概率的一切。毫无疑问，这是一次非常有趣的科幻冒险，但电影中没有一丁点现实主义。但是，嘿，这就是电影的目的，它是为了娱乐，而不是为了启示真实。
我对这部电影的史诗般的感觉感到非常惊讶。它轻松地超过了许多好莱坞制作的电影。我真的很喜欢它的CG特效、道具、布景、服装等等。虽然这部电影没有一丁点的真实感，但它在视觉效果和纯粹的赏心悦目方面弥补了这一点。
故事情节完全不切实际，但很有趣。《流浪地球》是一部非常、非常可预测的电影，在屏幕上展现出来之前你已经知道要发生什么了。但这个过于可预测的公式并不是电影的障碍。
《流浪地球》也拥有一个很好的演员团队，他们认真地刻画了角色。而这无疑使我能够更好地享受这部电影。
总得来说，《流浪地球》是个全方面让人喜欢的电影，我无比享受这部电影。我给它七分。

7/10
Quote: "If you drive unsafe your family will cry"

引用：“行车不规范，亲人两行泪。”

the_real_smile14 August 2019
"If you drive unsafe your family will cry", this is a line from the movie, I bet the original Chinese text was far better then this translation, but that's what we have to deal with. In stead of doing a decent job the translation is terrible, so with this movie you got the choice, go with the terrible dubbed English language or go for the far more terrible subtitles. So it is possible I watched a masterpiece, but never know because of the translation.
For the movie, the cgi is not bad, not great, but good enough. The actors, well I couldn't care if they live or die. The action, well, remember "Armageddon", there all the action scenes were great, but made no sense at all so unrealistic were they, This is the same, totally unbelievable actions but you should not care one bit of that. About stealing from other movies, it seams this movie has bits of every disaster movie from the last decades in it. Plot holes are also to many to name, if you are sensitive for that you definitely should not watch. Bottom line, if you want a brainless flick with much action and cgi, then this movie is for you.
22 out of 28 found this helpful.

“如果你开车不安全，你的家人会哭的”，这是电影中的一句台词，我打赌中文原文比这篇译文要好得多，而这是我们必须处理的问题。翻译不是很好，没有做好本土化，所以看这部电影时，你可以选择使用糟糕的配音英语，或者选择更糟糕的字幕。所以我有可能看了一部杰作，但因为翻译的原因我永远不得而知。
对于这部电影来说，CG特效不算差也不算好，但也足够用了。演员，好吧，我完全不在意他们是死了还是活着。动作，呃，想想《绝世天劫》，所有的动作都不错，但是没有一次是有意义的，这部电影也是一样，全部都是不可思议的动作戏但是你一点都不关心这些。说到从别的电影里面抄袭，看上去它有过去几十年每一部灾难片的影子。情节漏洞数不胜数，如果你对这个很敏感那么绝对不要去看。总之，如果你想看一部动作和CG特效都很丰富的无脑电影，那么这部电影适合你。

9/10
Epic Science Fiction Movie

史诗般的科幻电影

CJ_SciFi7 February 2019
Just watched the IMAX 3D movie. Trust me, don't do it any other way. Imagine ten of thousands of fusion thrusters are pushing our planet away from a dying sun on a IMAX screen. The visual effect is impressive and goes well with the story. The story is not everyday Hollywood style: Superhero saves the day; everyone else is there to give a round of applause. This movie brings a serious question to the audience: What are you gonna do facing an unavoidable, irresistible disaster to our civilization? All characters in the movie are ordinary people and everyone gives their answer with shining humanity. Against all the odds no one gives in without a good fight. The chance of success is close to zero but they choose hope. All the efforts add up and make impossible nothing. It is a Sci-Fi fan's feast you dont want to miss.
489 out of 841 found this helpful.

刚刚看了IMAX 3D版的电影。相信我，不要以任何其他方式观看它。想象一下，成千上万的核聚变推进器正在IMAX屏幕上将我们的星球从垂死的太阳附件推开。视觉效果令人印象深刻，与故事相得益彰。这个故事不是常见的好莱坞风格：超级英雄拯救了这一天，其他人都在那里鼓掌。这部电影向观众提了一个严肃的问题：面对我们文明不可避免的、不可抗拒的灾难，你打算怎么做？电影中的所有角色都是普通人，每个人都以闪亮的人性给出了答案。尽管困难重重，但没有人会在尚未抗争之前就屈服。成功的机会几乎为零，但他们选择了希望。所有的努力加起来，就没有不可能完成的事情。这是一场你不想错过的科幻迷盛宴。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处

3/10
Disappointing

失望

plasticteaspoon9 April 2019
Being a fan of Liu Cixin (three body trilogy) I wanted to like this movie but I found it impossible to do so. Bad acting, bad scxt, bad jokes, confusing plot, people who make stupid decisions because they love their family more than humanity, incorrect science, annoying characters, trying to make you cry about ten times at the end when I don't care about anyone in their stupid family. I'm still going to read the book though because I don't think it can be this bad. It is encouraging to see China try big movies like this but still a long way to go.
70 out of 102 found this helpful.

作为刘慈欣（《三体》）的粉丝，我想喜欢这部电影，但我发现做不到。糟糕的表演，糟糕的剧本，糟糕的笑话，混乱的情节，那些因为爱家人而不是人类所以做出愚蠢决定的人，错误的科学，令人讨厌的角色，试图让你哭十次但其实我不关心他们愚蠢的家庭中的任何一个人。不过我还是要读这本书，因为我觉得它不会这么糟糕。看到中国尝试这样的大型电影令人鼓舞，但仍有很长的路要走。

6/10
Not bad, but can be much better

不差，但是可以更好

y-1278110 February 2019
1. Background settings have great imagination. Very romantic in some way. (⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐) 2. Visual effects is wonderful (and made by Chinese, not easy) (⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐) 3. Plot not good. The director didn't handle to tell the story well. Rhythm is weird. Plot is not mind-catching. (⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐) 4. Ideas are too narrow. The main roles take family relation more seriously than human survival. And they didn't respect rules. (⭐⭐⭐) 5. Emotional expressions not natural. Lines are awkward. Too much 'tear points' but got little touching. (⭐⭐⭐⭐)
156 out of 243 found this helpful.

1.背景设置很有想象力。在某种程度上非常浪漫。（十星）
2.视觉效果很棒（而且是中国制造的，不容易）（九星）
3.情节不好。导演没有把故事讲好，节奏很奇怪，情节并不引人入胜。（五星）
4.观念太狭隘。主要角色比起人类生存更重视家庭关系，他们不尊重规则。（三星）
5.情感表达不自然。台词很别扭，太多的“泪点”却没有多少触动。（四星）

5/10
A typical Hollywood doomsday movie, but poorly acted

一部典型的好莱坞末日电影，但做得不行

heath-jeffrey11 February 201
The movie is groundbreaking for China in that the special effects are impressive and that it shows they can do sci-fi in design. Sadly, aside from that, there's not much to like about the movie.
To put into context first, Wandering Earth cannot be compared to a Marvel or DC Comics movie nor to most sci-fi movies: they are completely different genres and are much less likely to involve human cooperation. At it's core Wandering Earth is a 'doomsday' or 'disaster' movie. It should be compared to movies like: The Day After Tomorrow; Armageddon; Deep Impact; Outbreak; Contagion; etc.
In that context, Wandering Earth has a very basic, standard plot. The characters are similar, except exaggerated and over the top. Together, aside from the usual interdepartment and/or international disagreements and eventual cooperation that can be found in such disaster movies, the plot and characters sum up to: "Young, handsome rebel who hates his dad (unreasonably) and acts selfishly in all but the final moments ends up a hero".
The acting is weak. Character motivations are vague and often elaborated on only at the moment of death or near death (eg. through flashbacks), so there is no bonding with the characters on the way there. The main character swings back and forth between wanting to sacrifice all humanity to selfishly save his own friends and family (which would be very temporary) and wanting to sacrifice other people's lives to save all humanity. There is zero chance of ever feeling any connection or sympathy with that character. Potentially moving/touching moments are ruined by the way-too-obvious comedic relief characters (eg. watch someone important die, then laugh because the guy with white hair did something silly). The 'action' arc is "intro - climax - climax - climax - climax - climax - climax - conclusion" to the point that the climax just feels like it's dragging on and on.
Worst of all: There is an amazing sci-fi premise that is pulled off spectactularly with the special effects, but it amounts to nothing. It is the backdrop for just another disaster movie.
149 out of 233 found this helpful.

这部电影对中国来说是开创性的，因为它的特效令人印象深刻，这表明他们在技术上有能力做科幻。可悲的是，除此之外，这部电影没有太多值得喜欢的地方。
首先，《流浪地球》不能与漫威、DC漫画电影甚至大多数科幻电影相提并论：它们是完全不同的类型，这些电影不怎么涉及人类合作。《流浪地球》的核心是一部末日片或灾难片。它应该与以下电影进行比较：《后天》《绝世天劫》《彗星撞地球》《极度恐慌》《传染病》等。
在这种背景下，《流浪地球》有一个非常基本的、标准的情节。除了夸张和放大外，它们的角色都很相似。对比着看，在这样的灾难片中除了可以找到常见的部门间或国际的分歧以及最终的合作之外，情节和人物总结为：“年轻、英俊的叛逆者讨厌他的父亲（没有原因），除了最终时刻，其他所有时侯都自私地行事，最终成为了英雄”。
表演很差。角色的动机是模糊的，通常只在死亡或濒死的那一刻（比如通过闪回）进行详细描述，因此在进程中和角色没有共情。主人公在牺牲全人类自私地拯救自己的朋友和家人（这将是非常暂时的）与牺牲他们的生命来拯救全人类之间来回摇摆。你对这个角色没有任何共鸣或同情。太明显的喜剧角色破坏了潜在的泪点/燃点（比如，当看到一个重要人物死去时，因为这人有一头白发且做过一些傻事而大笑）。“行动”弧是“开场-高潮-高潮-高潮-高潮-高潮-高潮-高潮-结尾”，导致高潮像是在不断拖沓。
最糟糕的是：因为一个通过特效实现了神奇的科幻前提，但它并没有什么意义。它仅仅是一个灾难电影的背景。